Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread GULPF
> I think it might be easier to overlook if there was a tool that could that > could format the code in one way or another, or a linter of sorts that would > enforce a particular style? `--styleCheck:hint` or `--styleCheck:error` can be passed to the compiler which enforces that all symbols in

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread mashingan
> I've found that the style insensitivity is by far the biggest obstacle I've > found in Nim adoption at my company. I can definitely say it's incorrect finding. 99% companies like to play safe, use whatever popular without really understand pros/cons of what they're using. Because they don't w

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread runvnc
The reason the C sometimes relied upon underscores at one time was because in the good old days many system only supported one case. Now that all modern systems have upper and lower case, it makes sense to use an initial uppercase letter to use the same descriptive for a type rather than variabl

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread runvnc
When people say it's an obstacle for adoption, exactly in what way? Do you mean that they actually tried to compile something, and it failed because of identifiers being considered the same in Nim? Or just that they looked at the web page, saw that and that is the thing they decided to use as th

Memory regions / gc:regions

2018-11-23 Thread carterza
Does ANYONE know how to use memory regions beyond the examples that are available on the forum? These examples tend to consist of - var rx: MemRegion withRegion rx: discard 0 Run While this example code proves regions work - it doesn't prove much beyond

Has anyone written something like 'Expect' in Nim?

2018-11-23 Thread bobg
Has anyone written something like 'Expect' in Nim? Expect is a tool for wrapping command-line commands with a parser that can execute the command and then interpret the results. Commonly used as one of the basic pieces for constructing command execution tools like ansible or fabric. (see 'Expl

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread metasyn
Although I do not use Nim everyday (I'd like to!) - I've found that the style insensitivity is by far the biggest obstacle I've found in Nim adoption at my company. I think it might be easier to overlook if there was a tool that could that could format the code in one way or another, or a linte

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread didlybom
Completely agree. If that is the main benefit, why not focus on giving a non controversial solution to that particular problem?

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread Stefan_Salewski
> I thought if is used in run-time while when is for compile-time, is not like > that? Generally it is of course. But I just tested what I wrote above, and my memory was indeed correct: "echo (a +1)" does not compile for your example code, but replacing if with when makes it compile again. As

Re: Deprecation of "round" with two arguments

2018-11-23 Thread lscrd
Yes, I agree that this function is not generally what is needed. Most of the time, we want a string and "format" is what should be used. I didn’t wanted to discuss the decision, I was just curious to know if there exists situations where it actually gives a wrong result. Now, in my case, this i

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread andrea
@gemath Actually, a pure Nim library could not respect NEP1 and follow a different naming style. If I use such library, I will call it using NEP1 identifiers - no importc in sight. I think it could make sense to add a warning in the compiler for the case where mixed styles are used **inside** t

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread yglukhov
You could put those even into an int. But yeah, sure. Though note that Variant will not distinguish type aliases.

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread kcvinu
Can i put data types like HMENU, HWND, HPEN, HBRUSH, in a variant ?

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread allochi
One person wouldn't use multiple styles, a big team of developers, it's different story. Imagine in real big project, when you hire consultants to work on part of a project, and they write their code in a different style than that of the team, which they are using for months, and then you need

Re: The future of NIM's WASM?

2018-11-23 Thread Araq
What's new is my answer. :P

Re: The future of NIM's WASM?

2018-11-23 Thread mashingan
I don't know, but this post already asked several months ago and 90% of post wording is same, :/ [https://forum.nim-lang.org/t/4049](https://forum.nim-lang.org/t/4049)

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread mashingan
> But then the if statement makes not much sense any more, it should be a when. > But when is compile time of course. So for me here is no actual runtime test > at all. I thought `if` is used in run-time while `when` is for compile-time, is not like that?

Re: The future of NIM's WASM?

2018-11-23 Thread Araq
Our plans for the future are more general but improve the support for wasm as a side-effect: * Make the language more agnostic to the used underlying allocators (destructors). * Introduce an optional code transformation that maps exception handling to `if` statements. * Make the tracing g

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread yglukhov
Here's something that could help: [https://github.com/yglukhov/variant](https://github.com/yglukhov/variant). And +1 in most cases you can/should go with static typing.

Re: Deprecation of "round" with two arguments

2018-11-23 Thread Araq
We decided that this variant of round is almost never what you should use. The stdlib needs to avoid procs that trick you into programming bugs. If you **really** need it, use this code: proc myRound*[T: float32|float64](x: T, places: int): T= if places == 0: result =

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread alehander42
@kcvinu This is a very interesting experiment, and I'll be interested in seeing if it's possible for it to work well. Still, keep in mind, that this is just veeery unusal in normal Nim code: I doubt I'll ever use anything like that even if it works, because 1) one can use normal types / variant

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread moerm
> Does anyone out there routinely use this feature of diverging from the style > of an import or as I mentioned just follow the lib's conventions? I do. I do not feel it to be problematic how the Nim lib naming is but I always and consistently use my own style in my own code (CamelCase for vars,

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread gemath
> you are not supposed to use style insensitivity to mix styles inside a > codebase If that was the case, and I wish it was, style insensitivity would at least be limited to the `import`, `importcpp` and `importc` statements to be resolved with symbol binding.

