Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread Randy Bennell
On 01/06/2012 1:56 PM, Rick Knoble wrote: On Jun 1, 2012, at 12:32 PM, rdeaf...@aol.com wrote: Even my bodyshop friend said that I saved over 2 grand on the work I did .Strokes does many wonders !! I'll pass on the stroke, thanks. Rick Who sometimes IS a stroke... Sent from my iPhone T

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread Rick Knoble
On Jun 1, 2012, at 12:32 PM, rdeaf...@aol.com wrote: > Even my bodyshop friend said that I saved over 2 grand > on the work I did .Strokes does many wonders !! I'll pass on the stroke, thanks. Rick Who sometimes IS a stroke... Sent from my iPhone ___ http

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread RDeafBoy
"Miracle Paint" . When I could not temporarily drive due to my stroke,I repaired 5 rust holes following Bergsma's Rust repair manual. 3 years later it still looks new. Even my bodyshop friend said that I saved over 2 grand on the work I did .Strokes does many wonders !! Buy the Miracl

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread Curt Raymond
012 06:03:29 -0700 From: G Mann To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore? Message-ID: Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 At $308. each, that only accounts for 3 shop hours at a decent body shop. 3 hrs to repair, to paint standard, a rusty fender,

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread Randy Bennell
Try POR. Randy On 31/05/2012 6:34 PM, Allan Streib wrote: If I had the time and motivation, I'd try removing the fenders, using the electrolytic method to get rid of the rust, then repair or fill as needed. Wire brushing and topical rust "removers" do not approach what I've seen the electroly

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-06-01 Thread G Mann
Behalf Of Dan Penoff > > Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:50 PM > > To: Mercedes Discussion List > > Subject: Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore? > > > > 123 fenders used to be cheap as wine. Check with the Q. > > > > Dan > > > > On May 31,

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dimitri Seretakis
It those establishments were autobody shops then being reputable will not change anything. Body shops have no idea how to correctly repair rust. It needs to be taken to a high end restoration shop. Any other alternative besides doing it yourself in a skilled manner will surely lead to disappoint

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Allan Streib
If I had the time and motivation, I'd try removing the fenders, using the electrolytic method to get rid of the rust, then repair or fill as needed. Wire brushing and topical rust "removers" do not approach what I've seen the electrolytic conversion do. Instructions are somewhere on Jim Cathey's

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread G. M. Brown
Since I intend for my '84 300D to be my last car and last me the rest of my days, I replaced the RF & LR fenders in '09 after finding rust that I was convinced would spread. I've had rust "repaired" in the past by reputable establishments only for rust to reappear a couple years later. Even i

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Scott Ritchey
strasfogel Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:06 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore? We are thinking of repainting her 1985 300CD. It has some rust in both front fenders, esp. the passenger side. Would it be less costly to 1) buy and install (relatively)

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dieselhead
How bad is the rust? Big rust would require lots of shop time to fix, and sourcing fresh fender might be less costly. Second the new fender. I have not priced a fender for a 123 lately, but give Q a chance. Last I knew 124 fenders and 126 fenders were just a little over $100 each. 123 no

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Craig
On Thu, 31 May 2012 14:37:02 -0700 (PDT) Dimitri Seretakis wrote: > If rust can be repaired properly without removing fender then I'd opt > for that. Fender removal means removal of that undercoating stuff which > is a job in itself. MB stopped using the seam sealer somewhere around '82. Our '82

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Craig
On Thu, 31 May 2012 17:33:20 -0400 Dan Penoff wrote: > They use some nasty seam sealer on the top edge. You have to use a heat > gun or a torch to soften it up. They stopped using that somewhere around 1982 on W123s. Our '82 240D/3.0 was built without the seam sealer and the fenders are easy to

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dimitri Seretakis
If rust can be repaired properly without removing fender then I'd opt for that. Fender removal means removal of that undercoating stuff which is a job in itself. That might also predispose to future rust if not prepped and re- undercoated properly. Sent from my iPhone On May 31, 2012, at 4:17

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dan Penoff
They use some nasty seam sealer on the top edge. You have to use a heat gun or a torch to soften it up. Dan On May 31, 2012, at 5:32 PM, Randy Bennell wrote: > Are these glued on? I seem to recall some reference to difficulties changing > MB fenders because they are bolted and glued on. > >

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dan Penoff
pping is a bear. >> >> -Original Message- >> From: mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com [mailto:mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com] >> On Behalf Of Dan Penoff >> Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:50 PM >> To: Mercedes Discussion List >> Subject: Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replac

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Randy Bennell
Are these glued on? I seem to recall some reference to difficulties changing MB fenders because they are bolted and glued on. Randy On 31/05/2012 3:17 PM, clay monroe wrote: How bad is the rust? Big rust would require lots of shop time to fix, and sourcing fresh fender might be less costly.

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread andrew strasfogel
2012 4:50 PM > To: Mercedes Discussion List > Subject: Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore? > > 123 fenders used to be cheap as wine. Check with the Q. > > Dan > > On May 31, 2012, at 4:06 PM, andrew strasfogel > wrote: > >> We are thinking of repaint

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Rusty Cullens
They are $308.00 but shipping is a bear. -Original Message- From: mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com [mailto:mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com] On Behalf Of Dan Penoff Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:50 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore? 123

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Dan Penoff
123 fenders used to be cheap as wine. Check with the Q. Dan On May 31, 2012, at 4:06 PM, andrew strasfogel wrote: > We are thinking of repainting her 1985 300CD. It has some rust in > both front fenders, esp. the passenger side. Would it be less costly > to 1) buy and install (relatively) rus

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread clay monroe
How bad is the rust? Big rust would require lots of shop time to fix, and sourcing fresh fender might be less costly. PnP fender should be very inexpensive. Still lots of shop time to prep for paint and mounting. Probably same a for a new made fender. Maaco paint job with fix would be least

Re: [MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread Randy Bennell
No, no, no --- This is where you get to justify buying the mig welder, the air compressor etc. DIY! Randy On 31/05/2012 3:06 PM, andrew strasfogel wrote: We are thinking of repainting her 1985 300CD. It has some rust in both front fenders, esp. the passenger side. Would it be less costly to

[MBZ] 123 fenders - replace or restore?

2012-05-31 Thread andrew strasfogel
We are thinking of repainting her 1985 300CD. It has some rust in both front fenders, esp. the passenger side. Would it be less costly to 1) buy and install (relatively) rust-free used fenders; or 2) have the body shop repair the existing ones? ___ http://www.