[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

### November 19, 2020 AI review: none Pulp 3: * Do we need to generate SQLiteDBs at all? * https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7851 * https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7852 * https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7842 * introduce a switch, the default is not to generate sqlite metadata * black PR:

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

### October 29, 2020 AI review: none Pulp 3: * Need to be able to specify a custom 'gpgkey' string for a Publication. * Should do a new release - any blockers? * check for deprecations in pulpcore that affect the plugin * decide at next week's meeting Pulp 2: * 2.21.4 release

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review: none Pulp 3: * Content upload API improvement: https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7708 * Valid UX problem, could be difficult to fix "correctly" * Potentially changes necessary to the task response * Pulp 4 change? * Multi-repo copy issues: https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7625

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting Pulp 3: * Sprint items https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=161 * Grant will work on the copy issue and a pulp2 bug which already has a patch to support Amazon Linux repositories * Pavel will likely cover the

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting AI review: - github merge options - done Pulp 3: - As a Pulp Rpm user, I can have my repository synced, auto published and distributed https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7622 - need to add more details before grooming - Pulp

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting General: - github merge options - leave only rebase option Pulp 3: - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7537 - Would like to get into the pulp_rpm 3.8 if possible - +1 - depending on the effort it might

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting AI review: - ttereshc to investigate slow sync/publish for smart proxies in pup2 - ggainey to look at power kickstart https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7303 Pulp 3: - proxy issue https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7321 - distribution tree

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting AI review - ask katello if 3.6.1 release is needed 3.6.1. is out General: - commit bit for ggainey - agreed Pulp 3: - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7298 - put on the sprint for investigation for import/export issue

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Also available here: https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting AI review - ttereshc will create a hackmd doc for agenda/notes - ttereshc to take a look at pulp-internal list about fixing checksum mismatch Pulp 3: - 3.6.1 - file downloader is fixed - ask katello if release is

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

The agenda with the meeting notes are now public https://hackmd.io/@pulp/rpm_meeting. Feel free to add any items which require RPM mini-team attention. We meet once a week to go through the agenda items. Notes from yesterday: Pulp 3: - As a user, I want to be able to use ansible to manage a

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Distribution Tree model changes - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1782 - 3.5 branching/release once DistTree change is merged - UpdateCollection model fixes and uniqueness - in progress Pulp 2: - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7141 - closed

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review - ddavis to update 7096 with more explanation - Bmbouters to add comment to 7095 - Ppicka/dkliban to investigate 5847 (fix merged) Pulp 3: -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review - AI: ppicka to discuss relative-path investigation with Many Interested Parties, This meeting. - AI: daviddavis to file an issue RE “repo can have more than one distribution tree” - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7115 Pulp 3: - Distribution tree copy

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review - AI: dkliban will add commentary to issue - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7046#note-3 Pulp 3: - Distribution tree copy bug https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7046 - High prio - “retain_package_versions”

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Kickstarts copy issue https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7046 - Lots of discussion - AI: dkliban will add commentary to issue - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/7046#note-3 - Retain old count - Basically done - writing a test,

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review - discuss if other relations for comps needs to be removed or only packages to groups - bmbouter to remove ‘Pulp3 RPM blocker’ tag - dkliban to try to come up with rough design during the sprint https://pulp.plan.io/issues/5200 - started -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - comps.xml relation issues - PR for PackageGroups which removes relations completely - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1745 - Backward incompatible change in REST API - Ok, because it’s a bug fix

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review: - None Pulp 3: - Mirrorlist feature - Lubos updated PR, ipanova to review - Progress report. Seems like GroupProgressReport proposal is ok - Please provide feedback if there is any. ipanova to groom and put on the sprint the story after.

