[PEN-L:8682] Re: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Sam Pawlett
Jim Devine wrote: I contribute too many missives to pen-l Not! and I'm no expert on urban development. What do others on pen-l think? Should LA subsidize an NFL team to locate here? Is it a good idea for other cities to do so? Does it promote the _type_ of development we want? Should the

[PEN-L:8684] Re: Re: Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After theFallof Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Peter Dorman
I think it would be hard to find any major European thinker before the twentieth century who did not write vile racist claptrap. Marx may have been better than some, but his comment (whose cite I can't recall at the moment) about the "abundance" of the tropics inducing sloth and being

[PEN-L:8683] Re: the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread Sam Pawlett
Doug Henwood wrote: I'm thinking of doing an article on the rise to dominance of right-wing thought in economics social policy in the 1970s. Any PEN-Lers have any thoughts, reminiscences, etc.? Did Milton Friedman's presidency at the AEA mark some kind of turning point? In the

[PEN-L:8681] Re: Re: Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread Sam Pawlett
William S. Lear wrote: Since when is Chomsky a defender of Cartesian dualism? He has stated that since nobody has a definite conception of "body", even posing the problem is impossible. I think you are partly right. What Chomsky means by "Cartesian dualism" is different from the meaning

[PEN-L:8680] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thomas Friedman aneconomist?

1999-06-30 Thread Brad De Long
But it's a straightforward technical exercise to show that they aren't Peter Yep.

[PEN-L:8679] Re: RE: re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Brad De Long
Ken Hanly wrote: COMMENT: But this confirms my point doesn't it? Isn't it a core assumption of neoclassical economists that it is impossible to make interpersonal comparisons of utility? Am I wrong in thinking that? Isn't it standard that among most that only cardinal rankings of utility by

[PEN-L:8678] Re: re: interpersonal utility comparisons (wasThomas Fr iedman an economist?)

1999-06-30 Thread Brad De Long
Doesn't the process of comparing differences in ordinal rankings bring cardinal rankings back into the function, thereby violating the noncardinality condition? Yep. But ya gotta do it, one way or another... Brad DeLong

[PEN-L:8677] Re: Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
I wrote: We should be careful here. After all, just because imperialist spokescreeps are against something doesn't mean that we should be in favor of it. Those folks were right to oppose the Khmer Rouge for awhile (while they were wrong to support them for an even longer period). The enemy of my

[PEN-L:8676] Re: Left Racism 1968/69 - 1999

1999-06-30 Thread Rod Hay
As one who is old enough to have been active politically at the time, I can confirm Max's version. Take a look at the many left newspapers that were being produced at that time. The connection was made and the criticism of the main stream press for ignoring Jackson was prominent.

[PEN-L:8672] Among U.S. Donations, Tons of Worthless Drugs

1999-06-30 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
New York Times June 29, 1999 Among U.S. Donations, Tons of Worthless Drugs By Reed Abelson Last month, Project Hope, the American medical charity, shipped $1.5 million worth of emergency supplies to the Kosovo refugees. But relief workers desperate for syringes, penicillin and insulin found many

[PEN-L:8674] Re: RE: Left Racism 1968/69 - 1999

1999-06-30 Thread Carrol Cox
"Max B. Sawicky" wrote: The idea of any 'treason' is ridiculous. "Kent State" is the TIME magazine reconstruction. At the time, the left was quite anxious to make the Kent-Jackson connection. I hope Max is right and I am wrong. It would bode better for the future. Carrol

[PEN-L:8673] Re: Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread William S. Lear
On Wednesday, June 30, 1999 at 20:54:51 (-0500) Ken Hanly writes: I don't recall Chomsky defending Descartes' division between material and mental substance as the two basic substances, but he does defend a version of Descartes' doctrine of innate ideas in "Cartesian Linguistics" and elsewhere.

