Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run

2006-07-05 Thread chromatic
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 23:02, Shlomi Fish n wrote: > I don't see using the X11 licence for my software as anti-social. Like I > said, anyone can easily fork it as a software of a different licence. Supposing you actually find a mentee and TPF actually does fund this project and this code is s

Re: TAP::Harness

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 7/1/06, Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: As my flight is delayed I'll try to make a stab at posting up the basic design. The whole point of replacing the Perl QA wiki was to have a public place for the TAP::Harness design to live. :) http://perl-qa.yi.org/index.php/TAP::Harness

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run

2006-07-05 Thread Shlomi Fish n
On Thursday 06 July 2006 00:36, Jonathan T. Rockway wrote: > Two comments, pretty much agreeing with chromatic and Ricardo: > > 1) How would this proposed module benefit the perl community? Why > can't you fix things in Test::Harness and send the patch in? If you fix > deployed modules, everyone

Re: Test::Builder feature request...

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 2/9/06, Geoffrey Young <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > This works: yes, excellent randy. thanks for that. it still seems a little hackish but that's ok - hackish works for me if it means I can do what I want and nobody else needs to do extra work :) I made some tweaks to your format and added

Re: CPAN and META.yml: no_index dir vs directory

2006-07-05 Thread Johan Vromans
> > no_index/dir 13 > > no_index/directory 1397 > > private/directory40 > As for "dir", I'm three of the 13, I'm another three of the 13, and I'll switch to 'directory' as of the next upload. -- Johan

Re: CPAN and META.yml: no_index dir vs directory

2006-07-05 Thread David Golden
Andreas J. Koenig wrote: The page is there, http://thepierianspring.org/perl/meta/, but does not provide direct statistics so I made up my own. no_index/dir 13 no_index/directory 1397 private/directory40 David's D/DA/DAGOLDEN/Perl-Dist-Vanilla-5 used both dir and directo

Re: CPAN and META.yml: no_index dir vs directory

2006-07-05 Thread Andreas J. Koenig
> On Wed, 5 Jul 2006 21:39:06 -0500, Ken Williams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > On Jul 5, 2006, at 7:47 PM, David Golden wrote: >> Some potential options: >> >> (a) Add "directory" as a synonym to the spec and add "dir" as >> something that CPAN sites recognize. >> >> (b) Change the s

Re: CPAN and META.yml: no_index dir vs directory

2006-07-05 Thread Ken Williams
On Jul 5, 2006, at 7:47 PM, David Golden wrote: Some potential options: (a) Add "directory" as a synonym to the spec and add "dir" as something that CPAN sites recognize. (b) Change the spec to "directory" -- if CPAN sites are the only real user of META.yml no_index, then the pain should

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 7/5/06, Jonathan T. Rockway <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: 1) How would this proposed module benefit the perl community? Why can't you fix things in Test::Harness and send the patch in? If you fix deployed modules, everyone wins. If you write your own module, it sits on CPAN unused. What exac

Re: The new wiki

2006-07-05 Thread Tyler MacDonald
Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Thanks to Tyler MacDonald and yi.org we now have a brand spanking new > wiki! http://perl-qa.yi.org/ is its location, we'll worry about > getting more official domains later. Since I set up my own server for (then nx, now yi).org 8 years ago

The new wiki

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
Thanks to Tyler MacDonald and yi.org we now have a brand spanking new wiki! http://perl-qa.yi.org/ is its location, we'll worry about getting more official domains later. Its a wiki. Go nuts. Err on the side of editing rather than doing nothing. Not sure if something should go on the wiki? P

Module Signatures [was Re: On "Gaming" CPANTS...]

