RE: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-17 Thread Tony Hain
Ricky Beamwrote: On Wed, 15 Jul 2015 22:32:19 -0400, Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: You can blame the religious zealots that insisted that everything DHCP does has to also be done via RA's. I blame the anti-DHCP crowd for a lot of things. RAs are just dumb. There's a reason IPv4 can do

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-17 Thread Chuck Anderson
On Thu, Jul 16, 2015 at 07:59:14AM +0200, Tore Anderson wrote: * Owen DeLong o...@delong.com On Jul 15, 2015, at 08:57 , Matthew Kaufman matt...@matthew.at wrote: This is only true for dual-stacked networks. I just tried to set up an IPv6-only WiFi network at my house recently, and it

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-17 Thread Hugo Slabbert
On Fri 2015-Jul-17 12:36:51 -0400, Chuck Anderson c...@wpi.edu wrote: On Thu, Jul 16, 2015 at 07:59:14AM +0200, Tore Anderson wrote: * Owen DeLong o...@delong.com On Jul 15, 2015, at 08:57 , Matthew Kaufman matt...@matthew.at wrote: This is only true for dual-stacked networks. I just

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Hugo Slabbert
On Thu 2015-Jul-16 12:32:19 +1000, Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: --snip-- You can blame the religious zealots that insisted that everything DHCP does has to also be done via RA's. This means that everyone has to implement everything twice. Something Google should have realised when they

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Stephen Satchell
On 07/15/2015 07:32 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: None of which is the fault of the protocol. Blame the equipement vendors for being negligent. I'm sorry, it is just me? Or is the issue before us to fix the PROBLEM and not fix the BLAME? Pointing fingers isn't going to help get us to widespread

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Tore Anderson
* Owen DeLong o...@delong.com On Jul 15, 2015, at 08:57 , Matthew Kaufman matt...@matthew.at wrote: This is only true for dual-stacked networks. I just tried to set up an IPv6-only WiFi network at my house recently, and it was a total fail due to non-implementation of relatively new

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jul 15, 2015, at 19:32 , Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: In message 55a682e6.1050...@matthew.at, Matthew Kaufman writes: On 7/14/2015 11:22 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Yet I can take a Windows XP box. Tell it to enable IPv6 and it just works. Everything that a node needed existed

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jul 15, 2015, at 22:46 , Matthew Kaufman matt...@matthew.at wrote: On 7/15/15 7:32 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Go to any business with hardware that is 3-5 years old in its IT infrastructure and devices ranging from PCs running XP to the random consumer gear people bring in

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Seth Mos
. That is a no go for dynamic networks of any sort. Cheers Oorspronkelijk bericht Van: Owen DeLong o...@delong.com Datum: 16-07-2015 08:51 (GMT+01:00) Aan: Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org Cc: nanog@nanog.org Onderwerp: Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box? On Jul 15, 2015, at 19:32 , Mark

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Owen DeLong
DeLong o...@delong.com Datum: 16-07-2015 08:51 (GMT+01:00) Aan: Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org Cc: nanog@nanog.org Onderwerp: Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box? On Jul 15, 2015, at 19:32 , Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: In message 55a682e6.1050...@matthew.at, Matthew Kaufman writes

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Mark Andrews
In message 20150716060336.ga4...@bamboo.slabnet.com, Hugo Slabbert writes: --snip-- You can blame the religious zealots that insisted that everything DHCP does has to also be done via RA's. This means that everyone has to implement everything twice. Something Google should have realised

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Hugo Slabbert
On Thu 2015-Jul-16 21:19:54 +1000, Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: In message 20150716060336.ga4...@bamboo.slabnet.com, Hugo Slabbert writes: --snip-- You can blame the religious zealots that insisted that everything DHCP does has to also be done via RA's. This means that everyone has to

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Dave Pooser
Internet in a box. Wasn't that the Japanese thing with the Woody Woodpecker logo and the (translated) English text: Touch Woody, the Internet pecker? Didn't go over to well in English speaking parts as I recall ... But it eventually evolved into ChatRoulette. -- Dave Pooser

RE: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Keith Medcalf
Internet in a box. Wasn't that the Japanese thing with the Woody Woodpecker logo and the (translated) English text: Touch Woody, the Internet pecker? Didn't go over to well in English speaking parts as I recall ...

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-16 Thread Ricky Beam
On Wed, 15 Jul 2015 22:32:19 -0400, Mark Andrews ma...@isc.org wrote: You can blame the religious zealots that insisted that everything DHCP does has to also be done via RA's. I blame the anti-DHCP crowd for a lot of things. RAs are just dumb. There's a reason IPv4 can do *everything*

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Matthew Kaufman
On 7/15/15 7:32 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Go to any business with hardware that is 3-5 years old in its IT infrastructure and devices ranging from PCs running XP to the random consumer gear people bring in (cameras, printers, tablets, etc.) and see how easy it is to get everything talking on

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Mark Andrews
In message 55a682e6.1050...@matthew.at, Matthew Kaufman writes: On 7/14/2015 11:22 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Yet I can take a Windows XP box. Tell it to enable IPv6 and it just works. Everything that a node needed existed when Windows XP was released. The last 15 years has been waiting

