Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Ted Cooper
On 08/12/17 01:17, Ken O'Driscoll wrote: > On Thu, 2017-12-07 at 14:50 +0100, David Hofstee wrote: >> Hi, >> >> Can people here share their experience (or spamfilter configuration) with >> differing 5322.From and 5322.Reply-To domains in larger volumes of >> email? > > Completely agree with

Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Grant Taylor via mailop
On 12/07/2017 06:50 AM, David Hofstee wrote: Can people here share their experience (or spamfilter configuration) with differing 5322.>From and 5322.Reply-To domains in larger volumes of email? Is it a problem, if so, where? If it is a problem, are there requirements so that legitimate email

Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Al Iverson
Where I see freemail addresses in the reply-to in valid mail is in various mailing list platforms, ones that work around DMARC blocking by rewriting the from, then moving the original poster's email address to the reply-to, to allow for off-list replies. Not so much that I'm looking to argue

Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Ken O'Driscoll
On Thu, 2017-12-07 at 14:50 +0100, David Hofstee wrote: > Hi, > > Can people here share their experience (or spamfilter configuration) with > differing 5322.From and 5322.Reply-To domains in larger volumes of > email? Completely agree with Vladimir and Al, it's common practice. The only

Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Al Iverson
Yeah, lots of ESPs, list management tools, and ticketing systems can be and often are configured to use a different reply-to address, sometimes in a totally different domain. We have a fair number of clients who do this today and they don't experience any deliverability or filtering issues that we

Re: [mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread Vladimir Dubrovin via mailop
You should never do it, having different e-mails in From: and Reply-To, including ones from different domains, is a common practice. E.g., mailing lists like this can change From or Reply-To, most probably the message you read right now has From and Reply-To from different domains. 07.12.2017

[mailop] Different From domain and Reply-To domain

2017-12-07 Thread David Hofstee
Hi, Can people here share their experience (or spamfilter configuration) with differing 5322.From and 5322.Reply-To domains in larger volumes of email? Is it a problem, if so, where? If it is a problem, are there requirements so that legitimate email is accepted? Any info and opinions on this is