Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-23 Thread c b
You've demonstrated a certain special symbiosis between human and canine populations through history. It seems that just as humans have gotten into feuds and wars between each other, so have some human and canine populations fallen out at various levels. Maybe, when humans are hunters, canine

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-21 Thread c b
On 4/16/10, CeJ wrote: Well, same genus (smile). They can't interbreed, which defines a species. Actually you could cross a toy dog with a wolf and get viable offspring. CB: Yes, you are correct. Evidently, doesn't have to be a toy dog. By the way, the test of intra-species is

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-21 Thread CeJ
Name highly intelligent social species that organize as groups and cooperate to protect three successive generations in extended families and clans (one key aspect being nurturing fathers in addition to nurturing mothers). Humans and wolves come to mind. But isn't even more fascinating that these

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-15 Thread CeJ
And here we see the co-evolution of gesturing. Humans have gestures, wolves have gestures, but wolves do not understand human gestures. However, dogs do. The example of the dingo is most illuminating: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dingo#Social_behavior Other forms of communication During

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-15 Thread CeJ
This is an absolutely fascinating page about wolves and other wolf-like canines. What strikes me most when reading it, is that the sheer utter success of the wolves and coyotes in being top-predator in all the places that humans eventually got to. It also shows me I know very little about wolves,

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-15 Thread CeJ
Tie these two sets of information together, and we might be able to theorize some plausible scenarios for Neanderthal extinction. When you look at Neanderthal vs. Cro Magnon, you have to ask why in particular Cro Magnon survives and carries on the human line, but Neanderthals go extinct. One

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-15 Thread c b
On 4/14/10, Carrol Cox cb...@ilstu.edu wrote: I like a speculation by the aughor of The Monkey in the Mirror (I forget his name just now) as to the origin of language. First, he assumes (which seems right to me) that the cpacity for language was a spandrel, not a trait in itself seleced for.

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-14 Thread CeJ
I wrote:However, as the canine research and speculation gets at: apes are pretty much socially selfish and have no extended social sense. Moreover, their grasp of meaningful gesture is less than canines. This could be a weakness in the argument if it could be shown that great apes do organize

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-14 Thread CeJ
A couple more things about wolves, coyotes and dingoes. The wolf pack in the wild tends to be an extended family group, but it is also important to remember it is across several generations. Second, a new pack of any of these species is formed between unrelated animals, most usually a male and

[Marxism-Thaxis] Wolves were the first communists, or why canines taught hominids how to be social

2010-04-13 Thread CeJ
If our predecessors developed full-blown spoken language (from gesture to speech) while 'domesticating' dogs (from wolves), perhaps we need to reconsider the possibilties for co-evolution, with one result being full-blown language for humans. Consider that wolves have a more complex social