Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread Ode Coyote
To: mailto:silver-list@eskimo.comsilver-list@eskimo.com Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please It has been suggested that to protect from agyria when taking CS longterm, Selenium should also be taken. I have also been informed that supplemental selenium long term can be toxic. Maybe daily brazil nuts is a better

Re: CSRebuttals please-could silver cause selenium problems

2007-12-19 Thread marmar845
Hi. Yes, you are correct that we are talking about a horse. Thanks for your considered reply. MA -- Original message from ekowal...@aol.com: -- Unfortunately I can't say anything to disprove it and I won't say it's impossible either though I doubt it. Nutrients

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread faith gagne
- Original Message - From: Ode Coyote odecoy...@alltel.net To: silver-list@eskimo.com Sent: Wednesday, December 19, 2007 4:58 AM Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please Just because something is toxic if you get too much built up, doesn't mean that you can live without it. Copper and Zinc

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread marmar845
Hi Marshall. Thanks for your reply. It's interesting that in all the years that I've been a member of this list, I don't ever remember this fact being discussed. In fact, silver has been discussed here as being safer than the gallons of water that can be consumed in order to access it. But

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread marmar845
Hi Tony. Thanks for your response. Apparently she used CS to treat her horse for Lyme disease, and was made aware somehow that her horse's selenium deficiency was a consequence of the CS. On our EPM list, many of us have used CS to treat our horses for EPM and none of us, to my knowledge,

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread marmar845
Hi Ode. Thanks for your response -- it's appreciated. MA -- Original message from Ode Coyote odecoy...@alltel.net: -- Almost EVERY mineral supplement depletes that other mineral supplement, Selenium. It's what happens when Selenium does it's job of

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread Dee
Well, I actually did do research on this Chuck, and everything I came up with was that it was beneficial. I also realize that dosing is everything and that it is stupid to overdose on things like metals. Dee ---Original Message--- Dee, It's all in the dose. Up to

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread Dee
was a child. Dee ---Original Message--- From: Dianne France Date: 19/12/2007 01:24:35 To: silver-list@eskimo.com Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please Dee It is very beneficial. There are other factors you need to factor in. In horses if you lack selenium they won't grow out as tall

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-19 Thread GMetropulo
In a message dated 12/19/07 10:39:29 AM, d...@deetroy.org writes: metals.  Dee  What about long term overdosing on silver for chronic issues? ** See AOL's top rated recipes (http://food.aol.com/top-rated-recipes?NCID=aoltop000304)

Re: CSRebuttals please-could silver cause selenium problems

2007-12-18 Thread Dee
Maybe its another case of the old adage being applied; i.e. Only use when necessary and everything in moderation. Dee ---Original Message--- From: ekowal...@aol.com Date: 12/18/07 00:57:58 To: silver-list@eskimo.com Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please-could silver cause selenium

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Ode Coyote
Almost EVERY mineral supplement depletes that other mineral supplement, Selenium. It's what happens when Selenium does it's job of regulating levels of metallic micro-nutrients. In that respect, silver is no different than copper and copper is quite abundant in nature and unavoidable.

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Ode Coyote
: CSRebuttals please -- Original message from Dianne France mailto:dianne_fra...@hotmail.comdianne_fra...@hotmail.com: -- MarMar Do you know the state where this person resides? Is the area he stables his horse selenium deprived? The CS might not be a factor. Hi

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread GMetropulo
It has been suggested that to protect from agyria when taking CS longterm, Selenium should also be taken. I have also been informed that supplemental selenium long term can be toxic. Maybe daily brazil nuts is a better option to protect from agyria and depletion.

