Bogdan Butnaru wrote:
On 4/25/06, Simon Reinhardt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
- change "Release is a live performance of Release", "Release was performed live
as Release" to "Release has later recording(s) Release", "Release is a later
recording
of Release" and update the one case using the live
On 4/25/06, Simon Reinhardt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> - change "Release is a live performance of Release", "Release was performed
> live
> as Release" to "Release has later recording(s) Release", "Release is a later
> recording
> of Release" and update the one case using the live stuff since t
Hey,
so to sum it up:
Bogdan said {live} and {acoustic} make not much sense in the relationship since
they should be track attributes and I agree.
Then I just found an album-album AR type "live performance" by chance (created because of
http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/980) which is not yet
Adam Golding wrote:
i was discussing this in one of the classical threads--i repaste my
suggestion here:
I must say, I'm a bit confused by your proposal and don't understand all of it,
probably because it's very classical-related.
Again I'm pointing to the plans for the NextGenerationSchema (I
i was discussing this in one of the classical threads--i repaste my suggestion here: ack--let me try again here--i'll ignore whether these releations
are relfexive--either we'll treat them all as reflexive or none of them
as reflexive.
in the database, in addition to having RECORDINGS and WORKS we
Bogdan Butnaru wrote:
The only solution I see is that we should make a clear separation
between attributes that are relevant to the relation and those that
are relevant to the tracks: acoustic or live is a track attribute,
cover or parody or translated is an attribute of the re-releasing
process;
My issue is with the relation attributes. There is any number of
attributes that differentiate two different recordings of tracks, see
[A] for a partial list. Why we should select just "live" and
"acoustic" is rather mysterious to me.
[A] http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/ClarifyExtraTitleInformation
O
