Re: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-08-01 Thread Martin Cooper
: Assenza, Chris [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 31, 2001 6:28 AM Subject: RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity I tend to agree with Tim here, but only in certain circumstances. If you place very specific HTML code in your tag library then that tag library

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-08-01 Thread Assenza, Chris
Message- From: Martin Cooper [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, August 01, 2001 5:08 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity One thing to consider here is the partitioning of functionality across tag libraries. For example, Struts currently

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-31 Thread Assenza, Chris
tags, but it's very generic HTML that can be used again and again without much actual change to the Java code itself. :) -Chris -Original Message- From: Tim Colson [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Monday, July 30, 2001 9:20 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: some comparision between JSP

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Tim Colson
Scriptlets OK for view only? Another developer in my group and I discussed this at length last week. I believe scriptlets in the view to be bad practice...or at least a slippery slope towards badness. grin I suggest that there are two levels of separation we are trying to achieve. 1)

Re: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Pierre Delisle
Tim Colson wrote: Scriptlets OK for view only? Another developer in my group and I discussed this at length last week. I believe scriptlets in the view to be bad practice...or at least a slippery slope towards badness. grin I suggest that there are two levels of separation we are

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Niall Pemberton
PROTECTED]] Sent: 31 July 2001 00:55 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity Scriptlets OK for view only? Another developer in my group and I discussed this at length last week. I believe scriptlets in the view to be bad practice...or at least

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Tim Colson
Niall Pemberton suggested ...if the Struts tags dont do what you want then write your own. Then you dont have to use scriptlets, you have a re-useable bit of functionality, the web designers are happy and you dont have to use Velocity. While a custom tag is an option; this bit of

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Niall Pemberton
: RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity Niall Pemberton suggested ...if the Struts tags dont do what you want then write your own. Then you dont have to use scriptlets, you have a re-useable bit of functionality, the web designers are happy and you dont have to use Velocity

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-30 Thread Calvin Yu
On 30 Jul 2001 18:20:29 -0700, Tim Colson wrote: While a custom tag is an option; this bit of functionality would have required embedding javascript code and html inside the custom tag lib. To me, putting view specific code like inside a tag library is also a slippery slope in the quest to

Re: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-27 Thread VASQUEZ_JASON
This month's Java Developer's Journal has an article comparing jsp/struts and velocity/turbine. Pretty interesting read, especially since I wasn't too familiar with velocity/turbine. -jason suhas [EMAIL PROTECTED] 07/27/2001 06:40 AM Please respond to struts-user To:

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-27 Thread Sri Thuraisamy
-From: Greg Maletic [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]Sent: July 27, 2001 1:45 PMTo: [EMAIL PROTECTED]Subject: RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity This article contains an assertion that goes unquestioned in a lot of the documentationfor templating engines, but it's one

RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity

2001-07-27 Thread Duffey, Kevin
Totally agree! Exactly what I was thinking when I read that! -Original Message-From: Greg Maletic [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]Sent: Friday, July 27, 2001 10:45 AMTo: [EMAIL PROTECTED]Subject: RE: some comparision between JSP/struts and velocity This article contains