[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-18 Thread David van Ooijen
One detail that jumps out at me is the fruit bowl. It's a Chinese bowl, with calligraphy on the side. There was a great demand for China wares, made in China and Japan, in the West. There was a whole industry set up which made their wares specifically for the Western markets. With different

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-17 Thread Edward C. Yong
One detail that jumps out at me is the fruit bowl. It's a Chinese bowl, with calligraphy on the side. Of course, Chinoiserie was in fashion, and much faux-Chinese porcelain was produced in Europe, but I don't think much (if any) was produced with calligraphy on them. That would have been

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-17 Thread Leonard Williams
tempted to guess some sort of cheese, but the contents look a bit.. bubbly. I think it must be caramel coated pop-corn, or perhaps Cracker-Jacks. Regards, Leonard Williams On 2/17/10 4:59 AM, Edward C. Yong ky...@pacific.net.sg wrote: One detail that jumps out at me is the fruit bowl.

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-17 Thread demery
I think it must be caramel coated pop-corn, or perhaps Cracker-Jacks. nope, gotta be crunch n munch One detail that jumps out at me is the fruit bowl. It's a Chinese bowl, with calligraphy on the side. possibly purchased or a gift from traders with the 15c fleet bearing a chinese ambassador

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-16 Thread Nicolás Valencia
Thanks to all for your interesting insights and amusing comments on this curious painting. Best, Nicolás To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-16 Thread Sean Smith
Thanks for sending in the photo, Alexander. I think this is an important lute for the archives showing a good transitional solution. ... and a lute I wouldn't mind finding on my dining room table. The music is very legible, too. I'm sorry I don't know enough song rep to figure it out.

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Franz Mechsner
Hi, Wasting some time one may collect tons of strange lutes from the internet in many variations, the most strange one I found so far is this: Try [1]http://www.klassiskgitar.net/imagesr1.html I am refering to the the Painting Young Lady with Lute by Racinet which might

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread David Tayler
I find the oboe the most interesting :) dt At 10:59 PM 2/14/2010, you wrote: Count 'em again, folks- I'm counting 7 courses on the main pegbox. Treble rider, and 12 more pegs. I've got three courses- 6 pegs on the extension, the bottom one looks like a darker wood replacement (ebony?) -So we have

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Franz Mechsner
: Strange lute in French painting Hi, Wasting some time one may collect tons of strange lutes from the internet in many variations, the most strange one I found so far is this: Try [1][3]http://www.klassiskgitar.net/imagesr1.html I am refering to the the Painting

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Franz Mechsner
__ Von: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu im Auftrag von Gernot Hilger Gesendet: Mo 15.02.2010 10:51 An: Franz Mechsner Cc: Steve Ramey; lute Betreff: [LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting Hi Franz, the instrument in this pic is of course not a lute

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Gernot Hilger
I tried to find what the strange object under the bird might be. I believe it is a musette de cour with the chanter removed. There is a similar picture here: http://music.geocities.jp/muzettes/EngFile/main_eng/pictures_diag/hotteterre_musette.gif I have asked David Van Edwards for his

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Sean Smith
An archcittern, Gernot? That broken chanterelle curls like gut to my eye. Sean On Feb 15, 2010, at 1:51 AM, Gernot Hilger wrote: Hi Franz, the instrument in this pic is of course not a lute, but an archcittern. Looks like a Hamburger Cithrinchen with extended bass range. Gernot

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Christopher Stetson
It is of course a cittern, but it was also painted (drawn?) no earlier than 1850 judging from the artist's dates, so may be no more than a fantasy of olden times composed of elements from other visual sources. My first guess would be that the instrument never actually physically

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Gernot Hilger
Dear Sean, unless I am very much mistaken, you are speaking of the Linard Vanitas. I was referring to the pic Franz had linked to. The other picture is too small to see any chanterelle. Or do you once again have a mousepad with better resolution by any chance? Gernot Zitat von Sean Smith

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Sean Smith
So it is. Racinet's is certainly a citterncreature. Sean On Feb 15, 2010, at 5:43 AM, Gernot Hilger wrote: Dear Sean, unless I am very much mistaken, you are speaking of the Linard Vanitas. I was referring to the pic Franz had linked to. The other picture is too small to see any

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
David Van Edwards has of course nailed the lute perfectly- there is a picture of one being played about 1/3 way down on this page (Brief history of the lute, part 3) from his website, between the Des Moulins 11 course and the better known double headed Dutch lute.