2006-07-05 Thread Jonathan Rockway
> It adds a dependency on a binary application (gpg) that users have to > install by hand, doesn't check for the presence of it properly, and if > you don't have it, installs an enormous chain of dependencies, with said > deps having some major issues of their own. > > It's become bad enough that

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread David Golden
Randy W. Sims wrote: I don't know much about SocialText. Is there a converter, so that if you put something up temporarily in MediaWiki, it can later be converted and moved to SocialText? I know there are a whole series of HTML::WikiConverter dialects on CPAN. I haven't used it, but it seems

CPAN and META.yml: no_index dir vs directory

2006-07-05 Thread David Golden
To the Illuminated Masters of CPAN and META.yml: Apparently, my upload of Perl::Dist::Vanilla spuriously indexed directories that I thought I had listed as "no_index". On examination, it appears that the META.yml spec says to use a "dir" entry under "no_index" whereas PAUSE/CPAN/search.cpan.o

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Randy W. Sims
Michael G Schwern wrote: On 7/5/06, Jonathan T. Rockway <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: The thing about using MediaWiki is that it's not written in Perl. Not that PHP is bad (ok, yes it is bad...), but doesn't it send some sort of negative message when Perl QA doesn't use a Perl-based Wiki? Do I w

Re: On "Gaming" CPANTS, and a Kwalitee Suggestion

2006-07-05 Thread Adam Kennedy
Define "some" please :) Ricardo has said he is, for example. And, "improve compatibility" - with broken systems? OMG. :) You mean we now don't sign packages anymore just because someone isn't able to check the signature? The right way is to tell the user to fix their borken system, not to

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Andy Lester
On Jul 5, 2006, at 5:26 PM, chromatic wrote: If you cannot or will not work with the community, don't be surprised when the community has little interest in working with you. Please also LISTEN to what we're saying. A thread w/Shlomi typically has responses from Shlomi that rebut the co

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Tyler MacDonald
Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> You win! Set it up. Let us know when its online. We'll worry about > >> getting a proper domain/uri for it later. > > > >Done! http://qa.yi.org/ > > Thanks! > > Could you switch that to perl-qa.yi.org? Just to make it clear this > isn't yi.org

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 7/5/06, Tyler MacDonald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 7/5/06, Tyler MacDonald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >I'd be happy to. yi.org is already running a few mediawikis, as well as > >cpants.perl.org. Let me know and I'll get it set up. > > You win

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread chromatic
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 15:02, Shlomi Fish wrote: > Test::Run is licence-compatible with the core. I do not think those words mean what you think they mean. > Some of Test::Run is > licensed under the GPL and Artistic (version 1.0) licence which is the > licence of the perl 5 core. The other

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 7/5/06, Jonathan T. Rockway <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: The thing about using MediaWiki is that it's not written in Perl. Not that PHP is bad (ok, yes it is bad...), but doesn't it send some sort of negative message when Perl QA doesn't use a Perl-based Wiki? Do I worry that qa.perl.org is r

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 23:55, chromatic wrote: > On Wednesday 05 July 2006 12:28, Shlomi Fish wrote: > > I'd like to suggest a generic proposal for the Perl Foundation Grants. > > Note that I'm not going to take it myself, because I just started a new > > job and would like to commit to it. Howe

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 23:51, Ricardo SIGNES wrote: > * Shlomi Fish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2006-07-05T15:28:28] > > > The grant is about Test::Run, which is a fork of Test::Harness that aims > > to greatly refactor and modularise it. I've already revamped and > > re-written a lot of code for it, b

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Jonathan T. Rockway
I'd prefer MediaWiki (that which Wikipedia uses). I'm working on making Socialtext open source right now. I plan to put up a wiki based on it very soon. This sounds like the best idea. The thing about using MediaWiki is that it's not written in Perl. Not that PHP is bad (ok, yes it is

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Tyler MacDonald
Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 7/5/06, Tyler MacDonald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >I'd be happy to. yi.org is already running a few mediawikis, as well as > >cpants.perl.org. Let me know and I'll get it set up. > > You win! Set it up. Let us know when its online. We'll worr

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run

2006-07-05 Thread Jonathan T. Rockway
Two comments, pretty much agreeing with chromatic and Ricardo: 1) How would this proposed module benefit the perl community? Why can't you fix things in Test::Harness and send the patch in? If you fix deployed modules, everyone wins. If you write your own module, it sits on CPAN unused.

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
On 7/5/06, Tyler MacDonald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'd be happy to. yi.org is already running a few mediawikis, as well as cpants.perl.org. Let me know and I'll get it set up. You win! Set it up. Let us know when its online. We'll worry about getting a proper domain/uri for it later.