[PEN-L:8671] Re: Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread phillp2
Louis wrote: The issue is ECONOMICS. Milosevic wasn't ready to turn over the keys to the country to western banks. I am surprised that PEN-L'ers have done so little to dig into this question. Except for Paul Phillips who has a vested professional interest in Yugoslavia from what I can

[PEN-L:8670] Re: Re: Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread Ken Hanly
I don't recall Chomsky defending Descartes' division between material and mental substance as the two basic substances, but he does defend a version of Descartes' doctrine of innate ideas in "Cartesian Linguistics" and elsewhere. So he does owe a debt to Descartes that he freely acknowledges.

[PEN-L:8669] Re: Isaac on Chalmers Johnson

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
I am Asian, from Hong Kong, and I have been and am still intimitely invovled on a policy level and as a market participant with the Asian financial crises since July, 1997. I can report with some authority that Johnson's observations are not fantasies and in fact are rather calm and moderating.

[PEN-L:8668] Re: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread William S. Lear
On Wednesday, June 30, 1999 at 15:44:31 (-0700) Jim Devine writes: Henry wrote: Jim, Shrinking the size of the economy, even parts that are heavily subsidized, reduces growth by definition. ... ... I contribute too many missives to pen-l and I'm no expert on urban development. What do others on

[PEN-L:8667] Re: Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread William S. Lear
On Wednesday, June 30, 1999 at 15:47:12 (-0700) Sam Pawlett writes: Michael Keaney wrote: I cannot speak for his stuff on linguistics, however. I wonder if some here would regard these, if read blindly, as lofty and non-judgmental. Chomsky's writings on linguistics and philosophy are even

[PEN-L:8666] the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
The New York Times, June 20, 1999, Sunday, Late Edition - Final Holy Cow! By Allen St. John Allen St. John has covered the Yankees for the last seven seasons for The Village Voice and other publications. Those Damn Yankees: The Secret Life of America's Greatest Franchise. By Dean Chadwin.

[PEN-L:8665] Is the Fed behind the curve?

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
04:48 PM ET 06/30/99 Dollar slips amid limited scope for more rate hikes By Svea Herbst-Bayliss NEW YORK, June 30 (Reuters) - The dollar fell against most currencies on Wednesday when hours of waiting for news on U.S. interest rates ended with a surprise that left traders briefly

[PEN-L:8664] RE: Left Racism 1968/69 - 1999

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
The standard posture seems to be: we are against racism, but let's not discuss it, because it is divisive, it turns people off, it make the poster sound frenzied, let just oppose it quietly but not draw attention to it. I haven't followed most of this thread -- in self defense I am deleting

[PEN-L:8663] Re: Re: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Michael, Tactical error. Should have taken the consulting and try to move the project towardss a socialist direction. Next time, don't say no. Quote an exhorbitant consulting fee, like 2% of the deal and donate half of it to your favorite cause (not cahrity, please). Never turn away power if

[PEN-L:8662] Re: RE: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim, I don't disagree in general terms, but that means the target is capitalism not sports. Sports in the West has been corrupted by capitalism. To that there is no denying. Yet, sport itself is not to blame. Sport has defused war, used as effective diplomacy, build self-image for oppressed

[PEN-L:8661] Another Apology

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Perelman
I am sorry. I read this as an off line post to me. I did not mean to send personal stuff onto the list. My apologies to all. Michael Perelman wrote: Henry C.K. Liu wrote: I am not involved with this. I have filtered Sawacki out a while ago and have not engaged him. To not respond

[PEN-L:8660] Re: Sports and urban growth

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Social accounting a highly problematic. Its very hard to find a consultant report that does not lie. But lets suppose the cash flow tally comes out negative on the revenue/subsidy side, and lets assume that the benefits are unevenly distributed in similar proportion as in other sectors, it will

[PEN-L:8659] Re: Sports and urban growth

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Perelman
Roger Noll says that the early studies gave too much credit to the stadium since it took "entertainment" money from other local businesses. DOUG ORR wrote: It has been a long time since I looked at the "sports" lit., but a while back several studies indicated that attracting a team was, at

[PEN-L:8658] Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After the Fall of Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Ricardo wrote: I will be responding in greater detail to Yoshie's post, as well this one, later on, if time allows. For now let me say that, while all this stuff on the so-called "racism" of great thinkers is interesting (myself having posted a few of Marx's own "racist" remarks some time ago),

