[LUTE] Re: making a simple rose

2006-01-20 Thread Jon Murphy
Stewart, The rose has no real effect on the sound except as it releases the enclosed sound chamber. That is an incorrect statement, but it is close enough for government work. The guitar and most other lute family stringed instruments have merely the sound hol. But the lute does have a diffential

[LUTE] Re: making a simple rose

2006-01-20 Thread Nick Gravestock
A parchment or paper rose as on some early guitars might be easiest, though having cut roses on David Van Edwards Lute making course, it is not difficult, just slow and steady with the right tools - there is another course this summer - I don't know if there are any vacancies. Paul Baker of

[LUTE] Re: Question on Lute stringing

2006-01-20 Thread Jon Murphy
Nick, The exception that proves the rule. The basic answer is that 63cm is too long to comfortably tune to G at modern pitch A440. My flat-back is 63.5 cm VL, and I tune it to G. But there is no musical string that will hold that at that length. The closest is a nylon string, I've held G

[LUTE] Re: making a simple rose

2006-01-20 Thread Stuart Walsh
Many thanks for all the suggestions. I did try using some parchment - or that's what the craft shop called it. It just tore, even with a brand new scalpel blade. It was impossible to get any kind of clean line. I'll try, as suggested with some ordinary cardboard. Thanks again. To get on or

[LUTE] Re: Lute +clavichord

2006-01-20 Thread Roman Turovsky
Jurek Zak had been doing this on baroque lute. RT - Original Message - From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Friday, January 20, 2006 4:33 AM Subject: [LUTE] Lute +clavichord I have been reading about Jacob Herriman's duets wth lute and clavichord. This

[LUTE] Re: making a simple rose

2006-01-20 Thread Nick Gravestock
Aha! Your problem is your cutting method. A chisel point is required, not a slicing cut with a blade. Exacto do a chisel point blade that would do for parchment/paper, and probably cardboard. Small carving chisels thinned down without blueing the steel are best. These come in flats and various

[LUTE] Re: Question on Lute stringing

2006-01-20 Thread David Rastall
I beg to differ with you guys: On Jan 20, 2006, at 4:16 AM, Jon Murphy wrote: The basic answer is that 63cm is too long to comfortably tune to G at modern pitch A440. ...there is no musical string that will hold that at that length. I string my 66 cm Venere 10-course in G, using a

[LUTE] Re: Question on Lute stringing

2006-01-20 Thread Robert Clair
My flat-back is 63.5 cm VL, and I tune it to G. But there is no musical string that will hold that at that length. Another beautiful theory destroyed by ugly facts. We have two 65 cm ten course lutes (almost identical) and they are often kept at G (A440) with either nylon or nylgut

[LUTE] An American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Herbert Ward
Do Americans play lute with a distinctive accent? By this I mean: Suppose you took a good teacher with extensive experience in both American and Europe, and had him listen, blindfolded, to 10 American lutenists and 10 European lutenists. Could he pick out the Americans with any degree of

[LUTE] Re: Question on Lute stringing

2006-01-20 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear all, On Fri, 20 Jan 2006, David Rastall wrote: I string my 66 cm Venere 10-course in G, using a chanterelle of 0425 Pyramid nylon. I've never broken a chanterrelle yet. It works fine. It sounds just as good in G, with all the string gauges appropriately lighter than for F

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
I think you can not, POD and HS are both American, and completely different. PD -- Initial Header --- From : Herbert Ward [EMAIL PROTECTED] To : lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Cc : Date : Fri, 20 Jan 2006 08:06:46 -0600 (CST) Subject : [LUTE] An American

[LUTE] Re: An American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Taco Walstra
On Friday 20 January 2006 15:06, Herbert Ward wrote: Do Americans play lute with a distinctive accent? Oh yes sure, although only when they play from french tablature. Especially open strings and fourth position have distinct different accents. When both play Milano from Italian tablature there

[LUTE] Early 4-part lute playing

2006-01-20 Thread Arne Keller
Searching for something else in Music in the Renaissance by Gustave Reese, I happened to notice in the index one Heinrich (lutenist), mentioned by Tinctoris in his 12th treatise, De inventione et usu musicae, composed ca. 1484. Tinctoris writes about lute players: Others could play pieces not

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Herbert Ward
I think you can not, POD and HS are both American, and completely different. Do Americans play lute with a distinctive accent? I meant to ask the question with respect to ordinary lutenists like myself, and not gifted virtuosi like POD and HS, for whom I should be slow to say anything was

[LUTE] Re: 13c at ebay's

2006-01-20 Thread Mathias Rösel
It looks rather heavy, especially the rosette. Could it be an angelica as the subtitle on the Tielke picture reads? Hi Greet, have a closer look at the pictures! 5 bass courses on the exended neck, 8 courses on the fretboard qualifies as a typical German baroque lute setting, doesn't it.

