Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Socialist2001
This is one of the rare occasions where I agree with everything in a post that Michael Atherton wrote. I think that the following 2 points should be emphasized: In a message dated 6/15/2003 5:05:21 PM Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > > Eli Kaplan wrote: > > > Please do not

Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Anderson & Turpin
David Brauer wrote: Based on what I know of SLCs, Jim Grathwol is right. A kid chooses a medical magnet at Roosevelt - yes, a lot of the learning is applied through a medical metaphor. But the kid is no more locked into a medical career than anyone else. It just means they learn concepts better t

Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Rosalind Nelson
badly run that parents, students, and teachers are all miserable. Rosalind Nelson Bancroft neighborhood Craig Miller wrote: > > Subject: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS > > It is always interesting to see how parents perceive changes in the school > district regarding

RE: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Michael Atherton
Eli Kaplan wrote: > Please do not prejudge any program or MPS because you may not > have all the facts about the situation. Statistics can be geared > to show anything. Talk with the kids about their experiences. Bad statistics can be geared to show anything, valid statistical techniques c

Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Craig Miller
Subject: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS It is always interesting to see how parents perceive changes in the school district regarding learning styles and quote the "SLC" curriculum. Do you all know Barton School and its reputation today. Barton is classified as an o

[Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-15 Thread Eli
It is always interesting to see how parents perceive changes in the school district regarding learning styles and quote the "SLC" curriculum. Do you all know Barton School and its reputation today. Barton is classified as an open school and a merger between Lake Harriet Open School (Fulton Open)

RE: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-13 Thread Michelle Gross
At 07:23 PM 6/12/03 -0500, David Brauer wrote: With that in mind, I'd like to invite list parents with kids IN SLCs to comment on Julie Quist's charges that SLCs are too vocationally oriented and career-tracking. (I'm especially interested to hear from parents with kids not in an IB or Liberal Art

RE: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-13 Thread David Brauer
> David Brauer wrote: > > > Before I get into some specifics, I made a rule long before > > my kids started in the Minneapolis Public School system: only > > listen to those with kids IN the school system. The rest of us > > can more easily have our ideological axes to grind, but parents > > with

Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-13 Thread Socialist2001
In a message dated 6/12/2003 7:24:18 PM Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > > Before I get into some specifics, I made a rule long before my kids started > in the Minneapolis Public School system: only listen to those with kids IN > the school system. The rest of us can more ea

RE: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-12 Thread Michael Atherton
David Brauer wrote: > Before I get into some specifics, I made a rule long before > my kids started in the Minneapolis Public School system: only > listen to those with kids IN the school system. The rest of us > can more easily have our ideological axes to grind, but parents > with kids find

RE: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-12 Thread David Brauer
First, I share Julie Quist's concerns that education will be subsumed to the workplace, and that liberal arts are in peril. However, I think many of her specific charges are hyperbolic readings of an intelligent program. Before I get into some specifics, I made a rule long before my kids started

Re: [Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-12 Thread Socialist2001
In a message dated 6/12/2003 9:09:24 AM Central Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Julie Quist) writes: > > So what is the overall effect of the MPS career > system? The Minneapolis SLC system results in an > education in which our children will not be educated > beyond their station in life.

[Mpls] Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS

2003-06-12 Thread MREdCo
Re: Career Pathways for 8th Graders in MPS Dear Mr. Grathwol, In your June 8th letter to Senator Higgins you state that "no one [Mpls student] chooses a career pathway" and that Mpls "does not force students to choose careers in 8th grade." Your statements are simply not true. Th