[PEN-L:8657] Re: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Perelman
I believe that every city that has subsidized a major sports stadium has been burned. Al Davis's son was a student of mine and wanted me to be a consultant during his early suit with Oakland. I declined. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:8656] Re: Re: Re: RE: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Perelman
Henry C.K. Liu wrote: I am not involved with this. I have filtered Sawacki out a while ago and have not engaged him. To not respond will disappoint him. He loves to provoke you. I have move on to neoclassical economics and urban transportation and racism. Good. Should I stop and

[PEN-L:8655] Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Devine: We should be careful here. After all, just because imperialist spokescreeps are against something doesn't mean that we should be in favor of it. Those folks were right to oppose the Khmer Rouge for awhile (while they were wrong to support them for an even longer period). The enemy of

[PEN-L:8654] Re: Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Jim Devine wrote: I'm surprised the US doesn't see Milosevic as "our SOB." They might if the Albanian 'nationalist' leaders and/or the Serbian 'democratic' oppositions were left-wingers who refused to be controlled or manipulated by Americans and instead attacked the interests of capital. The US

[PEN-L:8653] RE: the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Craven, Jim
Last Response for the Day: The top growth industries in the US today are sports stadiums and prisons both of which involve--as usual--the socialization of costs of producing increasingly concentrated and centralized privatized profits. The NFL and other "sports" leagues are also essential

[PEN-L:8652] Sports and urban growth

1999-06-30 Thread DOUG ORR
It has been a long time since I looked at the "sports" lit., but a while back several studies indicated that attracting a team was, at best, a wash. It cost the local economy as much in subsidies as in new $ created (total $, not just tax $). Since then the subsidies have gotten bigger, so I

[PEN-L:8650] the NFL and urban development

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
Henry wrote: Jim, Shrinking the size of the economy, even parts that are heavily subsidized, reduces growth by definition. We must not confuse fair distribution of cost and benefits with the aggregate size of the economy. Full socialization of the NFL would be a better solution. What you are

[PEN-L:8649] Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After

1999-06-30 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
I will be responding in greater detail to Yoshie's post, as well this one, later on, if time allows. For now let me say that, while all this stuff on the so-called "racism" of great thinkers is interesting (myself having posted a few of Marx's own "racist" remarks some time ago), I think it

[PEN-L:8648] Re: Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread Sam Pawlett
Michael Keaney wrote: I cannot speak for his stuff on linguistics, however. I wonder if some here would regard these, if read blindly, as lofty and non-judgmental. Chomsky's writings on linguistics and philosophy are even more polemical and controversial than his political writings. Next to

[PEN-L:8647] Re: Re: RE: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Now Michael, I am not involved with this. I have filtered Sawacki out a while ago and have not engaged him. I have move on to neoclassical economics and urban transportation and racism. Should I stop and restart? Henry Michael Perelman wrote: Damn, Max. This is just provocative flame

[PEN-L:8646] RE: Re: the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread Craven, Jim
-Original Message- From: William S. Lear [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, June 30, 1999 3:37 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:8645] Re: the right-wing ascendancy On Wednesday, June 30, 1999 at 12:36:14 (-0400) Doug Henwood writes: I'm thinking of doing an article on

[PEN-L:8645] Re: the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread William S. Lear
On Wednesday, June 30, 1999 at 12:36:14 (-0400) Doug Henwood writes: I'm thinking of doing an article on the rise to dominance of right-wing thought in economics social policy in the 1970s. Any PEN-Lers have any thoughts, reminiscences, etc.? Did Milton Friedman's presidency at the AEA mark

[PEN-L:8644] ECONOMY: US Aid Chief Blasts Hypocrisy of Globalisation

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Eisenscher
/* Written 9:08 PM Jun 29, 1999 by newsdesk in igc:ips.english */ /* -- "ECONOMY: US Aid Chief Blasts Hypocr" -- */ Copyright 1999 InterPress Service, all rights reserved. Worldwide distribution via the APC networks. *** 29-Jun-99 ***

