[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-22 Thread Arino, Joseph via sig-policy
Hi Aftab, Thanks. I will be attending in person the upcoming APNIC 55 Open Policy Meeting on March 1 at Sofitel Hotel. Maybe we can have more discussion on this toipic. Thank you. [cid:image001.jpg@01D94773.53B237A0] Joseph Kenneth Arino IP Planning & Engineering, Telstra (AS4637) 110 Paya

[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-22 Thread Arino, Joseph via sig-policy
Hi Aftar and all, I am interested on this topic coz we have similar cases where our customer (using Private ASN) who advertised their own IP block to us (AS4637) via eBGP. Thank you. [cid:image001.jpg@01D9476E.B79A07C0] Joseph Kenneth Arino IP Engineering, Telstra (AS4637) From: Aftab

[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-22 Thread Aftab Siddiqui
Hi Joseph and Vivek, SLURM was designed for specifically this kind of use case (and others as well). A ROA with Private ASN has significance for the upstream of that particular operator and no one else. If I see a ROA with 65530 as origin but can't see that origin in the routing table then it has

[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-22 Thread Vivek Nigam
Hi Aftab, When we questioned this Member why they created the route and ROA with private ASN, they informed us that their upstream requested them to create it. It was related to some automation/security feature their upstream was using to fix routing issues. Thanks Vivek From: Aftab Siddiqui

[sig-policy] Re: prop-151-v001: Restricting non hierarchical as-set

2023-02-22 Thread Aftab Siddiqui
Hi Vivek and Anupam b, On the point that why the policy will not be enforced on the existing non-hierarchical AS-SET as mentioned in the impact section. 6. Impact on resource holders - APNIC has to request members to update their non hierarchical as-set as a new

[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-22 Thread Aftab Siddiqui
Thanks to George I saw the recording of policy webinar, Hi vivek, can you share more details about the incident where an operator gave a reason to create a ROA with private ASN? RFC1930 - Guidelines for creation of an AS - Section 10 Reserved AS Numbers The Internet Assigned Numbers Authority