[tbc-users] Re: open world assumption problem

2009-01-02 Thread Scott Henninger
Christoph; An addendum to Irene's post. One can probably work really hard to close the world and make the right reasoning in Pellet, etc. An alternative is to use simple SPARQL queries to make the inferences: CONSTRUCT {?x a :ValidCert .} WHERE {?x a :Certificate . OPTIONAL {?x

[tbc-users] Re: dl query and topbraid

2009-01-02 Thread Holger Knublauch
Yes, I agree with everything you state Atanas. I am aware that OWLIM covers a different subset of OWL than Pellet. I was calling it a DL engine since it covers a (significant) subset of OWL DL including owl:someValuesFrom. But right, formally OWL DL is more and OWLIM and other rule-based

[tbc-users] Re: ANN: TopBraid Composer 3.0.0 beta 1

2009-01-02 Thread Holger Knublauch
Hi Christoph, yes we will publish more background material on SPIN in the next few weeks or months. A good place to monitor is the Composing the Semantic Web blog [1] in which I will post use cases and other background on SPIN in the next few days. However, I believe SPIN is very easy to

[tbc-users] Re: dl query and topbraid

2009-01-02 Thread Scott Henninger
This is getting into topics of considerable debate. OWLIM and others (e.g. KAON2) are datalog reasoners. Pellet and Racer use the Tableau algorithm. OWL-DL is certainly not the only way to do reasoning. Many tools provide a kind of RDFS+ that includes some of the more common inferences -