[PEN-L:8643] Re: RE: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Perelman
Damn, Max. This is just provocative flame bait. You, Henry, and a few people need to stop immediately! Max B. Sawicky wrote: I think PEN-L is a place for people fleeing spam in homage to Leninism, and especially its degraded extensions in Stalin and Wao, I mean Mao. -- Michael Perelman

[PEN-L:8642] Re: Re: Re: Re: Racism and Urban Transportation

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim, Shrinking the size of the economy, even parts that are heavily subsidized, reduces growth by definition. We must not confuse fair distribution of cost and benefits with the aggregate size of the economy. Full socialization of the NFL would be a better solution. What you are objecting to

[PEN-L:8640] Re: the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread Rod Hay
Doug: Robert Gordon wrote an interesting article on the history of macroeconomics after the second world war in the US. While his view is different from yours, the article does have some interesting things to say. It was published in one of the NBER volumes in the early '80x. Rod

[PEN-L:8639] Re: Re: Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After theFallof Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Here is what Hegel has to say in the Introduction to Philosophy of History based on lectures delivered in 1830-31: Geographical Basis of History "... In the United States of North America all the citizens are of European decent, with whom the old inhabitants could not amalgamate, but was

[PEN-L:8638] Re: Re: Re: Racism and Urban Transportation

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
Henry writes: Keeping the NFL out will hurt the LA economy. Why does keeping the NFL out hurt the LA economy? Considering all of the subsidies that the NFL would receive (they want us to (re)build a stadium for them) -- and the alternative uses for LA's resources, such as putting money into

[PEN-L:8637] Re: Re: Racism and Urban Transportation

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim, It is a tactic dilemma. In America, short of a total revolution, the poor will never get anything without compensatory benefit to the rich. I realized the piggy back strategy is regressive structurally, but would it be better than nothing? Keeping the NFL out will hurt the LA economy.

[PEN-L:8636] Re: Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
David McReynolds says: Milosevic was not a dictator but had been elected three times. So perhaps Milosevic is like the late "hizzoner da mare" Richard J. Dailey of Chicago, who used his political machine to fix elections so that he could get reelected? I still remember old Dailey at the time of

[PEN-L:8635] Enlightenment racism

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
Emmanuel Chukwudi Eze, "Race and the Enlightenment: A Reader", pp. 58-64: Eze's preface to the selection: While Kant himself edited for publication his lectures in anthropology (Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View), he wrote, concerning his lectures in geography, "it will not be

[PEN-L:8634] Re: Racism and Urban Transportation

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
Even better would be to keep the NFL out of LA. Who needs taxpayer subsidies to rich folks like the Oakland Raiders' owner, who took the subsidies from LA and ran back to Oakland? LA should simply reject the NFL instead of being whip-sawed by the teams who insist of big bucks or they'll move

[PEN-L:8633] Re: Re: Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After theFallof Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Mathew Forstater
In addition to what I supplied in my previous post, Kant also wrote that "the negroes of Africa have by nature no feeling that rises above the trifling." West also reports that Kant wrote "in reply to advice that a black person gave to Father Labat": "And it might be that there was something in

[PEN-L:8632] Re: Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After the FallofCommunism*

1999-06-30 Thread Mathew Forstater
Hugh MacDougall, in his _Racial Myth in English History_ (1982, Harvest House), writes that "Hegel led the way in identifying the process of universal history with Germanic political thought and culture. He asserted that the final stage of history was reached with the development of Christian

[PEN-L:8631] Re: [fla-left] [news] Anti-flag burning amendment passesHouse (fwd)

1999-06-30 Thread Peter Dorman
Time to bring back that ol' July 4th favorite, flaming flag pie. It's a rectangular blueberry pie with strips of read and white crust over all but the upper-left part. Warm the pie, add a splash of brandy, light 'n serve. Peter Michael Hoover wrote: it may be lesser-of-two-evils (that may