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

AI review - dalley to email amatej w/r to the drpm library support - dkliban takes AI to write up cert-getting ticket - ppicka to talk to dkliban and file an issue about suse auth token - ttereshc to file an issue about import/export -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - AI review - 3.3.2 is out with the upgrade fix - Features - SUSE repos, auth token - Retain old count 5367 - EVR comparison - Ggainey’s cut at it

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/6699 - Core change - bmbouter to put a complete proposal - Release 3.3.1 is out, 3.3.2 is planned - Features - Estimate for mirroring metadata https://pulp.plan.io/issues/6353 -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Release 3.3.1 - Yes, the sooner the better, some critical bug fixes are merged - Features - Mirrorlist support - Needs review https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1690 - config.repo feature from @lieter -

Re: [Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

> > >- > >From now on, add functional tests at the same time as features >- > > At least a happy path > > +1 - Let's start building this into feature delivery estimates and commitments to stakeholders Robin Chan She/Her/Hers Satellite Software Engineering Manager - Pulp Red

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - 3.3.0 is released - From now on, add functional tests at the same time as features - At least a happy path - List of RPM features to test and/or to ensure are present in the docs - AI: Please review areas you are familiar with and which you

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - 3.3.0 release is on the way (various issues along the way which didn’t let to release earlier) - Focus on bug fixes and tests - Features - Lubos started on mirrorlist support - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/6225 -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Query for the upcoming release - https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=149 - Copy API docs - Maybe we can publish them after the release? +1 - PR reviews - “Relative_path” problem

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Query for items to be done for Katello release https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=149 - Priorities for Katello from the items which are not merged - Checksum type configuration for a publication - more tests added

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - “Relative_path” problem - https://www.redhat.com/archives/pulp-dev/2020-April/msg0.html - Doesn’t block critical work - Query for items to be done for Katello release https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=149 -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - A query for items to be done for Katello release https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=149 - Waiting on Katello to review and mark what is needed for the early-April release - DRPM support - Likely is needed for Katello

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy - In 3.3.0 beta 1 - Import/export - Initial CRUD for Exporter in progress. - PR should be ready for review today hopefully. Debugging an openapi issue. - Other features - Opensuse - Open

Re: [Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Forgot to add for Pulp 3: - Metadata signing merged - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4812 On Thu, Mar 12, 2020 at 5:43 PM Tatiana Tereshchenko wrote: > Pulp 3: > >- > >Copy >- > > Merged, waiting on testing from Katello > - > > Beta may be released ‘today’ >

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy - Merged, waiting on testing from Katello - Beta may be released ‘today’ - Tests - conversion to bindings - S3 test has some issues, hte rest are done - Finish and get signoff today? -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy API Status (dalley out-of-office) - General API shape + implementation: done - Depsolving: done - Incremental update: done - Multi-repo-copy: almost done - just need to hook the backend to the API properly, no

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy status - Depsolving: DONE - Incremental Update: Almost done - Multi-repo-copy: Almost done - API: - Need to check with Katello that their needs are met - Need to work out how to accept

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Reminder to mark bugfixes which needs to be cherry picked - PR author and reviewer should check that - Remaining features for katello 3.16 which have redmine tickets in new and not assigned - Copy - Importers/exporters -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Support repos with primary.xml only https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1627372 - Question is whether to support them or not? - Probably no, David will comment on the BZ and close in a week if there is no disagreement. -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy API work - No change since last meeting, David out, Daniel doing other work - Libsolv python 3 bindings (python3-libsolv subpackage RPM) - Also missing .egg-info / .dist-info - Probably possible to package as a Python package, not

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

>From last week. Pulp 3: - Distribution trees (main topic, Katello devs are joining this time) - Currently pulp implementation assumes that there is a main repo - It might not be correct because there can be multiple variants and no main repo -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Applicability - Summary of the discussion w/ Katello about ownership of applicability feature - AI: [ggainey] check in with jsherrill RE moving applicability discussion to pulp-dev - Copy -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Copy API discussion (continued) - Complex unified endpoint vs content-type specific endpoints + accumulative changes (repository versions created by many tasks + “commit”) - leaning towards the unified endpoint - Keep epic story up to

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - 1770940 - figured out why there’s a performance difference, now need to figure out what to do about it - Katello calls differ (no clone distributor is used), Pulp does publish in the same way -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Sat 6.6 publish performance issue bug(s) - investigating - 1770940 - 1773601 Pulp 3: - Blockers

