Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-21 Thread mouss
Chris Dos a écrit : [snip] I have read what the the bounce service does. I wish to intercept ALL hard bounces and process them internally with a script. I don't want it to bounce back to the sender that sent the bad message. I haven't been able to figure out a way to do it yet. If the

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Noel Jones wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: It looks like I want to check for RCPT TO:VERP_Address So I ran this check against the regexp table using postmap: postmap -q RCPT TO:chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com regexp:header_checks.regexp and it came back with a result

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Noel Jones
Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: It looks like I want to check for RCPT TO:VERP_Address So I ran this check against the regexp table using postmap: postmap -q RCPT TO:chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com regexp:header_checks.regexp and it came back

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Noel Jones wrote: I was was reading the header_checks won't work on bounced mail. I setup a regexp check_recipient_access map. This is the regexp file verp_redirect.regexp : /^RCPT TO:.+\+.+\=...@.+\..+$/ REDIRECTverpbounce It's still not working. Here is the postconf -n:

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Noel Jones
Chris Dos wrote: Well, pointing the gun the wrong way is differently something that I don't want to be doing. But in the case, I'm confused. I'm having mail-dr send out to another server, mail.chrisdos.com, on the internet. Mail-DR is a separate mail server all together on a different

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Noel Jones wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Well, pointing the gun the wrong way is differently something that I don't want to be doing. But in the case, I'm confused. I'm having mail-dr send out to another server, mail.chrisdos.com, on the internet. Mail-DR is a separate mail server all together

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: Okay, since the e-mail never finishes sending because the user is unknown on the other end and it is rejected right away, is there another way to do this. The whole point of this exercise for me is to just intercept a bounce back and process it internally

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
-- Chris Dos Senior Engineer Cell: 303-520-1821 Chris Dos wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: Okay, since the e-mail never finishes sending because the user is unknown on the other end and it is rejected right away, is there another way to do this. The whole point of this

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Noel Jones wrote: Okay, since the e-mail never finishes sending because the user is unknown on the other end and it is rejected right away, is there another way to do this. The whole point of this exercise for me is to just intercept a bounce back and process it internally instead of

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Duane Hill
On Fri, 20 Mar 2009, Chris Dos wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: Okay, since the e-mail never finishes sending because the user is unknown on the other end and it is rejected right away, is there another way to do this. The whole point of this exercise for me is to

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-20 Thread Chris Dos
Victor Duchovni wrote: On Fri, Mar 20, 2009 at 07:09:29PM +, Duane Hill wrote: Though now I'm getting this error after sending bounce to pipe: Mar 20 12:41:54 mail-dr postfix/pipe[10163]: warning: unexpected attribute nrequest from bounce socket (expecting: flags) Mar 20 12:41:54

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Costin Guşă
On Tue, Mar 17, 2009 at 11:35 PM, Chris Dos ch...@chrisdos.com wrote: I'm at a loss why this is not working.  I'm sending a VERP SMTP e-mail using the following script: (       echo EHLO $(uname -n)       echo MAIL FROM:ch...@chrisdos.com XVERP       echo RCPT TO:no-one-h...@chrisdos.com  

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Charles Marcus
On 3/17/2009, Chris Dos (ch...@chrisdos.com) wrote: Sorry, I did have: recipient_delimiter = + in another part of my main.cf file. One reason why the DEBUG_README asks (among other things) that you provide output of postconf -n instead of snips from main.cf. -- Best regards, Charles

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Wietse Venema
Chris Dos: Wietse Venema wrote: Chris Dos: relay=mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73]:25, delay=0.19, delays=0.02/0/0.11/0.05, dsn=5.1.1, status=bounced (host mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73] said: 550 5.1.1 chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com: Recipient address rejected: User

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Chris Dos
Charles Marcus wrote: On 3/17/2009, Chris Dos (ch...@chrisdos.com) wrote: Sorry, I did have: recipient_delimiter = + in another part of my main.cf file. One reason why the DEBUG_README asks (among other things) that you provide output of postconf -n instead of snips from main.cf. Here is

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Chris Dos
Wietse Venema wrote: That is what YOU believe. You probably made a typo somewhere. This is why you should post postconf -n command output, as requested in the mailing list welcome message which you decided to ignore. I don't believe that header addresses contain ONLY an e-mail address.

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Noel Jones
Chris Dos wrote: Wietse Venema wrote: That is what YOU believe. You probably made a typo somewhere. This is why you should post postconf -n command output, as requested in the mailing list welcome message which you decided to ignore. I don't believe that header addresses contain ONLY an

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Chris Dos
Noel Jones wrote: It looks like I want to check for RCPT TO:VERP_Address So I ran this check against the regexp table using postmap: postmap -q RCPT TO:chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com regexp:header_checks.regexp and it came back with a result of DISCARD. So I guess I don't

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Noel Jones
Chris Dos wrote: Noel Jones wrote: It looks like I want to check for RCPT TO:VERP_Address So I ran this check against the regexp table using postmap: postmap -q RCPT TO:chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com regexp:header_checks.regexp and it came back with a result of DISCARD. So I guess

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-18 Thread Chris Dos
I don't see a forward action in header_checks. Maybe you intend to use REDIRECT? Postfix access tables allow more than accept/reject, including REDIRECT. http://www.postfix.org/access.5.html But my point is that header_checks are the wrong tool for the job. There is no guarantee that

VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-17 Thread Chris Dos
I'm at a loss why this is not working. I'm sending a VERP SMTP e-mail using the following script: ( echo EHLO $(uname -n) echo MAIL FROM:ch...@chrisdos.com XVERP echo RCPT TO:no-one-h...@chrisdos.com echo DATA echo From: ch...@chrisdos.com echo To:

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-17 Thread Wietse Venema
Chris Dos: relay=mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73]:25, delay=0.19, delays=0.02/0/0.11/0.05, dsn=5.1.1, status=bounced (host mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73] said: 550 5.1.1 chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com: Recipient address rejected: User unknown in local recipient table (in reply

Re: VERP Bounce Intercept

2009-03-17 Thread Chris Dos
Wietse Venema wrote: Chris Dos: relay=mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73]:25, delay=0.19, delays=0.02/0/0.11/0.05, dsn=5.1.1, status=bounced (host mail.chrisdos.com[71.33.251.73] said: 550 5.1.1 chris+no-one-home=chrisdos@chrisdos.com: Recipient address rejected: User unknown in local