E=T=N=M1=R= M2=C= G1=W=P=G2

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
A theoretical explanation of the foundations of a modern model of neoclassical equilbrium, tolerance and the good society What I omitted to say in reference to the ideology of tolerance Jim Devine asked about, is that what this really refers to is negotiability, i.e. the idea that everything is

Venezuela confronts the FTAA

2003-11-21 Thread michael a. lebowitz
Venezuela confronts the FTAA Michael A. Lebowitz (4 October 2003) Our principle, announced Ramón Rosales (Venezuela’s Minister of Production and Commerce) is “as much market as possible, and as much state as necessary.” What that statement, released at the September 2003 WTO meeting in

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/20/03 12:50:48 PM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Why should I not kick their ass. Do you have kids or just stupid?Melvin, Michael Perelman is probably too busy writing his next book topay attention to this thread but I will not dignify your question with

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Perelman
Melvin, you oppose gay marriage. I think that we all understand that by now. You are welcome to your opinion, but you should not get personal in differing with those who differ from you. Nor should those who differ with you get personal with you. So, please calm down. You made your opinion

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Doyle Saylor
Hello All, I am home today sick. For me, this is a sad moment. I don't look for times like this to take stands they just seem to come to me. When I was young I was assaulted many times as a queer. I didn't even know what that meant. There are certainly many people like Melvin who are in the

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Carrol Cox
Michael Perelman wrote: My original point in mentioning the subject was that gay marriage gets people emotional and prevents rational discourse. I did not expect that observation to apply here on this list. _Every_ issue of any importance to the left gets people emotional, or ought to. And

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Perelman
I agree with everything that Doyle wrote and mostly agree with everything that Carroll wrote. I take issue with his agreement with Lou's statement that a Revolutionary party would have to expel Melvin. I think that Doyle was closer to the mark. He seems to understand that we need to learn to

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Michael Perelman wrote: I take issue with his agreement with Lou's statement that a Revolutionary party would have to expel Melvin. What I said is that if Melvin made remarks at a branch meeting like he made here, he'd be brought up on charges. I know for a fact that lots of older SWP'ers,

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
At the same time, we need to struggle against all injustice, and cannot let toleration blind must to inequities. I wish I knew the formula to achieve this. The Irish formula, from what I understand of it, is that if toleration blinds you to inequities, you get charged, whether you like it or

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Michael wrote: My original point in mentioning the subject was that gay marriage gets people emotional and prevents rational discourse. I did not expect that observation to apply here on this list. Does that mean we could realistically look forward to the next American elections as

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
Doyle Saylor wrote: My only answer to that is the whole working class is the whole working class. We cannot build a socialist society that does not acknowledge all the different elements that build a society and builds a whole society. Thanks, Doyle Well put. Joanna

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
Carrol Cox wrote: As Lou says, a revolutinary party that did not expel Melvin would not be a revolutionary party. Well, if a specific revolutionary party sought human liberation irrespective of wether that human was straight or gay, I assume Melvin would not join this party. Solidarity is

Refs

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Hi Yoshie, You were less dismissive about my argument about advertising. One could think it through from our point of view reading such books as: - Media Hypnosis by Lonny Kocina (Mid-America Entertainment Inc., 2002), - The Fall of Advertising and the Rise of PR by Laura and Al Ries reviewed

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Hoover
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 11/21/03 11:48AM Michael Perelman wrote: I take issue with his agreement with Lou's statement that a Revolutionary party would have to expel Melvin. What I said is that if Melvin made remarks at a branch meeting like he made here, he'd be brought up on charges. I know for a

'Shoot-to-kill' demand by US

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Hoover
'Shoot-to-kill' demand by US Martin Bright, home affairs editor Saturday November 15 2003 The Guardian Home Secretary David Blunkett has refused to grant diplomatic immunity to armed American special agents and snipers travelling to Britain as part of President Bush's entourage this week. In the

Facing South

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Hoover
F A C I N G S O U T H A progressive Southern news report November 19, 2003 - Issue 66 Published by the Institute for Southern Studies and Southern Exposure magazine. To join the Institute and get a year's worth of Southern Exposure and Facing South, visit www.southernstudies.org _

Sports of the Times

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Hoover
Sports of The Times: A Teenager Handling the Adult World With Poise November 20, 2003 By GEORGE VECSEY FREDDY ADU is mature far beyond his 14 years. When he makes a spin move on the soccer field, he leaves opponents chomping on the turf, real or artificial. Adu is also mature in the

Re: Sports of the Times

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
What a wonderful story. It's reassuring that: His mother tells him what to do. For the foreseeable future, he will live at home in suburban Maryland, on her say-so. In return, as man of the house, he protects her. J.