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - #5658 - modulemd_defaults and copy - Potential fix in hand, PR today or tomorrow - Dep solving performance concerns - https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1771780 Pulp 3: - Blockers

Re: [Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Hi Ales, Thanks for confirmation! I'll definitely file BZs when we analyze and figure out all the differences and what is needed. It was a quick pre-GA discussion about the path forward when we need to add opensuse advisories. Tanya ___ Pulp-dev

Re: [Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

On Thu, Nov 7, 2019 at 10:04 PM Neal Gompa wrote: > On Thu, Nov 7, 2019 at 3:48 PM Tatiana Tereshchenko > wrote: > > > > Advisory > > > > Opensuse advisory > > > > some fields differs (reboot_suggested != restart_suggested) > > > > These are not the same fields. The restart_suggested field

Re: [Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

On Thu, Nov 7, 2019 at 3:48 PM Tatiana Tereshchenko wrote: > > Advisory > > Opensuse advisory > > some fields differs (reboot_suggested != restart_suggested) > These are not the same fields. The restart_suggested field indicates that the update tool should restart itself after this update is

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - 5359 /BZ#1744225 closed WONTFIX - Investigating 5658 Pulp 3: - Blockers https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=139 - All RPM endpoints, go/no-go

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 3: - Blockers (aim is to close all by pulpcore dev freeze) - https://pulp.plan.io/projects/pulp_rpm/issues?query_id=139 - 3-4 docs, can be done after dev freeze - Few refactors - soft blockers - The rest must be done

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - MONGO_X509 auth PR in - discussions w/ewoud about impacts on Katello installation - not pulp_rpm specific Pulp 3: - 3.0.0b7 released - Blockers status - Couple are waiting on 3541 https://pulp.plan.io/issues/3541 - If you have

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

- Modularity update (ppicka) - PR for upload sent - Comps.xml (dana) - Sync PR was blocked by segfault bug in libcomps, using workaround - Github issue filed: https://github.com/rpm-software-management/libcomps/issues/54 -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Pulp 2.21.0 GA going out today (24 hr delay due to docs build issues) - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/5447 - should add this to 2.21.1 - non-RPM specific Pulp 3: - Modularity update (ppicka) - Sync and publish are merged - Comps.xml update

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General: - Make the meeting optional? +1 - Make sure to fill the agenda and updates at least the day before, so others will know whether they should attend or not - Don’t plan anything on purpose for this time, in case you’ll be needed for a discussion

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Multi-repo copy update (dalley) - 2 PRs, got approval from 1 reviewer, will be good to get a second reviewer - https://github.com/pulp/pulp/pull/3947 - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1420 - Daniel will continue to test

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Multi-repo copy update (dalley) - PRs ready for review - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1420/ - https://github.com/pulp/pulp/pull/3947 - Docs changes remain - Still no smash tests, will work with QE on this,

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Multi-repo copy update (dalley) - 2 PRs - https://github.com/pulp/pulp/pull/3947 - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1420 - Still testing the 2nd one, not returning exactly the same results yet for the standard test cases

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Dep solving - Finished the part which interacts with libsolv (the multi-repo copy feature is the last one left to close the dep solving features/bugs for pulp2) - No smash tests for the new stuff yet - *AI*: dalley will work with

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General: - Fabricio joined RPM mini-team. Welcome! Pulp 2: - Dependency solving - 3 PRs in progress - Address copying module-defaults with modules - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1400 - Blocked on

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Modularity dep solving - automatic module_default copy works!! but is buggy, *crashes* - under investigation - "too many packages/modules are copied" issue - clear what to do, just needs to be done - Multiple source/target repositories support for recursive

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

*June **2**7**, 2019* Pulp 2: - Modularity dep solving - fixes are not in 2.20.0 for now - refactoring and future PR: - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1383 - issue with dependencies being spread across multiple repos - discussion with Katello is planned

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Modularity bug updates https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4693 - a lot of progress - smash test is written, thanks to bherring Pulp 3: - JFYI, version for the master branch has been updated - master branch should always refer to .dev - more attention is needed