[LUTE] Re: making a simple rose

2006-01-20 Thread Stuart Walsh
Nick Gravestock wrote: Aha! Your problem is your cutting method. A chisel point is required, not a slicing cut with a blade. Exacto do a chisel point blade that would do for parchment/paper, and probably cardboard. Small carving chisels thinned down without blueing the steel are best. These come

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Roman Turovsky
In fact, most top-flight players are American or Argentinian, with one Colombian exception. RT - Original Message - From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: ward2 [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: lute lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Friday, January 20, 2006 9:19 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute

[LUTE] Re: 13c at ebay's

2006-01-20 Thread Roman Turovsky
EastGerman, from the 60's, Wandervogel in disguise... RT - Original Message - From: Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lutelist lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Friday, January 20, 2006 1:27 PM Subject: [LUTE] 13c at ebay's To whom it concerns: Apparently, there is a 13c lute, swan

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Arto Wikla
On Fri, 20 Jan 2006, Roman Turovsky wrote: In fact, most top-flight players are American or Argentinian, with one Colombian exception. Well, ..., do not forget the Swedish one and also some from the islands to the west from Europe... And even on the continent - in the so called old Europe

[LUTE] Re: 13c at ebay's

2006-01-20 Thread Mathias Rösel
Roman Turovsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: EastGerman, how do you know? from the 60's, how do you...? Wandervogel in disguise... well, that one's for sure: no. Double courses, u-c. Could call it a nice try, though B) -- Cheers, Mathias http://de.geocities.com/mathiasroesel

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Roman Turovsky
Lets start the list, limited to REAL BIG TIME pros (geniuses included). Americans: Barto Smith POD Maginley Stubbs Herringman Burris Scheiderman Argentinians: Eguez, Abramovich Mascardi Costoyas Bosnia: Karamazov Colombia: Buraglia Italy: DÁgosto, Cicero, Contini Switzerland: Pianca Sweden:

[LUTE] Re: 13c at ebay's

2006-01-20 Thread Roman Turovsky
I almost bought one in 1986, from Noah Wolfe's store in NYC. Jerry Willard owns one, I suspect the one I didn't buy then. The bridge position is very WV like. RT - Original Message - From: Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Lutelist lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent:

[LUTE] Re: n American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Arto Wikla
On Fri, 20 Jan 2006, Roman Turovsky wrote: Lets start the list, limited to REAL BIG TIME pros (geniuses included). It would really be interesting to hear the list of geniuses by everyone in the list! :) I could not name anyone..., ..., just wait, ..., perhaps F. da Milano, J. Dowland, A. de

[LUTE] Re: Early 4-part lute playing

2006-01-20 Thread demery
On Fri, Jan 20, 2006, Arne Keller [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Tinctoris mentions a German, Heinrich, recently in the service of Charles the Bold, as one of them. (MitR. p.148). Charles was killed in 1477. So this is pretty early for 4-part lute-playing, don't you think? May have been Hayne

[LUTE] Re: An American accent in lute playing?

2006-01-20 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
FWIW -- I recall overhearing a remark at some festival, after solo recitals by Paul O'Dette and Nigel North, that POD was kind of a gringo. -Original Message- From: Herbert Ward [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, January 20, 2006 8:07 AM To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: [LUTE] An

[LUTE] Re: Early 4-part lute playing

2006-01-20 Thread Michal Gondko
Others could play pieces not only a 2 but also a 3 or a 4 - a difficult feat. Tinctoris mentions a German, Heinrich, recently in the service of Charles the Bold, as one of them. (MitR. p.148). He was Henri Bouclers, he appears in the Burgundian court's payment records since 1468,