[PEN-L:8630] Racism and Urban Transportation

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
BUS RIDERS UNION CALLS ON THE NFL: DON’T PLAY BALL WITH A RACIST CITY— MAKE THE MTA BUY THE BUSES! CONTACT: KIKANZA RAMSEY or MARTIN HERNANDEZ at (213) 387-2800 On Thursday, June 17, 1999 the Labor/Community Strategy Center and

[PEN-L:8629] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Peter Dorman
But it's a straightforward technical exercise to show that they aren't. For example, consider a situation in which my business is dumping a toxic chemical into your community. If we do a benefit-cost analysis, the profit I get from dumping is recorded as a cost of anti-dumping regulation, and

[PEN-L:8628] support the McKinney debt cancellation act

1999-06-30 Thread Robert Naiman
to sign your organization on to this letter, send an email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] include name of organization, city, state, contact person. deadline is Tuesday afternoon, July 6. - SUPPORT REP. MCKINNEY'S DEBT CANCELLATION ACT To: Members of the United States

[PEN-L:8627] Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
The kind in the throes of collapse? The kind that acts one way towards the national majority, and quite another w/respect to others? mbs [was that repetitious?] Max, perhaps we have different definitions of dictatorship. Greece had a dictatorship in the 1960s which was backed by the US

[PEN-L:8625] Liberal Stuff

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
Items of current interest . . . Campaign for America’s Future -- Steel Sold Out The US Senate failed to support a measure to stop the illegal dumping of foreign steel in the U.S. after Clinton Administration lobbying against a

[PEN-L:8626] RE: Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
.. . . useful to consider today's NY Times for an obvious refutation of theme 3. What kind of dictatorship would allow peaceful protests such as these in the aftermath of a catastrophic military defeat?] NY Times, June 30, 1999 10,000 Serb Protesters Demand Resignation of Milosevic . . . The

[PEN-L:8624] Experts

1999-06-30 Thread Craven, Jim
Once I was giving a graduate class in Development and Planning at St. Berchman's University in Changanacherry, Kerala India. The class wanted to go over some of the work in "operations theory" coming out of the U.S. I asked the class: What is the average wage of a lorry driver in Kerala? What is

[PEN-L:8623] EDF Corrupt on Global Warming? New Report Challenges Integrityof Leading U.S. Eco-Group

1999-06-30 Thread Robert Naiman
full report at www.erols.com/npap Crony Environmentalism: Report Challenges Integrity of Environmental Defense Fund; Do Conflicts of Interest Corrupt Global Warming Agenda of Leading U.S. Eco-Group? -- EDF Created and Affiliated Group Would Profit from Provisions of Senator Chafee's "Early

[PEN-L:8622] Pacifica protest

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Times, June 30, 1999 Power Struggle Disrupts Oldest Public Radio Station By EVELYN NIEVES BERKELEY, Calif. -- The trouble at radio station KPFA has come to this: When two folk singers scheduled to perform as a duo on Sunday afternoon arrived at the building, armed security guards would only

[PEN-L:8621] Re: Nietzsche and Social Democracy (wasSocialism, Social Democracy,Democracy)

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
On the highly sophisticated version of sd, in the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party (Bolshevik) Lunarcharski ( later Minister of Education) and a number of others advocated Nietzschean ethics. Charles Brown Yoshie Furuhashi [EMAIL PROTECTED] 06/30/99 01:24PM Michael Keaney to Lou: I'm

[PEN-L:8620] Consumerism defended

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
Village Voice, June 30 - July 6, 1999 Natural Born Shoppers "Commercialism is the water we all swim in, the air we breathe, our sunlight and our shade." If James Twitchell weren't a graceful, witty writer, his new book, Lead Us Into Temptation: The Triumph of American Materialism, would be

[PEN-L:8619] RE: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
What Max is saying ( not Wax himself) is mindless and uncritical liberal western dogma unaware that it is in caricature of free thinking wit, a bane of the human race. Charles Brown "Max B. Sawicky" [EMAIL PROTECTED] 06/30/99 01:50PM Louis Proyect wrote: My suggestion to Charles and Henry