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Dee
Why are we having all this about selenium being highly toxic now? I have just ordered some because I thought it was beneficial! Dee ---Original Message--- From: gmetrop...@aol.com Date: 18/12/2007 14:03:52 To: silver-list@eskimo.com Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please It has been

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Marshall Dudley
marmar...@bellsouth.net wrote: The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I caution anyone using the Colloidal silver for an extended period of time. It depletes the body of selenium. I have personaly used it on my lyme disease

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Marshall Dudley
marmar...@bellsouth.net wrote: -- Original message from Dianne France dianne_fra...@hotmail.com: -- MarMar Do you know the state where this person resides? Is the area he stables his horse selenium deprived? The CS might not be a factor.

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Tony Moody
On 17 Dec 2007 at 21:00, marmar...@bellsouth.net wrote about : Subject : CSRebuttals please The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I caution anyone using the Colloidal silver for an extended period of time. It depletes

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Del
: CSRebuttals please Why are we having all this about selenium being highly toxic now? I have just ordered some because I thought it was beneficial! Dee ---Original Message--- From: gmetrop...@aol.com Date: 18/12/2007 14:03:52 To: silver-list@eskimo.com

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread cking001
On 12/18/2007 9:18:03 AM, Dee (d...@deetroy.org) wrote: Why are we having all this about selenium being highly toxic now? I have just ordered some because I thought it was beneficial! Dee Dee, It's all in the dose. Up to 400 micrograms daily is listed as safe. Always be careful of mettalic

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-18 Thread Dianne France
: Tuesday, December 18, 2007 9:18 AM Subject: Re: CSRebuttals please Why are we having all this about selenium being highly toxic now? I have just ordered some because I thought it was beneficial! Dee ---Original Message--- From: gmetrop

CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread marmar845
The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I caution anyone using the Colloidal silver for an extended period of time. It depletes the body of selenium. I have personaly used it on my lyme disease gelding, and this was how I found

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread Carol Ann
Did the poster say exactly how this information was derived or to how the CS was specifically related to selenium depletion ie. Tests, etc. marmar...@bellsouth.net wrote: The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread Dianne France
-list@eskimo.commailto:silver-list@eskimo.com Sent: Monday, December 17, 2007 4:00 PM Subject: CSRebuttals please The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I caution anyone using the Colloidal silver for an extended period

CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread marmar845
-- Original message from Carol Ann saffiresk...@yahoo.com: -- Did the poster say exactly how this information was derived or to how the CS was specifically related to selenium depletion ie. Tests, etc. Hi Carol. No -- there was no substantiation. Just the

CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread marmar845
-- Original message from Dianne France dianne_fra...@hotmail.com: -- MarMar Do you know the state where this person resides? Is the area he stables his horse selenium deprived? The CS might not be a factor. Hi Dianne. No -- I don't know where this person

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread leslie1053
I found out that mercury depletes selenium. Just thought I'd throw that in. Leslie - Original Message - From: marmar...@bellsouth.net To: silver-list@eskimo.com Sent: Monday, December 17, 2007 5:29 PM Subject: CSRebuttals please -- Original message from

Re: CSRebuttals please-could silver cause selenium problems

2007-12-17 Thread Ekowal459
Unfortunately I can't say anything to disprove it and I won't say it's impossible either though I doubt it. Nutrients are often antagonistic to each other. When some ratios are thrown far out of kilter, deficiencies can be antagonized. Calcium and magnesium are antagonistic

RE: CSRebuttals please-could silver cause selenium problems

2007-12-17 Thread bob Larson
included but here's what i take plenty extra supplementally for this purpose: chlorella/spirulina blend selenium C E MSM water -Original Message- From: ekowal...@aol.com [mailto:ekowal...@aol.com] Sent: Monday, December 17, 2007 7:57 PM To: silver-list@eskimo.com Subject: Re: CSRebuttals

Re: CSRebuttals please

2007-12-17 Thread Del
Subject: CSRebuttals please The following post came through one of my equine lists. Can anyone here comment on this please? MA I caution anyone using the Colloidal silver for an extended period of time. It depletes the body of selenium. I have personaly used it on my lyme disease