Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-29 Thread Mateusz Konieczny via Tagging
I created https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dhospital#Mapping_internal_hospital_structure Extending, review etc is welcomed. Apr 13, 2020, 11:27 by r...@technomancy.org: > I think this is a case of “Things within other things”. How do we map that? > For the enclosing hospital, w

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 13. Apr 2020, at 11:29, Rory McCann wrote: > > OSM could do much better for indoor mapping, and for shopping centres or > train stations, that's easy. Add each `shop` or corridor. But what about a > (sorta of) clinic within a larger OSM object? it‘s a similar situati

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Paul Allen
On Mon, 13 Apr 2020 at 23:31, Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote: It would be a good idea if the tag/s developed here could be used with > other things that have 'departments' such as universities. > > Hence my suggestion of 'department', as a key it is used some 799 times .. > > You'd have great

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Warin
On 13/4/20 9:28 pm, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: Ok, I do agree that "healthcare=department" or perhaps "healthcare=hospital_department" would make sense for an inpatient department within a larger hospital, since that is certainly not an amenity=clinic (which are outpatient facilities). It would not

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Paul Allen
On Mon, 13 Apr 2020 at 15:09, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: > > I suspect carto people are going to say "no synonyms." > > While synonyms are a bad idea, we are talking about something that is > NOT a synonym: an inpatient department of a hospital, rather than a > clinic or doctor's office. > Since y

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
> I suspect carto people are going to say "no synonyms." While synonyms are a bad idea, we are talking about something that is NOT a synonym: an inpatient department of a hospital, rather than a clinic or doctor's office. > What is needed, though, is a tag for hospital wards. That might also be

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Paul Allen
On Mon, 13 Apr 2020 at 12:30, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: > Ok, I do agree that "healthcare=department" or perhaps > "healthcare=hospital_department" would make sense for an inpatient > department within a larger hospital, since that is certainly not an > amenity=clinic (which are outpatient faciliti

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
Ok, I do agree that "healthcare=department" or perhaps "healthcare=hospital_department" would make sense for an inpatient department within a larger hospital, since that is certainly not an amenity=clinic (which are outpatient facilities). It would not be a good idea to use a totally new key like

Re: [Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Warin
On 13/4/20 7:27 pm, Rory McCann wrote: I think this is a case of “Things within other things”. How do we map that? For the enclosing hospital, we know how to map that. But how do we map individual parts within it? Similar to universities? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=unive

[Tagging] Things within things | Re: Request for assistance in creating a tag.

2020-04-13 Thread Rory McCann
I think this is a case of “Things within other things”. How do we map that? For the enclosing hospital, we know how to map that. But how do we map individual parts within it? e.g. St. James' Hospital in Dublin (OSM: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/32015912 ), the hospital has it's own phone