Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread MarshaV
That's interesting. On May 7, 2011, at 9:19 AM, X Acto wrote: I think to group reification with conceptualization is confusing the meaning of both terms leading to inaccuracies. - Original Message From: MarshaV val...@att.net To: moq_disc...@moqtalk.org

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread Steven Peterson
Craig, On Sat, May 7, 2011 at 11:53 PM, craig...@comcast.net wrote: [Pirsig] To say that A causes B or to say that B values precondition A is to say the same thing. The difference is one of words only. Instead of saying A magnet causes iron filings to move toward it, you can say Iron

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread david buchanan
Steve said to Dan: Since the Cartesian self is denied, the free will is denied since there is no autonomous agent to posses the faculty known as free will. dmb says: I'm not so sure it follows. Does the denial of the Cartesian self also entail the denial of agency? It seems to me that freedom

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread MarshaV
Marsha: In the MoQ, causation is replaced by preference, but it is still a pattern or an explanatory extension of a pattern. On May 8, 2011, at 10:52 AM, david buchanan wrote: Steve said to Dan: Since the Cartesian self is denied, the free will is denied since there is no autonomous

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread Dan Glover
Hello everyone On Sat, May 7, 2011 at 10:53 AM, Steven Peterson peterson.st...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Dan, Steve: I think Pirsig's interpretation of causality as B values precondition A renders the whole question of free will versus determinism moot for MOQers. At least it should. Choices are

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-08 Thread John Carl
Dan and Dave, Perfection in MoQ terms is easy to conceptualize and define. It's peace of mind. That's all. Dan: Well, again, if you wish to believe in perfection, then believe in perfection. Don't let me stop you. John: For some people, peace of mind is easy. For others its very hard.

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-08 Thread craigerb
[Pirsig] To say that A causes B or to say that B values precondition A is to say the same thing. The difference is one of words only. Instead of saying A magnet causes iron filings to move toward it, you can say Iron filings value movement toward a magnet. In Iron filings value movement toward a

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-08 Thread John Carl
Ok, one more point Dan, since I had to leave some previous dialogue behind... David: I disagree that static patterns evolve towards Dynamic Quality. Dan: Then you disagree with the MOQ: ...Phaedrus wrote on one of his slips, It seems clear that no mechanistic pattern exists toward

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-08 Thread Dan Glover
Hello everyone On Sun, May 8, 2011 at 9:09 PM, John Carl ridgecoy...@gmail.com wrote: Ok, one more point Dan, since I had to leave some previous dialogue behind... David: I disagree that static patterns evolve towards Dynamic Quality. Dan: Then you disagree with the MOQ: ...Phaedrus

[MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-08 Thread 118
Hey John, wherever you are, Freedom is a rig full of gas, a wide open road, a stack of audio CDs, and some sweet rock and roll. Oh, yeah, and truck stops full of coffee. Just watch out for the ones full of Vampires... Let me know what you find On the Road, I am interested. Mark Moq_Discuss