Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-30 Thread Mike Larkin
On Sun, Mar 29, 2015 at 11:55:49AM +0400, Denis Lapshin wrote: Since 4.9 till current 8510p/w read acpi temp with error (enormous high temp about 2000-5000 C) because SMBus data is not ready for reading. It seems data reading should be delayed. I thought we(I) fixed this last year. If you

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-29 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2015-03-29, Denis Lapshin den...@mindall.org wrote: The machine is DCS6005. This is an old Dell branded AMD based server node. They named it as Cloud Server Node or something like that. It has AST2050 installed. I would like to buy some for a project, but not sure that OpenBSD support

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-29 Thread Theo de Raadt
Since 4.9 till current 8510p/w read acpi temp with error (enormous high temp about 2000-5000 C) because SMBus data is not ready for reading. It seems data reading should be delayed. Theo, you told that you don't want to implement shit in CVS repository. Most of ACPI code should be rewritten in

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-29 Thread Denis Lapshin
Since 4.9 till current 8510p/w read acpi temp with error (enormous high temp about 2000-5000 C) because SMBus data is not ready for reading. It seems data reading should be delayed. Theo, you told that you don't want to implement shit in CVS repository. Most of ACPI code should be rewritten

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-29 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2015/03/29 11:55, Denis Lapshin wrote: Since 4.9 till current 8510p/w read acpi temp with error (enormous high temp about 2000-5000 C) because SMBus data is not ready for reading. It seems data reading should be delayed. Theo, you told that you don't want to implement shit in CVS

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-29 Thread Denis Lapshin
The machine is DCS6005. This is an old Dell branded AMD based server node. They named it as Cloud Server Node or something like that. It has AST2050 installed. I would like to buy some for a project, but not sure that OpenBSD support ACPI tables of this machine properly. Because of negative

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-28 Thread Denis Lapshin
I'm sorry, but the question have sense. Using HP 8510p for four years with OpenBSD, I have a great trouble with reading SMBUS (data ready on it) for years. Every release I need to apply a patch after upgrade for reading ACPII data from 8510p in time, to prevent wrong data on SMBUS. Theo

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-28 Thread Theo de Raadt
Every release I need to apply a patch after upgrade for reading ACPII data from 8510p in time, to prevent wrong data on SMBUS. Theo replied that the patch will not be implemented in CVS because all ACPI must be rewritten in new manner. But they will do nothing since my last report... I doubt I

Re: ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-28 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2015-03-28, Denis Lapshin den...@mindall.org wrote: Hi, Has OpenBSD implemented ACPI for Aspeed AST2050 in current or release? The question doesn't really make sense, ACPI is a method where the manufacturer can supply a set of BIOS tables with instructions about how to route interrupts,

ACPI implementation for Aspeed AST2050

2015-03-28 Thread Denis Lapshin
Hi, Has OpenBSD implemented ACPI for Aspeed AST2050 in current or release? This IC is present in some Dell branded Tyan products like DCS6005 cloud nodes and some other Tyan MBs. Seems Aspeed its their own product because these ICs can be found on all Tyan server mainboards as I can see.