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/21/03 8:12:33 AM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: When I was young I was assaulted many times as a queer. I didn't even knowwhat that meant. There are certainly many people like Melvin who are in theleft and feel they are leftists. To them I am morally

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/21/03 9:30:06 AM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: recp 'comrades' used to kick shit out of gay rcp-er friend of mine for'bourgeois decadence' during 'maoist self-criticism'sessions...he remained member for number of years as this washappening... michael

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Melvin wrote: I maintain that at this juncture of history homosexuality is propagated by the bourgeois and part of the decay and degeneracy in society. The Bolsheviks were outspoken supporters of gay rights. Not only did the Soviet Union abolish all laws against homosexual acts in December, 1917,

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread ravi
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Further, with the acceptance of homosexuality in society a number of social issue arise... ... I teach them that homosexuality is primarily - not exclusively, learned behavior. ... I maintain that at this juncture of history homosexuality is propagated by the

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread ravi
Doyle Saylor wrote: My only answer to that is the whole working class is the whole working class. what is the working class, in terms of unique characteristics or use characteristics that help lend it definition? i am truly puzzled: i go to work each day. i am part of the yuppie privileged

Re: the next wedge issue/end enough of this

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/21/03 11:04:28 AM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Let me repeat this with emphasis: the Soviet government did not viewsame-sex relations as being in any way *sick* or *perverted*. It didnot promote homosexuality, nor did it condemn it. This is all

Re: the next wedge issue/end enough of this

2003-11-21 Thread ravi
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Expel Melvin because he thinks different from me. And my wrong thinking and political assessment is really Stalinism. Because Stalinism did something back n the 1930s. Forget the economic and social content of the times and the political maneuver. The issue is sodomy.

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread andie nachgeborenen
--- joanna bujes [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Carrol Cox wrote: As Lou says, a revolutinary party that Solidarity is not the logic of an idea. I repudiate what Melvin is saying because I don't agree with himnot because PEN-L solidarity (whatever that means) requires that I do so. Joanna:

new economy spillover

2003-11-21 Thread Eubulides
Reefs at risk after Disney film David Fickling in Sydney Friday November 21, 2003 The Guardian A booming trade in aquarium fish, sparked by Finding Nemo, the Disney film featuring clownfish, is endangering the wildlife of the Vanuatu archipelago in the South Pacific. Over the past year about

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Perelman
I think that the debate with Melvin has gone on long enough. Let's call it finished. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/21/03 11:44:27 AM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: i have snipped out all the hand-waving (why, some of my best friends aregay! in fact some of them hit on me!) arguments. i want to hear thefactual basis (outside of the anecdotal evidence that is given) of

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 11/21/03 2:21:36 PM Pacific Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I think that the debate with Melvin has gone on long enough. Let's callit finished.--Michael PerelmanEconomics DepartmentCalifornia State UniversityChico, CA 95929 Sorry I sent another article before I read

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
As far as I am concerned, Justin's position is correct. What people always forget in these disputes about reformism and revolutionism is that the classical debates about this topic, which occurred in Europe, between Kautsky, Bernstein, Lenin, Luxemburg and so on, took place in a historical context

Nitzan on oil

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Perelman
On November 20, two explosions rattled Istanbul, pushing the price of oil up to $32/bbl. Eventually, the rally receded: It's hard to sustain prices at this level,'' said Marshall Steeves, an analyst with Refco Group Ltd. in New York. There has to be a constant stream of unsettling news

Berrigan bros.

2003-11-21 Thread Kenneth Campbell
Michael brought the Berrigans up in the Thread-That-Will-Not-Be-Named. I'd like to underline that point, even though it was only originally mentioned in the context of Catholics and that dogma (and all its facets, liberation theology, etc.). Raised a Catholic, I appreciate reading about what they

Re: Berrigan bros.

2003-11-21 Thread Michael Perelman
Although the thread degenerated, one point I appreciated was Melvin's ability to transcend his abhorrance of gay sex to show solidarity with a gay worker. Almost everybody had useful contributions to the thread, amidst the heat and excessive verbiage. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department

Re: Nitzan on oil

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
Haven't read Nizan yet, but maybe the Iraq campaign was more of a Goldfinger move. Remember Goldfinger? He wanted to render all the gold in Fort Knox radioactive so that _his_ gold would be worth more. One view of the war holds that it was over control of oil. This translates in a lot of people's

Re: Unsubscribe please

2003-11-21 Thread Waistline2
I did not oppose Gay marriage and I do not have to agree with anyone on the politics of maneuver. I oppose the state and my statements are very clear. Although I abhor homosexuality I have never raised it as an issue but responded to the politics of entrapment by the bourgeoisie. The list is a

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
ravi wrote: what is the working class, in terms of unique characteristics or use characteristics that help lend it definition? i am truly puzzled: i go to work each day. i am part of the yuppie privileged class. there's a guy wearing a union t-shirt who installs furniture in my building. am i in

Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread Kenneth Campbell
Joanna wrote: It's interesting,in this regard, to note that all fictional plots involving the rich and the poor changing places, always have a capitalist trade places with a beggar...not a worker. Today, yes, often so. Not always so... One of my fave old movies is the Devil and Miss Jones...