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Modularity bug updates https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4693 - investigation in progress - dalley planned to collaborate with QE Pulp 3: - bindings - docs updated - announcement sent - bmbouter/dkliban gave overview of how bindings are generated and

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Modularity bug updates https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4693 - As noted, erroneous behavior reproduced w/ modules in the Fedora modules repo - It seems like a lot of modules are copied correctly, but some aren't. Trying to figure out the pattern. -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

*May **23**, 2019* Pulp 2: - schedule for 2.20 - dkliban and ttereshc discussed it the other day - ttereshc to put it together today Pulp 3: - simple copy PR https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1328 - there were some merge conflicts but its fixed now and ready to

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - Some old issues which are fixed are still at ON_QA. daviddavis will move it to CLOSED-CURRENTRELEASE - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/3047 - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/3100 - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/3115 - 2.19.1 work - low participation, probably

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2: - Dev freeze for 2.19.1 is May 14 - Look for the pulp2 issues of the sprint, most of them should be fixed for 2.19.1 - the nice-to-have ones have comments that they are not critical to go into 2.19.1 specifically. - dkliban set platform release for 2.19.1

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2: - many Pulp 2 items are on the sprint, including publish dir race condition - any deadlines/priorities? - need them in 2.19.1 (tentatively by the end of May) - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4534 Searching for modulemd_defaults without "profiles" field will crash:

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - High priority issues? - publish race condition https://pulp.plan.io/issues/3098 - not RPM specific but affects RPM plugin as well (mostly noticeable for the Docker plugin) - volunteer is needed - Pulp 2 RPM bugs, mass closing - AI:

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General: - ppicka joined RPM mini-team - welcome :) Pulp 2: - dkliban to plan release of 2.19.1 soon to release the migration issue https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4617 and other bugfixes which will be completed in time for the release - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4631 Pulp

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General: - changes in Fedora 30 - remaining items are being evaluated (see details in the previous e-mail) Pulp2 - there are few issues on the sprint, nothing urgent at the moment Pulp3 - installer updates - bmbouter plans to work with asmacdo in the upcoming days

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General: - We should track changes in Fedora and evaluate impact on Pulp - https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Releases/30/ChangeSet - any volunteers? - Daniel(@dalley) - Possibly relevant changes: - Zchunk Metadata

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2 - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4477 modular errata publication issue - on the sprint - should it be considered as a blocker for upcoming 2.19.0 - ttereshc will work on it - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4541 packages are published twice, in different layouts -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2 - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4477 modular errata publication issue - needs to be worked on sooner rather than later, added to the sprint Pulp3 - Sync is failing https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4505#note-2 - likely a problem in core but easy to reproduce with RPM plugin

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2 - recursive copy docs https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4371 , in progress - should be done today - new libsolv package, QE are blocked - if no news from the build team by the end of the week, bring up on Monday meeting Pulp3 - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4424 -

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp2: - https://github.com/pulp/pulp_rpm/pull/1269 approved, about to merge +1 +1 - AI: Ina to check with stakeholders if there is any required release date - checked, we can release according to our schedule Pulp 3: - https://pulp.plan.io/issues/4424 - How

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General discussion: - The commit bit to pulp/pulp_rpm has been given to QE team. - Codeowners [0] for functional tests in pulp/pulp_rpm - Agreed to add - AI: David to open PR to add codeowners. Add some docs to wiki. Pulp 2: - Potentially an issue with sync of Fedora 29

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

General discussion: - We had a discussion about a commit bit to pulp/pulp_rpm for QE team. Everyone who was present is on board. Many team members were out today, so the final decision is deferred till they are back. Pulp 2: - Modularity issues are solved and merged, thanks to

[Pulp-dev] RPM plugin meeting notes

Pulp 2: - modularity issues are on the sprint [0], dalley is working on them. - module dep solving story [1], dalley or jortel will take a look at the corresponding PR to see if it requires any adjustments Pulp 3: - Agreement reached with the stakeholders that it's ok to publish