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Andy Lester
On Jul 5, 2006, at 4:17 PM, Michael G Schwern wrote: We need a new wiki. schwern.org is too anemic to run anything serious (64 megs of RAM, woo!). We need a volunteer with server space to setup and maintain the Perl QA Wiki. I'd prefer MediaWiki (that which Wikipedia uses). It seems the bes

Re: Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Tyler MacDonald
Michael G Schwern <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > These TAP extension proposals and designs for parsers and questions > for details about the TAP grammar... they should all go into the Wiki. > But the Perl QA Wiki sucks. Its slow. Its spammed. UseModWiki > sucks. And I don't have the time to maint

Volunteer wanted: We need a new wiki.

2006-07-05 Thread Michael G Schwern
These TAP extension proposals and designs for parsers and questions for details about the TAP grammar... they should all go into the Wiki. But the Perl QA Wiki sucks. Its slow. Its spammed. UseModWiki sucks. And I don't have the time to maintain it. We need a new wiki. schwern.org is too ane

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread chromatic
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 14:04, Andy Lester wrote: > On Jul 5, 2006, at 3:55 PM, chromatic wrote: > > You want TPF to pay some unspecifed and unidentified other person > > to continue a fork of a core module that can't ever replace the core > > module because of its licensing? > But at least he

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Andy Lester
On Jul 5, 2006, at 3:55 PM, chromatic wrote: You want TPF to pay some unspecifed and unidentified other person to continue a fork of a core module that can't ever replace the core module because of its licensing? But at least he'll act as mentor. -- Andy Lester => [EMAIL PROTECTED] => ww

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread chromatic
On Wednesday 05 July 2006 12:28, Shlomi Fish wrote: > I'd like to suggest a generic proposal for the Perl Foundation Grants. Note > that I'm not going to take it myself, because I just started a new job and > would like to commit to it. However, I can be the mentor for this grant. > I'm posting it

Re: Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Ricardo SIGNES
* Shlomi Fish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2006-07-05T15:28:28] > The grant is about Test::Run, which is a fork of Test::Harness that aims to > greatly refactor and modularise it. I've already revamped and re-written a > lot of code for it, but there's still a lot that needs to be done. [...] > Some o

Re: TAP Grammar

2006-07-05 Thread Chris Dolan
On Jul 3, 2006, at 6:33 PM, chromatic wrote: On Monday 03 July 2006 09:01, Jonathan T. Rockway wrote: That said, I would be interested. I'm still trying to page all the perl6/parrot grammars (PGE, TGE, etc.) into my brain, so any additional examples would helpful, interesting, and fun. Fo

Proposal Suggestion - Test::Run [was Re: [Israel.pm] Fwd: Call for proposals -- Perl Foundation Grants]

2006-07-05 Thread Shlomi Fish
Hi all! I'd like to suggest a generic proposal for the Perl Foundation Grants. Note that I'm not going to take it myself, because I just started a new job and would like to commit to it. However, I can be the mentor for this grant. I'm posting it here to get some reactions before I put it in my

Re: On "Gaming" CPANTS, and a Kwalitee Suggestion

2006-07-05 Thread Tels
Moin, On Wednesday 05 July 2006 17:56, David Golden wrote: > Randy J. Ray wrote: > > I'm a fairly-recent addition to the list. I've read a good part of > > the > > Welcome! > > > Secondly, having recently added digital-signing to a few of my > > modules, perhaps the presence of a SIGNATURE file mi

Re: On "Gaming" CPANTS, and a Kwalitee Suggestion

2006-07-05 Thread David Golden
Randy J. Ray wrote: I'm a fairly-recent addition to the list. I've read a good part of the Welcome! Secondly, having recently added digital-signing to a few of my modules, perhaps the presence of a SIGNATURE file might be a Kwalitee marker (with the caveat that it should be an actual Module::

Re: TAP::Harness

2006-07-05 Thread Geoffrey Young
Geoffrey Young wrote: > I've mentioned the idea of making it simple to use > plan() and Test::More functions before blarg... insert "separately" ^ here. all the rest is pretty simple already :) --Geoff

Re: TAP::Harness

2006-07-05 Thread Geoffrey Young
sorry for dropping in on this late, but it was a holiday weekend :) > * How can I help? > > Provide use cases, what would you want to do with Test::Harness if you > could? What are you doing with Straps? What features do other > testing systems (JUnit, for example) have that you'd like to see i