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Marco Davids
Mark is right and I couldn't agree more with him. On 15/07/15 08:22, Mark Andrews wrote: Yet I can take a Windows XP box. Tell it to enable IPv6 and it just works. Everything that a node needed existed when Windows XP was released. The last 15 years has been waiting for ISP's and CPE

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Mark Andrews
In message 55a5b526.8030...@alter3d.ca, Peter Kristolaitis writes: On 7/14/2015 8:02 PM, Mike wrote: The flame wars and vitrol and rhetoric is too much noise for me to derive anything useful from. Someone needs to stand up and lead. I will happily follow. Too much noise has been v6's

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Baldur Norddahl
On 15 July 2015 at 02:02, Mike mike-na...@tiedyenetworks.com wrote: I am a small provider with a 16 bit asn, a /20 and a /22 of ipv4 and a /32 of v6, but no clue yet how to get from where I am today to where we all should be. The flame wars and vitrol and rhetoric is too much noise for me to

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread mikea
On Wed, Jul 15, 2015 at 04:27:08PM +0300, John Kinsella wrote: On 7/15/15 1:28 PM, Baldur Norddahl wrote: You can't be a dummy and a service provider... oh? :) Counterexample: Cox. They refuse to even admit to me that they are even considering IPV6. -- Mike Andrews, W5EGO

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Matthew Kaufman
On 7/14/2015 11:22 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Yet I can take a Windows XP box. Tell it to enable IPv6 and it just works. Everything that a node needed existed when Windows XP was released. The last 15 years has been waiting for ISP's and CPE vendors to deliver IPv6 as a product. This is not to

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread John Kinsella
On 7/15/15 1:28 PM, Baldur Norddahl wrote: You can't be a dummy and a service provider... oh? :)

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Mel Beckman
Did you deploy Mikrotik routers by any chance? -mel beckman On Jul 15, 2015, at 3:29 AM, Baldur Norddahl baldur.nordd...@gmail.com wrote: On 15 July 2015 at 02:02, Mike mike-na...@tiedyenetworks.com wrote: I am a small provider with a 16 bit asn, a /20 and a /22 of ipv4 and a /32 of

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Lee Howard
I google¹d ³IPv6 for Dummies² and found this: https://www.wesecure.nl/upload/documents/tinymce/IPv6.pdf It¹s licensed from the For Dummies series, written and published by Infoblox. more below. . . On 7/14/15, 8:02 PM, NANOG on behalf of Mike nanog-boun...@nanog.org on behalf of

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Owen DeLong
On Jul 15, 2015, at 08:57 , Matthew Kaufman matt...@matthew.at wrote: On 7/14/2015 11:22 PM, Mark Andrews wrote: Yet I can take a Windows XP box. Tell it to enable IPv6 and it just works. Everything that a node needed existed when Windows XP was released. The last 15 years has been

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-15 Thread Lee Howard
On 7/15/15, 11:57 AM, NANOG on behalf of Matthew Kaufman nanog-boun...@nanog.org on behalf of matt...@matthew.at wrote: Go to any business with hardware that is 3-5 years old in its IT infrastructure and devices ranging from PCs running XP to the random consumer gear people bring in (cameras,

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread John S. Quarterman
In Japan, they had that on a CD in 1994, just after the law changed. Lines snaked across the floor at Interop in the huge new Makuhari Messe conference center in Chiba. -jsq Stephen Satchell wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Peter Kristolaitis
On 7/14/2015 8:02 PM, Mike wrote: The flame wars and vitrol and rhetoric is too much noise for me to derive anything useful from. Someone needs to stand up and lead. I will happily follow. Too much noise has been v6's problem from the start. Every time I've looked at v6 for use in the

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Brett Watson
On Jul 14, 2015, at 4:46 PM, Stephen Satchell l...@satchell.net wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box that contained everything one needed to get started on the Internet. Just add a modem and a computer, and you were on your way.

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Mel Beckman
Mike, I agree that something like that needs to be done. Maybe I’ll do it. In the meantime, have you got an IPv6 lab set up? I’m guessing that with your /32 allocation in hand, you likely do. Have you run through HE.net’s excellent personal IPv6 certification program? Until you gain fluency

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Mike
On 07/14/2015 04:46 PM, Stephen Satchell wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box that contained everything one needed to get started on the Internet. Just add a modem and a computer, and you were on your way. No fuss, no learning

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Steve Atkins
On Jul 14, 2015, at 4:46 PM, Stephen Satchell l...@satchell.net wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box that contained everything one needed to get started on the Internet. Just add a modem and a computer, and you were on your way.

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Joel Jaeggli
This stuff has been consumerized. If you walk into any vzw store you can for $99 and $60 a month no contract walk out with a mifi with v6. You don't even have to ask, or configure anything, pretty much as it should be, the consumer wants internet, Facebook email, and all the upper layer

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Miles Fidelman
Stephen Satchell wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box that contained everything one needed to get started on the Internet. Just add a modem and a computer, and you were on your way. No fuss, no learning curve. I'm beginning to

Re: Remember Internet-In-A-Box?

2015-07-14 Thread Matthew Petach
On Tue, Jul 14, 2015 at 4:46 PM, Stephen Satchell l...@satchell.net wrote: This goes back a number of years. There was a product that literally was a cardboard box that contained everything one needed to get started on the Internet. Just add a modem and a computer, and you were on your way.