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
It's down at the bottom, next to what appears to be a plate on edge; dangerously close to the parsnips. It appears that the bell is of a different wood than the body; and on the whole it somewhat resembles an extraordinary oboe played extraordinarily well by Gonzalo X. Ruiz a few weeks ago-

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Nedmast2
Aside from the issue of musical instruments, there seem to be some odd perspective relationships going on in the painting. Examples: the basket of fruit at the top right sitting on a wood 'cabinet', the drawer of the table in relation to the cabinet and the table itself, the bowl

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Nancy Carlin
While we are picking through this - I see what looks like a lemon and an orange. Is the other piece of fruit supposed to be a pomegranite? And what is the silver cylinder near the bell of the oboe? Nancy At 10:55 AM 2/15/2010, Daniel Winheld wrote: It's down at the bottom,

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread G. Crona
Oboe? I'd think pestle mortar :) G. - Original Message - From: Daniel Winheld dwinh...@comcast.net To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Monday, February 15, 2010 7:55 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting It's down at the bottom, next to what appears to be a plate

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
Maybe it's both (Emergency at the oboe players house- Honey, could you stop practicing for a minute and come grind this garlic?) Oboe? I'd think pestle mortar :) -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread howard posner
I think David was kidding about the oboe (hence the :) sign). The objects Dan describes do not resemble any oboe da caccia I've seen. The goldish-colored oboe part looks like a pestle, and the similarly-colored round object is more than likely the mortar or similar dish. It can't be the bell

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
Damn it, I want to see Gonzalo's oboe again. The last time we had parsnips they were much too tough, and the finger holes didn't help a bit. I think David was kidding about the oboe (hence the :) sign). The objects Dan describes do not resemble any oboe da caccia I've seen. The

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Steve Ramey
Winheld dwinh...@comcast.net To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Mon, February 15, 2010 1:55:24 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting It's down at the bottom, next to what appears to be a plate on edge; dangerously close to the parsnips. It appears that the bell

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Sean Smith
What kind of glue are you using on those parsnips? Remember, the organic ones need longer clamping time. s On Feb 15, 2010, at 11:45 AM, Daniel Winheld wrote: Damn it, I want to see Gonzalo's oboe again. The last time we had parsnips they were much too tough, and the finger holes didn't

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
No reason parsnips and woodwinds can't get along: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpfYt7vRHuY -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Daniel Winheld
Maybe one more hour on simmer, and a few shakes from the cyanide jar Nancy spotted. Bon Apetit! :( Funny- I do have a dentist appointment in one hour! -Dan I don't think an oboe da caccia would be any easier on your teeth, but I suppose it would depend on how you cook it. -- To get on

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread wikla
What is the notated piece under the lute head and recorder? Isn't there any photo with more pixels than that http://www.wga.hu/art/l/linard/senses.jpg Arto To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Leonard Williams
Could the bird-like object actually be a feathers arranged on a wire (visible extending down and to the right from the bird body) used for cleaning the musette pipes? Also, does anyone recognize the music? It's not in tab. The other Lady With Lute that Franz found seems more like a cittern

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-15 Thread Alexander Batov
What always puzzled me in this picture is that some of the frets (which seem to appear to be double ...?), starting from the third, look as a kind of 'split' from the middle and down towards the edge of the neck. The painter didn't 'confirm' this feature in the mirror reflection of the neck,

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Nancy Carlin
I think one of the most interesting things about this picture is the cord with the loop going along the back of the instrument. Also the decoration along the top edge of the sides is something we fon't see in this century. Nancy At 07:31 PM 2/14/2010, Nicolas Valencia wrote:

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Ed Durbrow
On Feb 15, 2010, at 12:31 PM, Nicolas Valencia wrote: I've found this lute in a painting by Jacques Linard, (France, 1600-1645). It's called The Five Senses and the Four Elements, so I guess the lute represents hearing. What kind of lute is this?

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread EUGENE BRAIG IV
: Nancy Carlin na...@nancycarlinassociates.com Date: Sunday, February 14, 2010 11:58 pm Subject: [LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu    I think one of the most interesting things about this picture is the    cord with the loop going along the back

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Steve Ramey
of sausage stuffer??? Just my two cents or less... Steve __ From: Ed Durbrow edurb...@sea.plala.or.jp To: LuteNet list lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Mon, February 15, 2010 12:14:00 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Strange lute

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Sean Smith
I counted up the pegs and got a 9-c lute: treble rider (w/ broken chanterelle)+ 6 courses on the main pegbox and 2 doubled courses on the extension. Otoh, it might be 3 doubled courses on the extension making it a 10-c, tho. 10 frets on the neck. Fitting for the time and perfect for

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Sean Smith
Something else comes to mind about the curious pegboxes. If one was updating a 6-c for 9/10 courses, it would make sense to reuse the old 6-c pegbox. That would explain the different angles. Yes, the neck would be new as would be the extension pegbox but why remake the other pegbox if it

[LUTE] Re: Strange lute in French painting

2010-02-14 Thread Daniel Winheld
Count 'em again, folks- I'm counting 7 courses on the main pegbox. Treble rider, and 12 more pegs. I've got three courses- 6 pegs on the extension, the bottom one looks like a darker wood replacement (ebony?) -So we have a 10 course. There is a Dutch picture of a young man playing one of these