Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-19 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2016-09-18 21:12 GMT+02:00 Tobias Knerr : > On 11.09.2016 12:46, Dave F wrote: > >> But it's *not a tunnel* >> > > Before there was any dedicated tag for it, many people mapped it as > tunnel=yes, so people definitely appear to intuitively consider it > tunnel-like. or

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-18 Thread Tobias Knerr
On 11.09.2016 12:46, Dave F wrote: But it's *not a tunnel* Before there was any dedicated tag for it, many people mapped it as tunnel=yes, so people definitely appear to intuitively consider it tunnel-like. (Perhaps that's also a language issue, not sure.) That's why the new value was also

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-12 Thread Dave F
On 12/09/2016 01:15, Daniel Koć wrote: W dniu 11.09.2016 17:53, Dave F napisał(a): Well, OK. 'Classification' then (which gives indications to who can use it). I still hold my position. Classification doesn't tell who can use it, rather the purpose. Hmm.. 'Motorway', when first mapped,

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Daniel Koć
W dniu 11.09.2016 17:53, Dave F napisał(a): Well, OK. 'Classification' then (which gives indications to who can use it). I still hold my position. Classification doesn't tell who can use it, rather the purpose. Service road and corridor are clear about it: first is for "last mile" servicing

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Dave F
On 11/09/2016 15:24, Daniel Koć wrote: W dniu 11.09.2016 15:48, Dave F napisał(a): On 10/09/2016 12:43, Daniel Koć wrote: BTW: There's also another interesting and quite established tag - highway=corridor, which I've found lately: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dcorridor

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Daniel Koć
W dniu 11.09.2016 15:48, Dave F napisał(a): On 10/09/2016 12:43, Daniel Koć wrote: BTW: There's also another interesting and quite established tag - highway=corridor, which I've found lately: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dcorridor Oh Great Scott. It doesn't tell anyone

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Dave F
On 10/09/2016 12:43, Daniel Koć wrote: BTW: There's also another interesting and quite established tag - highway=corridor, which I've found lately: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dcorridor Oh Great Scott. It doesn't tell anyone who can travel along it. It's useless. All

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Richard
On Sun, Sep 11, 2016 at 11:46:36AM +0100, Dave F wrote: > But it's *not a tunnel* that makes 2 votes for covered=building_passage and phasing out tunnel=building_passage Richard > > On 10/09/2016 12:23, Simone Saviolo wrote: > >Yes, an obvious one: a building_passage *goes through a building*

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-11 Thread Dave F
But it's *not a tunnel* On 10/09/2016 12:23, Simone Saviolo wrote: Yes, an obvious one: a building_passage *goes through a building* :) Semantically it is quite important to distinguish between a colonnade/arcade and a building passage (BTW, also arcades and colonnades have their own tag).

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-10 Thread Richard
On Sat, Sep 10, 2016 at 12:09:56PM +0100, Dave F wrote: > Hmm... > The building_passage tag (65 445) is a new one to me. > http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/tunnel=building_passage > > Looking at the wiki it's very similar to covered=yes (254 624) >

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-10 Thread Daniel Koć
W dniu 10.09.2016 13:23, Simone Saviolo napisał(a): Yes, an obvious one: a building_passage *goes through a building* :) Semantically it is quite important to distinguish between a colonnade/arcade and a building passage (BTW, also arcades and colonnades have their own tag). covered=yes just

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-10 Thread LeTopographeFou
Thank you for your feedback. This is an important topic but I think that fixing a typo and approving a tag are two different needs. Whether this tag is validated or not, I think it should be fixed because the intent of those contributors was to put building_passage and not those fancy

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-10 Thread Simone Saviolo
Yes, an obvious one: a building_passage *goes through a building* :) Semantically it is quite important to distinguish between a colonnade/arcade and a building passage (BTW, also arcades and colonnades have their own tag). covered=yes just implies that the building is over the highway, but it

Re: [Tagging] tunnel=building_passage or covered=yes

2016-09-10 Thread Dave F
Hmm... The building_passage tag (65 445) is a new one to me. http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/tunnel=building_passage Looking at the wiki it's very similar to covered=yes (254 624) http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/covered I thought there was a discussion here where it was agreed to be