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread moerm
Side note: Adapting to a libraries style _can_ also been as an advantage ("Obviously code from elsewhere"). In fact, almost all of those questions _can_ be seen this or that way. Based on some decades experience I can't remember having felt that some libraries naming convention was problematic

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread kcvinu
It is just an experiment. I love ArrayList in vb.net and list in python. I am trying to implement something like them in Nim. I know, that most of the time we can make a user defined type and declare a seq contains that type will work. But this is also a good feature of a language. This is my a

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread cblake
Does anyone out there routinely use this feature of diverging from the style of an `import` or as I mentioned just follow the lib's conventions? Part of @dom96's survey should perhaps ask if that aspect is just a "theoretical nicety". I mean, someone cared enough about project-internal style co

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread kcvinu
Could you please post a code snippet using "of" instead of "is"

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread alehander42
Hey @kcvinu, what are you trying to do generally with this approach? It seems interesting, but it's very rarely needed to do something like that in normal Nim code: I think you're trying to recreate some Python/Ruby code patterns, but maybe you can solve this in a generally different way (e.g. o

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread kcvinu
Thanks man. Great help. :)

Re: classic "can not open sdl2" ...

2018-11-23 Thread thedoc
It is installed, but it has to be in the same directory as the rest, else it does not appear to be recognized. That makes sense, of course. It's as you describe now ... and I probably should have upgraded to 0.19 earlier.

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread andrea
@allochi that experiment does not really make much sense, because you are not supposed to use style insensitivity to mix styles inside a codebase, unless you are masochistic. Style insensitivity is used to take a library written in a different style and use inside your project without having to

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread allochi
Here is a little experiment. 1. Write a sample code, explicitly use style insensitive in the code 2. Show it to some colleagues who doesn't know nim 3. Try to explain to them the code without bringing style insensitive up unless they ask 4. They will definitely ask why you have get_data()

Re: classic "can not open sdl2" ...

2018-11-23 Thread Stefan_Salewski
When sdl.nim is missing (package not installed) you should get an error at compile time. When a dll is missing, you should get an error when you launch your executable.

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread mratsim
For inherited types (i.e. runtime types) you can use `of` instead of `is`.

Deprecation of "round" with two arguments

2018-11-23 Thread lscrd
Hello all, When compiling (with development version of Nim) a module which uses the "round" function from the "math" module, more precisely the "round" function with two arguments (the second one being the number of positions after decimal point), I got a deprecation warning. The recommended wa

Re: classic "can not open sdl2" ...

2018-11-23 Thread thedoc
Okay, so apparently I've mixed up example files ... and it's not the dll that's missing, but the package. I've figured it out by looking at the tests in nim/tests/.../sdl. I saw "import sdl" and went "oh" That doesn't explain why i have the dll problem with csfml, but at least this is probab

Re: classic "can not open sdl2" ...

2018-11-23 Thread thedoc
Ah okay, so apparently the sdl.nim is **required** to work, and it is not actually asking for the dll (like it did in the old version) but actually asks for sdl.NIM ... man ...

Re: Araq in IRC: for Python migration TableRef will suit you much better than Table

2018-11-23 Thread mratsim
In Python everything is a ref object. When porting you might get the wrong result if you use tables with value semantics instead of TableRef if the Table/TableRef is copied.

Araq in IRC: for Python migration TableRef will suit you much better than Table

2018-11-23 Thread Stefan_Salewski
[https://irclogs.nim-lang.org/26-10-2018.html#09:38:42](https://irclogs.nim-lang.org/26-10-2018.html#09:38:42) Can someone explain?

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread cblake
I think a vote would be fine. Ballot box stuffing is possible, but probably identifiable via sheer numbers since the Nim community is so small unless the vote gets HackerNews'd or Slashdotted. I also agree that the people who matter most would never participate in such a vote because they've alr

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread Stefan_Salewski
mashingan, your above example looks a bit funny and strange to me. Your printout proc is generic, so due to actual calls with int, string and float parameters, we should actually get 3 distinct instances of that proc in executable. And actual parameter decides which actual instance is called. Bu

classic "can not open sdl2" ...

2018-11-23 Thread thedoc
Greetings. I don't know why it is not working. I have updated to the latest nim. I have made sure that I have the correct dll installed, which is the 64bit version. I have placed the dll everywhere where it might make sense, including system32 and nimbin and, of course, the local directory. Wh

The future of NIM's WASM?

2018-11-23 Thread HerbertClair
I went from Go and recently had an interest in Web Assembly, but I do not feel that Go is particularly good for it, mainly due to the large binary size. So I look around for a new language and Nim seems perfect for it, modern, fast and makes even binary files even under the web. Have I found so

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread lscrd
Thanks for the precision. But is it really style insensitivity? That’s what I thought until I understood that it is only a consequence of ignoring the underscores in identifiers as underscores are ignored in numbers. So Nim style insensitivity may be seen only a consequence of Nim case insensit

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread mashingan
Just because code has uniform _naming-style_ doesn't make it easier to read, and vice-versa. By non-programmer point-of-view, glorious_function and gloriusFunction is (about) same, read same, and (almost) look same, and that's only natural.

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread kcvinu
> Types exist at compile-time only (opposite to Ruby, Python and the like). I just want to check the type at runtime and want to make some changes in program. So i am assuming i cant do it in nim.

Re: How to convert integer to pointer

2018-11-23 Thread mashingan
> I just want to check the type at runtime [https://nim-lang.org/docs/typeinfo.html](https://nim-lang.org/docs/typeinfo.html)

Re: Should we get rid of style insensitivity?

2018-11-23 Thread moerm
We can turn it anyway we like but we must not go against the vital rule that a compiler must not ever change an identifier behind the developers back. leading '_' can be discussed (I'm pro but can accept Nim staying against it). Case sensitivity and/or rules (like types capital 1st. letter, vars