Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-20 Thread MarshaV
Great thinkers think alike... On Jul 20, 2011, at 4:20 AM, Andre Broersen wrote: Marsha to Andre: In the MoQ Texbook Anthony writes that the fundamental nature of the static is the Dynamic:... Andre: So? What point are you making? Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo,

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-20 Thread Ian Glendinning
:-) On Wed, Jul 20, 2011 at 9:28 AM, MarshaV val...@att.net wrote: Great thinkers think alike... On Jul 20, 2011, at 4:20 AM, Andre Broersen wrote: Marsha to Andre: In the MoQ Texbook Anthony writes that the fundamental nature of the static is the Dynamic:... Andre: So? What point

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-20 Thread Andre Broersen
Marsha to Andre: Great thinkers think alike... Andre: After celebrity status are we? This is a philosophical forum Marsha, not a popularity contest. Evasion yet again. Delete forever. Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-19 Thread MarshaV
Andre, In the MoQ Texbook Anthony writes that the fundamental nature of the static is the Dynamic: Moreover, Nagarjuna (1966, p.251) shares Pirsig’s perception that the indeterminate (or Dynamic) is the fundamental nature of the conditioned (or static:. In their ultimate nature things

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-19 Thread MarshaV
Andre, This seems an interesting way to change the subject of free-will determinism without dmb conceding to Steve's argument. Marsha On Jul 19, 2011, at 3:37 AM, Andre Broersen wrote: Andre to Dave: Just another insert Dave. When I talked about Leave it in the weather for a

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-17 Thread MarshaV
On Jul 17, 2011, at 2:03 PM, Andre Broersen wrote: Marsha to dmb: You sure don't know... Ad hominem attacks, and you say she says he says are the best you can do. backing up her: ... Of freewill, determinism and causation, I neither accept them nor reject them. They are static

Re: [MD] [Bulk] Re: The Quality of Free Will

2011-07-17 Thread Andre Broersen
Marsha to Andre: Why would I debate a non-issue? I'll leave it for those want to take a som point-of-view. Andre: See what I mean? You are so predictable. Heroshima and Nagasaki a som issue? You do not add anything Marsha...you only detract. You may think you are sooo deep but you represent