Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-30 Thread lists
But you’ve done nothing but calling me names nonstop, I owe you an apology then, and the developers and users who may have read my ramblings. then complaining when people do the same to you. You’re a hypocrite, but you clearly don’t realize that, because you keep saying that “you’re cool”

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Mike Burns
On 2015-06-29 09.52.19 +0100, Raf Czlonka wrote: That being said, FAQ is *not* an OpenBSD for former Linux users guide, FAQ 9 is titled Migrating to OpenBSD, four of the five sections have Linux in the title, and the one section that does not mentions Linux twice in the first paragraph. Are you

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Raf Czlonka
On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 02:19:36PM BST, Mike Burns wrote: On 2015-06-29 09.52.19 +0100, Raf Czlonka wrote: That being said, FAQ is *not* an OpenBSD for former Linux users guide, FAQ 9 is titled Migrating to OpenBSD, four of the five sections have Linux in the title, and the one section

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread lists
Are you proposing that the whole of FAQ 9 should be scrapped? May it be proposed to you that you further advise Carlos on improving his suggested patch or scrapping this knitting already. Whose idea was to stoke the binpatch theme anyway, somebody of commercial interest? No such thing is

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Theo de Raadt
Lot of angry fuss over words on a web page.

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread lists
On Sun, 28 Jun 2015 18:58:19 -0400 Bryan Steele bry...@openbsd.org wrote: Carlos' patch may not be appropriate, but you're kind of a condecending jerk, especially for someone who's apparently never sent mail to the OpenBSD lists before. Who are you? On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Raf Czlonka
On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 09:21:14AM BST, Carlos Fenollosa wrote: Thanks Sebastien, Here’s a new rewrite with your contributions. If I may, I’d suggest to keep this list item short, as a summary, and maybe write a longer section on the FAQ expanding on it with more detail. If you feel

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Carlos Fenollosa
Thanks Sebastien, Here’s a new rewrite with your contributions. If I may, I’d suggest to keep this list item short, as a summary, and maybe write a longer section on the FAQ expanding on it with more detail. If you feel that’s appropriate, I can volunteer to write it too. Carlos Index:

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread Marc Espie
On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 02:41:16AM +0300, li...@wrant.com wrote: Lack of resources is about the only good reason there is for not providing binary updates. That's not true. Further, base + packages are updated frequently in snapshots, which is exactly a binary upgrade path for users

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread lists
Work on current is something that naturally occurs. It does not mean there are enough resources to *duplicate that work* and do the same on stable. Obvious facts make obvious points. The snapshots for current and the security errata is good enough for me. It's easy and allows me to run

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-29 Thread lists
Lot of angry fuss over words on a web page. Indeed. https://youtube.com/watch?v=hrCVu25wQ5s I have no wishes and the discontent with the proposed patch is gone now.

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Carlos Fenollosa
Hi, I’m sorry that it came off that way. Did you read the whole article? No that you should have, but it addresses most of the points that you mention I understand that OpenBSD owes me nothing (and vice versa) and I was just trying to help. The decision to merge that information is not mine to

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Michael McConville
On Sun, Jun 28, 2015 at 07:20:51PM +0200, Carlos Fenollosa wrote: This patch is regarding the fact that there are no binary updates, which is a given thing in most Linux distributions, and some tips on how to keep the system updated. It may be worthwhile to mention that updates are

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
I’ve recently discovered OpenBSD after using Linux for more than 15 years. Long time, no see? And you blogged and achieved your goal of... making yourself expressed, critically on your own controlled web space. I wrote a blog article with my impressions and some other users suggested me to

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Mike Burns
On 2015-06-29 00.03.09 +0300, li...@wrant.com wrote: And you consider this a service to other Linux long time users? Or a way to try push some notion of yours - criticise and try to lobby for some other entity's interests. Do you have a patch that achieves the same goal (that is, the goal he

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
I understand that OpenBSD owes me nothing (and vice versa) and I was just trying to help. The decision to merge that information is not mine to do, however, I honestly thought it could help people looking for a more thorough comparison between Linux and the BSDs. Are you by chance being

[Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Carlos Fenollosa
Hi, I’ve recently discovered OpenBSD after using Linux for more than 15 years. I wrote a blog article with my impressions and some other users suggested me to patch faq9.html to help other users migrating. This patch is regarding the fact that there are no binary updates, which is a given

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Denis Fondras
This patch is regarding the fact that there are no binary updates, which is a given thing What you missed : https://stable.mtier.org/

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Adam Wolk
On Sun, 28 Jun 2015 19:55:58 +0200 Denis Fondras open...@ledeuns.net wrote: This patch is regarding the fact that there are no binary updates, which is a given thing What you missed : https://stable.mtier.org/ What do you mean? The author mentioned mtier.org both in his original blog

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
What do you mean? The author mentioned mtier.org both in his original blog post and the patch sent to this mailing list. Author? Exactly whose ground are you defending here, Adam? If it's going to be merged then it's probably worth to mention that if... and you're on top of each other

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Bryan Steele
On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 01:02:44AM +0300, li...@wrant.com wrote: Do you have a patch that achieves the same goal (that is, the goal he stated, not the one you're reading into) that is up to your standards? One that reversed the submission of the proposed patch, correcting it and this

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Matthew Via
Without reading much of the documentation to gain reasonable production usage, you're trying to mend the OpenBSD site to say it is lacking something that you thought worth having according to your current limited to Linux experience. Never occurred to you it may be intentional? The

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
Lack of resources is about the only good reason there is for not providing binary updates. That's not true. Further, base + packages are updated frequently in snapshots, which is exactly a binary upgrade path for users without worry. This works exceedingly well and is well stated in the

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Theo de Raadt
Lack of resources is about the only good reason there is for not providing binary updates. That's not true. It must feel absolutely glorious to bask in your anonymity and make such a strong claim. I personally am not going to spend a second working on binary updates until I know there

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
Lack of resources is about the only good reason there is for not providing binary updates. That's not true. It must feel absolutely glorious to bask in your anonymity and make such a strong claim. There are no strong claims. The other good reasons are to manage the updates

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Theo de Raadt
Well, not near one, but I volunteer for binary errata patch on current for i386 and amd64 (the only archs I own for now). People are going to use binary patches from you? Who are you? What is your name? That's the first step to establish trust. Boy, that's a pretty clever joke!

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
Well, not near one, but I volunteer for binary errata patch on current for i386 and amd64 (the only archs I own for now). People are going to use binary patches from you? I was hoping to try help with testing at least. Who are you? What is your name? That's the first step to establish

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Theo de Raadt
So the discussion is to probably best put these upgrade details in the upgrade guide, not in the migration guide in the meantime. Without delegating resources until deemed necessary and no need to state explicitly they have no binary upgrades on the migration guide. I think you've already

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
I think you've already said enough nasty stuff Right. I personally am not going to spend a second working on binary updates until I know there are 20+ other developers also dedicated to making it happen, and once it starts happening -- keeps happening forever. Well, not near one, but I

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread Sebastien Marie
Hi, I would just do some comments inline. On Sun, Jun 28, 2015 at 07:20:51PM +0200, Carlos Fenollosa wrote: Hi, I’ve recently discovered OpenBSD after using Linux for more than 15 years. I wrote a blog article with my impressions and some other users suggested me to patch faq9.html to

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread lists
So, for newcomers from other systems the practical approach would be to follow snapshots to be able to upgrade all (packages on top of base). Install first (once) 1) download a snapshot set (or only bsd.rd for network install) 2) install latest snapshot base OS 3) install your packages with

Re: [Patch] New item to the Migrating to OpenBSD guide

2015-06-28 Thread L.R. D.S.
Who are you? What is your name? That's the first step to establish trust. I would not think in this way Theo. If you need a name and a social status to trust someone, then you're fucked, because everyone can fake this, and a name is just a name, symbols of some language together, nothing