Re: OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-10 Thread August Nagro
> I don’t see that as a problem as new versions can be uploaded as required. Don't you think it would be an issue if Oracle decided to change the JAR format from ZIP to something else? I agree with the rest of your reply though. On Mon, Dec 10, 2018 at 1:16 PM August Nagro wrote: > I wouldn't

Re: OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-10 Thread Scott Palmer
Inline > On Dec 10, 2018, at 2:16 PM, August Nagro wrote: > > I wouldn't recommend publishing JMOD files on maven central since the file > format is not yet stable (based on zip currently, but ideally will change to > better compression in the future). JMOD seems to be 'unfinished business'

Re: OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-10 Thread August Nagro
I wouldn't recommend publishing JMOD files on maven central since the file format is not yet stable (based on zip currently, but ideally will change to better compression in the future). JMOD seems to be 'unfinished business' from JPMS. Ex, https://stackoverflow.com/questions/44732915/why-did-java

Re: OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-10 Thread Matthias Bläsing
Hi Johan, I was in a similar situation for JNA (Java Native Access) and found, that sonatype accepts other package types than jar/javadoc/sources. To support opening JNI libraries, the native parts need to be packed differently. This packaging is an "aar" (Android Archive). I did not ask sonatype

Re: OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-09 Thread Johan Vos
Hi Scott, I got the use case. I think it should be possible, although in general uploading to the OSS sonatype repository requires uploading jars for the classes, sources and javadoc. There is no procedure yet (afaik) for uploading mods, but we can see if that works. - Johan On Fri, Dec 7, 2018

OpenJFX JMOD Files

2018-12-07 Thread Scott Palmer
Is there a reason not to make the jmod files available as artifacts on Maven Central? The idea being that I can then use dependency management in my Gradle script and not require the extra setup and configuration of a JavaFX SDK - yet still be able to use the jmod files as input to jlink. I would