[PEN-L:8618] Obfuscatory hogwash

1999-06-30 Thread Tom Walker
Ken Hanly asked, Is your description of Pareto optimality as obfuscatory hogwash generally agreed upon by economists? How could we ever know without making interpersonal comparisons of utility? regards, Tom Walker http://www.vcn.bc.ca/timework/worksite.htm

[PEN-L:8617] FW: Clintons fax/phone

1999-06-30 Thread Craven, Jim
Clinton is about to go to the Lakota Reservation at Pine Ridge in a few days. Please join in sending letters or making calls to demand the release of Leonard Peltier who is almost dead after 23 years in prison for a crime he did not commit according to the FBI's own ballistics reports. He has had

[PEN-L:8616] RE: [fla-left] [news] Anti-flag burning amendmentpasses House (fwd)

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
What does the flag mean to these people ? Presumably, it means they feel they are connected to the history of the U$A. So, in this case the American$ see no problem in finding their connection to earlier generations of the nation. But when you mention reparations and affirmative action for the

[PEN-L:8615] Left Racism 1968/69 - 1999

1999-06-30 Thread Carrol Cox
"Henry C.K. Liu" wrote: The standard posture seems to be: we are against racism, but let's not discuss it, because it is divisive, it turns people off, it make the poster sound frenzied, let just oppose it quietly but not draw attention to it. I haven't followed most of this thread -- in

[PEN-L:8614] Re: Socialism, Social Democracy, Democracy

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
Michael Keaney writes: ... Sheldon Wolin has written good stuff on the deleterious effects of Western culture's elevation of the economic over the political. That Marx is implicated by this does not mean that he ought to be ditched­far from it. But we could be a little more critical of the

[PEN-L:8613] re: interpersonal utility comparisons (was Thomas Friedman an economist?)

1999-06-30 Thread Tom Walker
Jeffrey Fellows asked, Doesn't the process of comparing differences in ordinal rankings bring cardinal rankings back into the function, thereby violating the noncardinality condition? My argument is that it doesn't because the allegedly ordinal rankings don't stand up to scrutiny. Using the

[PEN-L:8612] RE: re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
.. . . The difference between shit and shinola: if you assume that maximum output equals maximum welfare, you're making an interpersonal comparison of utility between those who have a preference for consumption goods and those who have a preference for disposable time. The "no interpersonal

[PEN-L:8611] RE: re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Tom Walker Sent: Wednesday, June 30, 1999 10:34 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:8596] re: Thomas Friedman an economist? Ken Hanly wrote: COMMENT: But this confirms my point doesn't it? Isn't it

[PEN-L:8610] RE: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Max B. Sawicky
Louis Proyect wrote: My suggestion to Charles and Henry is to avoid getting bogged down in debates with Professor Delong. As far as I can tell, he is a very upscale sort of troll. Louis, I don't think that this sort of characterization is useful. He knows that PEN-L is not really a haven for

[PEN-L:8609] Latin American stagnation

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
June 30, 1999 New Data Indicate Longer Recession in Latin America By CLIFFORD KRAUSS BUENOS AIRES, Argentina -- Despite brighter-than-expected economic performances in Brazil and Mexico, a spate of new economic data around Latin America in recent days suggests that the recession

[PEN-L:8608] RE: [fla-left] [news] Anti-flag burning amendment passes House (fwd)

1999-06-30 Thread Craven, Jim
No, this is important stuff. The Nazis while raping, murdering and pillaging wore belt buckles that said "Gott Mit Uns". The ultra-rightists have a party and ideology designed for the ultra-rich, ultra-confortable and ultra-white but when you have the rappings and illusions of bourgeois

[PEN-L:8607] Re: Nietzsche and Social Democracy (wasSocialism, Social Democracy, Democracy)

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
I think Terry Eagleton said something like that (probably in his _The Illusion of Postmodernism_), especially with regard to _Hegemony Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics_ by Ernesto Laclau + Chantal Mouffe and other post-marxist stuff. There is a precedent for this

