Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Florian Schmaus
On 9/4/20 11:06 AM, Andrew Nenakhov wrote: > […] if you really > want a compliance suite, you shouldn't pollute the list of extensions > with this day-to-day bureaucracy, but simply publish a 'compliance > suite' page on https://xmpp.org/compliance/ URL and update it when > necessary. You get

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Andrew Nenakhov
We don't really care. In part, because we have implemented far too many extensions that are necessary to provide speedy work on iOS/web platforms, some of which outright replace the ones listed in those suites, and, in part, because the XEPs are lately grossly misused by the XSF, being used now

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Maxime Buquet
On 2020/09/02, Tedd Sterr wrote: > I suspect their main benefit, rather than for implementations to claim some > level of compliance, is as a guide to which features are in use across the > ecosystem, and therefore worthwhile to implement. As federation requires > overlapping feature-sets, this

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-03 Thread Georg Lukas
* Dave Cridland [2020-09-02 17:27]: > If you have an XMPP product or public project, do you claim compliance with > XEP-0423? I'd love to claim yaxim's compliance with Core IM and Advanced Mobile, but can't due to a lack of badges. I'm not sure what the marketing effect of such compliance

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-03 Thread JC Brand
On 02.09.20 17:23, Dave Cridland wrote: Hey all, Really simple questions, so please do reply and answer: If you have an XMPP product or public project, do you claim compliance with XEP-0423? Converse is about 80% compliant. https://github.com/conversejs/converse.js/issues/1398 I think

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Ruslan N. Marchenko
Am Mittwoch, den 02.09.2020, 16:23 +0100 schrieb Dave Cridland: > Hey all, > > Really simple questions, so please do reply and answer: > > If you have an XMPP product or public project, do you claim > compliance with XEP-0423? > > If you do not claim compliance, are you aiming for compliance

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Tedd Sterr
I suspect their main benefit, rather than for implementations to claim some level of compliance, is as a guide to which features are in use across the ecosystem, and therefore worthwhile to implement. As federation requires overlapping feature-sets, this neatly answers the question: "if there

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Sam Whited
The year I revamped the compliance suites I went to a presentation at FOSDEM where the Telepathy folks (I think? Might have been libpurple) were discussing adding features to make themselves compatible. I don't think anyone advertises support, but we haven't given them a way to do so. End users

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Guus der Kinderen
We have not, for Openfire. We've never had anyone ask us if the product has a particular level of compliance either. That's not to say that there is no interest, but I believe there's not much interest, at least not in our community. I'd be happy to start including compliance claims, but,

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Daniel
Hi, we evaluated Gajim's comliance [1] according to XEP-0423. Gajim seems to meet the requirements to be a 'Core Client' in the 'XMPP IM Compliance Suite'. In order for Gajim to meet the requirements of 'Advanced Client', support for XEP-0410 (MUC Self Ping) would need to be implemented. We're

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Thilo Molitor
> If you have an XMPP product or public project, do you claim compliance with > XEP-0423? For Monal we are aiming for compliance in the long run. - tmolitor ___ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards

[Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-02 Thread Dave Cridland
Hey all, Really simple questions, so please do reply and answer: If you have an XMPP product or public project, do you claim compliance with XEP-0423? If you do not claim compliance, are you aiming for compliance with XEP-0423? Dave. ___ Standards