Re: [MD] Spiritual snake oil?

2014-04-25 Thread John Carl
Hi Joe, Definable in life, indefinable in philosophy is a common occurrence. Philosophy in general and metaphysics in particular are unusual activities with rigourous rules so while Quality is indefinable philosophically, everybody knows what is good and what is not. John On Thu, Apr 24, 2014

[MD] Followers of James and Dewey

2014-04-25 Thread John Carl
... pragmatists in the James-Dewey temper will have to learn *difficult*philosophy, something they have successfully avoided doing for about three generations, through disinclination, dullness of mind, and uninformed superstitions about the role of reason in philosophy. The inheritors of the

Re: [MD] Followers of James and Dewey

2014-04-25 Thread Ian Glendinning
Don't know Auxier, but that is entertaining. Thanks John. Ian On Fri, Apr 25, 2014 at 3:39 PM, John Carl ridgecoy...@gmail.com wrote: ... pragmatists in the James-Dewey temper will have to learn *difficult*philosophy, something they have successfully avoided doing for about three generations,

Re: [MD] Followers of James and Dewey

2014-04-25 Thread John Carl
Hi Ian, On Fri, Apr 25, 2014 at 9:16 AM, Ian Glendinning ian.glendinn...@gmail.comwrote: Don't know Auxier, but that is entertaining. Thanks John. Ian Randall E. Auxier is a scholar, writer and philosopher with few peers, in my personal pantheon. I'm also honored to consider him a friend as

Re: [MD] Spiritual snake oil?

2014-04-25 Thread Joseph Maurer
Hi John, Metaphysics is not omniphysics. There must be secure borders in reality or evolution is meaningless. The rigor of metaphysical logic has always been in dispute. Dispute and clarification follow different pathways Joe On 4/25/14 7:22 AM, John Carl ridgecoy...@gmail.com wrote:

Re: [MD] Spiritual snake oil?

2014-04-25 Thread John Carl
Joe, there must be borders, I agree but what security you find in them is your own business. I don't see any hard and fast lines drawn in nature. John Ps: omniphysics I like - very clever. On Fri, Apr 25, 2014 at 12:31 PM, Joseph Maurer jh...@comcast.net wrote: Hi John, Metaphysics is