RE: Home sprinkler mandate in MN

2013-05-01 Thread Cahill, Christopher
First, To be clear, in MN any way, the legislation is the cities or state code authorities can't force sprinklers. It does not ban them. B, does not the gov't and especially the legislature have immunities to being sued. I'd think sprinklers are the least the legislature has done to hurt and

Re: Old style deflector

2013-05-01 Thread Thomas Watt
Someone in this group is likely to have the answer and an example to prove it. https://www.facebook.com/Collecting.Old.Fire.Sprinkler.Heads On Wed, May 1, 2013 at 10:16 AM, Todd Williams t...@fpdc.com wrote: Did they make heads for regular use with the old small deflector in 1954? Todd G

Re: Home sprinkler mandate in MN

2013-05-01 Thread Ron Greenman
I'm no lawyer so don't trust me 100% 0n any legal stuff, but to my understanding State agencies cannot be held criminally libel unless there is a policy of ignoring their public charge. State agencies can be sued, as well as individual employees in civil matters. This I know for sure since I work

RE: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread curtis
Distinguished Forum Members; Let me begin by saying that everyone in West lost something, and in no small measure. The owners of the plant lost their business, yes. But they also knew the employees and fire fighters that were lost. They knew the people who lost their homes, several of which,

RE: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread David Autry
I know of a 500,000 sq ft one of these in Texas. I'm not sure how much of the bad stuff they have, but at 500,000 sq ft I bet it's tons more than West. I could go on, but it's protected with sprinklers. Even with sprinklers, I hope the first responders in this county learned from West and know

RE: Old style deflector

2013-05-01 Thread Sprinkler Academy - C Bilbo
Todd, The Standard Spray sprinkler was researched and began being used in the late 40's on FM insured projects. The conventional sprinkler remained the sprinkler of choice in NFPA 13 until the 1955 edition. The research done by FM convinced the committee of the superior effectiveness of

Re: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread Todd - Work
We can be gentle with the people and the community in general, but there appears to be negligence at many levels. Those that circumvent their job, cover up problems or knowingly put others at risk do not deserve that respect. If a business that provided jobs and economic vitality knowingly

RE: Corrosion Resistant Pipe

2013-05-01 Thread Nicky Marshall
Stainless steel pipe would be suitable Perhaps copper too. Nicky Marshall Branch Manager (Blenheim) Protech Design Specialist Fire Protection Consultants 03 579 5577 021 433 488 www.protechdesign.co.nz skype: nicky-marshall 105A Alabama Rd, Redwoodtown, Blenheim 7201, New Zealand PO Box 4022,

RE: Corrosion Resistant Pipe

2013-05-01 Thread John Denhardt
Agree, but the question asked about steel piping. John August Denhardt, P.E., FSFPE Strickland Fire Protection Incorporated 5113 Berwyn Road College Park, Maryland 20740 Office Telephone Number: 301-474-1136 Mobile Telephone Number: 301-343-1457 FIRE SPRINKLERS SAVE LIVES - Can you live without

Re: Old style deflector

2013-05-01 Thread George Church
That well-rounded education is very useful in the workplace. Like the NICET testing forcing us to look at various segments of the industry and see it presented in a complete set of pipe charts. One sees all available so if someone brings up or specs on something OTHER than what we all use- sch

Re: Old style deflector

2013-05-01 Thread Ron Greenman
Stay on that box George. On Wed, May 1, 2013 at 1:56 PM, George Church g...@rowesprinkler.com wrote: That well-rounded education is very useful in the workplace. Like the NICET testing forcing us to look at various segments of the industry and see it presented in a complete set of pipe

Re: Home sprinkler mandate in MN

2013-05-01 Thread bverhei
Yes, Chris, I don't give legal advice, but under our legal system government is not sued for failure to regulate. Take automobiles. A whole raft of features have been shown to reduce fatalities. Each has taken years to be implemented. Padded dashboards, laminated safety glass, brake systems

Re: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread bverhei
We don't know that how the fire ignited, spread, how the chemical storage became involved or exploded. We do know that there we a variety of chemicals on-site that had potential to harm neighbors. These chemicals act different and can hurt responders in ways that are different from their common

Re: Home sprinkler mandate in MN

2013-05-01 Thread Ron Greenman
Government could have been sued if legislation existed that mandated safety features could not be added, actively interfering, and thereby creating a harm. Government cannot be sued for non-participation though. Government can be sued for breach of contract and I've seen this happen over and over,

Re: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread Ron Greenman
I liked that response Bruce. Particularly the last lines about will. And if they actually did have the quantities of chemicals reported in any of the reports it was several times to way too many times relative to the mandated quantity hat triggers the need to report that to a higher authority. Had

Re: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread Ron Greenman
How 'bout this Bruce? The Navy wanted to disband the fire department at the fuel depot on the grounds that they had a mutual assistance agreement with Manchester and so they no longer needed their own fire department. Wanna bet the Navy FD was better equipped to handle house fires, traffic

Re: West, TX explosion

2013-05-01 Thread bverhei
I know someone who in a previous life worked for Pan Am Fire at Bangor. He talked about a fire on the Ohio. Would not have been a situation to send the typical volunteers into. Pan Am, so it shows how long ago it was. bv - Original Message - From: Ron Greenman rongreen...@gmail.com

check valves on dry standpipes

2013-05-01 Thread Greg McGahan
Are you required to put check valves on FDC's supplyign dry standpipe systems such as on docks etc? Thanks, -- Greg McGahan Living Water Fire Protection, LLC http://www.livingwaterfp.com 1160 McKenzie Road Cantonment, FL 32533 850-937-1850 fax 850-937-1852

Re: check valves on dry standpipes

2013-05-01 Thread Charles Thurston
Hello Greg, Is it a Manual Dry system? If so we do not and the AHJs in the area see no reason to. Wednesday, May 1, 2013, 9:38:18 PM, you wrote: Are you required to put check valves on FDC's supplyign dry standpipe systems such as on docks etc? Thanks, -- Best regards, Charles

Re: check valves on dry standpipes

2013-05-01 Thread John Denhardt
Agree with you. No check valves required. Fire sprinklers save lives Sent from my iPad On May 1, 2013, at 9:44 PM, Charles Thurston charl...@mbfsg.com wrote: Hello Greg, Is it a Manual Dry system? If so we do not and the AHJs in the area see no reason to. Wednesday, May 1, 2013,

Re: Home sprinkler mandate in MN

2013-05-01 Thread njarendt tds.net
Prices must be expensive in mn priced out our house in wis at under $1500 in two floors for 3000 sq ft. Norm On Apr 30, 2013 10:44 AM, Hinson, Ryan rhin...@burnsmcd.com wrote: FYI Here is a chain email letter being sent out by the builder's association in MN regarding the eminent vote on the

Re: check valves on dry standpipes

2013-05-01 Thread Greg McGahan
T hanks - that makes three!~! On Wed, May 1, 2013 at 8:45 PM, John Denhardt jdenha...@stricklandfire.comwrote: Agree with you. No check valves required. Fire sprinklers save lives Sent from my iPad On May 1, 2013, at 9:44 PM, Charles Thurston charl...@mbfsg.com wrote: Hello Greg,

Re: check valves on dry standpipes

2013-05-01 Thread bverhei
Did you mean dry sprinkler system, or standpipe, ie, built in hard pipe fire hose? bv - Original Message - From: John Denhardt jdenha...@stricklandfire.com To: sprinklerforum@lists.firesprinkler.org sprinklerforum@lists.firesprinkler.org Sent: Wednesday, May 1, 2013 6:45:40 PM