[PEN-L:8606] Re: the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
At 12:36 PM 6/30/99 -0400, you wrote: I'm thinking of doing an article on the rise to dominance of right-wing thought in economics social policy in the 1970s. Any PEN-Lers have any thoughts, reminiscences, etc.? Did Milton Friedman's presidency at the AEA mark some kind of turning point? I

[PEN-L:8605] Nietzsche and Social Democracy (was Socialism, Social Democracy,Democracy)

1999-06-30 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Michael Keaney to Lou: I'm not sure you do justice to the many positions mentioned above. I share your lack of enthusiasm regarding the pomos, although I had not come across a description of them as "a highly sophisticated version of social democracy" prior to your post. I think Terry Eagleton

[PEN-L:8603] Re: BLS Daily Report and the offending piece

1999-06-30 Thread Tom Walker
More good news? The Washington Post views the record personal savings deficit as "giving the Fed ammunition" to justify a rate rise. But the other side of the coin is that it makes the upward adjustment of interest rates precarious. An increase in debt service costs has to either erode

[PEN-L:8602] Re: (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After the Fallof Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
In his review of David MacGregor's book *Hegel and Marx After the Fall of Communism* (forwarded by Ricardo Duchesne), Nicholas Murray writes: Far from being conservative, however, he emerges from this book as someone who "saw reason, the love of freedom, as an instinctive quality in human

[PEN-L:8601] Re: re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Ken Hanly
Right. I meant ordinal. Thanks. Is your description of Pareto optimality as obfuscatory hogwash generally agreed upon by economists? :) I thought that the rejection of interpersonal comparisons of utlity was based partly upon the view of people such as Von Mises who accept the postivist doctrine

[PEN-L:8600] the right-wing ascendancy

1999-06-30 Thread Doug Henwood
I'm thinking of doing an article on the rise to dominance of right-wing thought in economics social policy in the 1970s. Any PEN-Lers have any thoughts, reminiscences, etc.? Did Milton Friedman's presidency at the AEA mark some kind of turning point? Doug

[PEN-L:8599] re: interpersonal utility comparisons (was Thomas Friedman an economist?)

1999-06-30 Thread Fellows, Jeffrey
Doesn't the process of comparing differences in ordinal rankings bring cardinal rankings back into the function, thereby violating the noncardinality condition? -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, June 30, 1999 10:34 AM To: [EMAIL

[PEN-L:8598] Doug's point and the IMF

1999-06-30 Thread Robert Naiman
I think Doug is right here and have held similar views on this point for a long time. The desire to relive the 30's scenario -capitalism has to be saved from itself and we're the ones to do it --has some bad political consequences other than the ones Doug mentions. This is a problem that

[PEN-L:8597] (Fwd) Review of *Hegel and Marx After the Fall of Communism*

1999-06-30 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
--- Forwarded Message Follows --- Date: Wed, 10 Mar 1999 11:22:45 -0500 (EST) Reply-to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] From: David MacGregor [EMAIL PROTECTED] To:Multiple recipients of list [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Review of *Hegel and Marx After the Fall of

[PEN-L:8596] re: Thomas Friedman an economist?

1999-06-30 Thread Tom Walker
Ken Hanly wrote: COMMENT: But this confirms my point doesn't it? Isn't it a core assumption of neoclassical economists that it is impossible to make interpersonal comparisons of utility? Am I wrong in thinking that? Isn't it standard that among most that only cardinal rankings of utility by

[PEN-L:8595] BLS Daily Report

1999-06-30 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, TUESDAY, JUNE 29, 1999 Personal spending rose 0.6 percent in May, outpacing the 0.4 percent gain in personal income, the Commerce Department reports. Personal saving hit a record low of minus 1.2 percent in May. ... Private wage and salary disbursements increased 0.6 percent

[PEN-L:8594] Re: Whiteness Studies and Its Discontents

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Yoshie has posted some of the most insightful and academically respectable material on racism. I am not an expert on the literature, yet I can say without qualification I am a empirically qualified object of victimization. Some have suggested that my minor accomplishments disqualify me from

