Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread James Wallbank
Hi Bronac, I've always believed in the truism "ars longa, vita brevis". You only really see what an artwork is in time. Lev is right that some artworks become hopelessly outdated, or just of interest as an experiment - a record of a moment. But some are still highly relevant. Now, in

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread bronac ferran
Hi James Points taken. Thank you. B On Mon, 21 Sep 2020 at 17:16, James Wallbank wrote: > Hi Bronac, > > I've always believed in the truism "ars longa, vita brevis". You only > really see what an artwork is in time. > > Lev is right that some artworks become hopelessly outdated, or just of >

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread Max Herman
.pnas.org/content/112/8/2295 Sterling book link: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/what-health From: nettime-l-boun...@mail.kein.org on behalf of Brian Holmes Sent: Monday, September 21, 2020 12:11 AM To: nettime Subject: Re: Lev on the embarressment of dig

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread bronac ferran
Dear James Fascinating, but inevitably some thoughts arise I'd already been viewing Lev's cri de coeur as his Hamlet moment, or better still, his anthropophagic minute: Tupi or not Tupi, as our Brazilian forefathers warned us. How to breathe life into old stuff? To regurgitate the swallowed? To

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread James Wallbank
Hello Nettime! This conversation is simply *too* *interesting*! I'm a bit busy right now, but just want to register that I have loads of responses. What is "digital art"? Where is the boundary between digital art and art that engages with the digital? The artworks that I and my friends

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread voyd
  On Mon, 21 Sep 2020 10:26:40 -0400, v...@voyd.com wrote:   Steve, thanks for this, and yeah, the Tactical Media Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test was a great trip. What a ride, and it might not be done. However. This might seem like the biggest non-committal answer possible, but I see

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread Allan Siegel
Hello, Thanks Molly for your Sunday post... allan # distributed via : no commercial use without permission #is a moderated mailing list for net criticism, # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets # more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l # archive:

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread d . garcia
Before the digital cultures insurgency of the 1990s the previous decade had seen a similar burst of excitement around so called video art. Like "new media” or digital cultures movement the power of the video moment came from the breadth of its reach and multiple touch points in art, political

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-21 Thread Geert Lovink
Great postings, Brian, Molly, John and so many others. Lev or no Lev, the whereabouts of new media arts occupy us here, for a reason. From a political and personal perspective the opening up of a new communication medium offers unheard possibilities. Then things close down and the real

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-20 Thread Brian Holmes
As I understand it, Lev Manovich set out to define New Media Art using modernist criteria - notably the tautological gesture whereby the artwork refers to its own components, or its so-called "conditions of possibility." However, as Steve Kurtz, Molly Hankwitz and John Hopkins have pointed out,

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-20 Thread John Hopkins
On 20/Sep/20 14:12, Molly Hankwitz wrote: Dear Geert, Lev, nettime...ok, I take the bait...!!! thanks Molly, et al... Important point -- that the use of networked/digital communications tools was the core (or at least peripheral) for some 'digital' works -- most of them forgotten -- except

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-20 Thread John Young
Art, or "art," has become so ubiquitous it is a challenge to avoid it, like pervasive mania for science in the early 20th century succeeded religion as a must have, and political ideology a compulsory requirement of sclerotic intelligentialism. CBD-Tech art, digital or 3D crafting, or

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-20 Thread Molly Hankwitz
Dear Geert, Lev, nettime...ok, I take the bait...!!! On Thu, Sep 17, 2020 at 12:38 AM Geert Lovink wrote: > URL or not but this is too good, and too important for nettimers, not to > read and discuss. These very personal and relevant observations come from a > public Facebook page and have

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-19 Thread Christiane Robbins
CAE's 30+ years of action, > and feel lucky to have worked with such great colleagues in the struggle, and > I don't even need Prozac to feel that way. > > SK > > From: nettime-l-boun...@mail.kein.org > <mailto:nettime-l-boun...@mail.kein.org> <mailto:nettime-l-b

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-18 Thread Anonymousemail
>From a private chat thread of 30 young artists, writers, researchers.. In response to Levs post, first added to the chat with the comment: I think Lev is having an existential crisis  Person A: I see real people, not ideas and meaningless sounds of yet another electronic music performance, or

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-18 Thread Tilman Baumgärtel
After my first visit to Riga in 1999 I mentioned to my aunt that we went to the Jugendstil quarter that Mikhail Eisenstein, father of Sergei Eisenstein, built there. She told me that this was considered a quaint and dated part of the city because of the "old-fashioned architecture" when she

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-18 Thread Kurtz, Steven
# distributed via : no commercial use without permission #is a moderated mailing list for net criticism, # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets # more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l # archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nett...@kein.org

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread he...@machfeld-foundation.net
Hello out there! Thanks to Lev Manovich to start this discussion! I also wanna make a short statement here: Digital art is the art form of rapid change. In my opinion, not only the artistic investigation of new technologies is available as a field of work. Rather, digital art should also

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread STATION ROSE
Hi all, I think I have to make a statement here as well. Digital Art is my profession since 1988, and I prefer to create art instead of talking about it. But there are lots of important points in Lev Manovich s post. Yes, it is important to have feelings & passion in the digital art. And as a

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread Eric Kluitenberg
hi all, I just visited the superb exhibition at the Stedelijk Museum in Mokum of Nam June Paik, and while some of the work feels a bit dated - most of it felt vibrant, topical, fun, over the top (in a good way), relevant, at times endearing, then again poetic even outrageous, nostalgic in

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread Francis Hunger
Dears, The problem of Ars Electronica is known for a long time. It adds up. It can't however not be generalized for the field, as Olia already pointed out. What might be at stake is a discussion about festival culture. As much as I value festivals as a meeting

Re: Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread olia lialina
"Sad by Manovich" or "Sad by Ars Electronica" ;) Six false statements in four sentences is a lot! "New media art never deals with human life, and this is why it does not enter museums. It's our fault. Don't blame curators or the "art world." Digital art is "anti-human art," and this is why it

Lev on the embarressment of digital art

2020-09-17 Thread Geert Lovink
URL or not but this is too good, and too important for nettimers, not to read and discuss. These very personal and relevant observations come from a public Facebook page and have been written by Lev Manovich (who is “feeling thoughtful” as the page indicates). —