Dear all,
I can tell you my real experience with APNIC, when I want to transfer my unused
IP ranges to a Singapore based ISP from my account, they deny it!! That is
ridiculous! They said I cannot transfer! I cannot believe it if the IP address
I owned but I cannot transfer it to a new owner.
C
Hi,
The justification for the needs was/is great to have in place to protect a
free pool of scarce resources.
Maintaining a correct registry, with the proper information is one of the
core responsibilities of the RIRs, and as a community we must develop
policies that allows the RIR to do that job
I disagree…
I believe that needs testing still preserves the idea of distributing addresses
to those with need even in a post-exhaustion world.
This serves to discourage speculative transactions and other transfers to those
not actually needing addresses which would only drive prices up and not
Hello all,
I agreed that APNIC should accept all transfer without question because IP
resource could be count into a assets to the IP holder in accounting. That's
mean the ip holder have the right to request transfer to or from other APNIC
members or other RIR.
Ernest Tse
Sent from Mobile
>
Hi Aftab,
This is only to simplify things, need based policies are there to protect
the free pool from exhaustion and ensure fair distribution.
Space that is already out there can already be transferred without much
hassle, removing the need base justification just simplifies the whole
process, m
