Hi Martin, Yves
Usage is a good point, thank you.
Le dim. 22 nov. 2020 à 03:01, Martin Koppenhoefer
a écrit :
> this would deprecate around 20k pump values describing a pump type, plus
> 15k yes/no.
>
OSM counts 143k water_wells according to taginfo for man_made=water_well.
There are 21k pump
Given the number exposed here by Martin, and the fact that there is a few
established data consumers, I think that preserving the pump tag as it is now
and refine it with another tag would be a good idea indeed.
Yves
Le 22 novembre 2020 02:58:07 GMT+01:00, Martin Koppenhoefer
a écrit :
>
>
sent from a phone
> On 22. Nov 2020, at 02:32, François Lacombe wrote:
>
> It's true proposed tagging deprecates the current pump=* definition according
> to rationale and wishes to use the pump word in a more appropriate way.
this would deprecate around 20k pump values describing a pump
Joseph,
It's true proposed tagging deprecates the current pump=* definition
according to rationale and wishes to use the pump word in a more
appropriate way.
However, it would be ok to define mechanical_driver=powered for situations
when mappers aren't able to determine a more precise value.
The current tagging of man_made=water_well + pump=no/manual/powered is
currently used by the HDM style, featured as the "Humanitarian" map layer
on Openstreetmap.org, to determine what sort of icon should be shown for a
water well. Examples:
On the Talk page, the proposal author has now ignored two different
requests to change the new pump=values to a different key like
pump_mechanism, which would allow the continued use of pump=manual and
pump=powered.
The author claims: "I find current tagging meaningless (with all due
respect to
Dear Mateusz,
Proposal goes through different stages and I was proposing simpler driver=*
instead of mechanical_driver. Comments have been made about the possible
confusion with human drivers driving cars.
I am not a fan of deprecating
pump=manual and replacing it with nearly impossible to remember and less clear
mechanical_driver=manual
Also, this proposal deprecates pump=powered without providing replacement
Now to tag this info one is supposed to select value from
reciprocating_solenoid
Hi all
Tonight I'm pleased to announce the start of voting for the tagging
proposal about pumps
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Pumping_proposal
A lot of comments lead us to an interesting tagging for pumps devices,
water wells and wind pumps. Thank you to anyone involved