[PEN-L:8593] Re: Re: Re: Whiteness Studies and Its Discontents

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Hoover
all analogies being suspect... Michael Hoover On Monday, June 28, 1999 at 21:36:23 (-0400) Yoshie Furuhashi writes: ... ... Besides, it's nearly impossible to discuss race on e-lists in any case, which I think has been proven before. Yes, particularly

[PEN-L:8592] Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
Lou, I thank you for your concern, but I tend to disagree about not debating Brad D. Although he and I disagree much on these lists, sticks and stones will break my bones, but words... But even more, there are many more people in this country who think as Brad D. does, than as I do. Only by

[PEN-L:8591] Apology

1999-06-30 Thread michael
I regret that I had given the impression that Charles Brown had participated in personal attacks. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:8590] Serb dictatorship?

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
[The propaganda war against the Serbs revolves around 3 basic themes: 1) they started the war in Croatia and Bosnia out of a desire to create a Greater Serbia. 2) They woke up one morning in the late 80s and decided to withdraw autonomy in Kosovo for essentially racist reasons. 3) They are

[PEN-L:8588] Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread michael
Louis Proyect wrote: My suggestion to Charles and Henry is to avoid getting bogged down in debates with Professor Delong. As far as I can tell, he is a very upscale sort of troll. Louis, I don't think that this sort of characterization is useful. He knows that PEN-L is not really a haven

[PEN-L:8587] Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
Oh now I remember. You said that in response to Max saying: DeLong, Capitalist Roader: Your unconscionable slanders of the Dear Leader and Grand Poobah will never be swallowed by the masses of alert proletarians, who are keenly aware of their world-historic contributions to progress and human

[PEN-L:8586] Re: Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Louis Proyect
Thanks for the sound advice, Louis. I have also received similar advice off list from others. I guess the Berkley professor is not among those who can be united for the good cause, perhaps not even should be. The bankruptcy of neo-liberal globalization has driven him up the wall. We should just

[PEN-L:8585] Re: Re: On Prevarication (not about racism)

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Thanks for the sound advice, Louis. I have also received similar advice off list from others. I guess the Berkley professor is not among those who can be united for the good cause, perhaps not even should be. The bankruptcy of neo-liberal globalization has driven him up the wall. We should just

[PEN-L:8499] Re: Re: RE: The Theory of Cultural Racism

1999-06-30 Thread Rob Schaap
Says Henry: This is precisely why Hegel, though his views were not racist, could easily lend themselve into logical racism. People can and are diffierent without being better or worse. To insist otherwise will lead towards a dangerous and inhuman path. And substantial chunks of Marxism have

[PEN-L:8574] Re: Re: Neoclassical economics

1999-06-30 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Classical economics centers on man's mechanical response to inflexible economic laws. The concepts of William Stanley Jevons (English 1835-82, value determined by ultility), Karl Menger (Austrian 1840-1921, marginal utlilty) and Leon Walras (French 1834-1910 managed currency) represented

[PEN-L:8575] Re: Re: China

1999-06-30 Thread Michael Keaney
Henry wrote: The current direction of China is another issue which we have discussed at some legenth on this and other lists. This particularly debate is focused on an historical issue: whether Mao purposefully murdered 30 million of his countrymen with an egotistic policy of the Great Leap

[PEN-L:8577] Re: the offending piece

1999-06-30 Thread Charles Brown
Is the below a post from me or Jim D. ? There's no automatic socialism. Charles B. Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 06/29/99 04:43PM In Doug's article, he writes; That faith in inevitable self-destruction has deeply unfortunate political consequences. Even if catastrophist predictions _do_ work

[PEN-L:8579] US NPR on liberal hawks

1999-06-30 Thread Jim Devine
people might be interested in yesterday afternoon's report on US NPR's "All Things Considered" on liberal pro-war attitudes. They quoted a lot of interesting anti-war opponents, including Noam Chomsky, who hardly ever gets media coverage. They also quoted David Rieff (I think I've got his name

  1   2   >