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread ravi
joanna bujes wrote: I also take deep umbrage (I've always wanted to use that phrase) at your characterizing the tonga driver as a wife beater. The notion that the poorer part of the working class is more violent is very untrue in my experience. There's plenty of domestic violence among the

Re: Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
Maybe you mean domesday book [TR Introduction] The first approach to a modern assessment roll or cataster is the well known Domesday Book. The existing literature on this remarkable memorial is so extensive, that it has not appeared advisable to quote largely from it. Our first quotation contains

Re: Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread Kenneth Campbell
Maybe you mean domesday book No, no... I know that Norman accounting tax grab census you mention... I mean the Doomsday Book... you have to see his evil plot to get her comment. And I think, really, the idea of the Corporate Boss hiding in the shoe department, scribbling about unionists in his

Re: the next wedge issue

2003-11-21 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
At 11:48 AM -0500 11/21/03, Louis Proyect wrote: What I said is that if Melvin made remarks at a branch meeting like he made here, he'd be brought up on charges. I know for a fact that lots of older SWP'ers, especially factory workers, felt threatened by woman's and gay liberation but they had the

Norman Solomon responds

2003-11-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Dear Louis, Thanks for your letter. I think you make some good points. When I talk about this, I like to say that the U.S. and U.K. should recuse themselves (as aggressor nations) from U.N. decision-making on Iraq. I agree the rest of the Security Council is hardly pure as to motives, yet the

Re: Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
At 7:46 PM -0500 11/21/03, Kenneth Campbell wrote: It's interesting,in this regard, to note that all fictional plots involving the rich and the poor changing places, always have a capitalist trade places with a beggar...not a worker. Today, yes, often so. Not always so... One of my fave old

Re: Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread bgramlich
In the broadway musical Urinetown the protagonist is a working class man fighting to overthrow the evil company that regulates the only toilets in the area. Then again he does get thrown off of a building before the story is over. But not without first inspiring the CEO's daughter to do what's

Re: Fiction: Rich and poor

2003-11-21 Thread Devine, James
Fritz Lang's _Metropolis_ has the only son (Freder) of the biggest industrialist (Jon Frederson), smitten with an angelic and virginal working-class woman reformer (Maria), descend from the heavenly paradise of the rich and idle to take the place of a laborer in the subterranean hell of

bombings in Turkey

2003-11-21 Thread joanna bujes
From: Sebnem Oguz [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Middle East Socialists Network [EMAIL PROTECTED] ,Discussions on the Socialist Register and its articles [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [MESN] Fw: Terror blasts in Istanbul :atrocities aid Bush's war on terror Date: Fri, 21 Nov 2003 11:40:04 -0500

Senate Committee Tasks Army with Morale Review after Stripes' Report

2003-11-21 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
* Friday, November 21, 2003 Senate committee tasks Army with morale review after Stripes' report By Patrick J. Dickson [EMAIL PROTECTED], Stars and Stripes European edition, Saturday, November 22, 2003 WASHINGTON - The Senate Armed Services Committee on Wednesday tasked the Army with

beltway backlash on farm states pork

2003-11-21 Thread Eubulides
washingtonpost.com Tired of Plain Greed And Subsidies By Steven Pearlstein Friday, November 21, 2003; Page E01 A message to my fellow Americans who chose to live where the wheat waves, the buffalo roam and most rites of passage still involve a pickup truck: I'm sick and tired of having my pocket

Euro-survey: The flat earth society loses again - additional note on public opinion surveys

2003-11-21 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
I still haven't been able to study the methodology of the EU survey on globalisation, but one point I wanted to add, is that we can of course add up quantified observations which really refer to different things. For example, among other things, on my writing desk I have at the moment: 1. a

Lee Harvey Oswald

2003-11-21 Thread Louis Proyect
Last night PBS Frontline aired a fascinating documentary on Who Was Lee Harvey Oswald? (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/oswald/). This show would have had a special resonance with members of the Socialist Workers Party, past or present. In the course of his determined but