Re: [TIC: Tongue in Cheek] Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2015-02-10 Thread Richard Gaskin
Mark Wieder wrote: Richard- Thursday, May 15, 2014, 2:34:38 PM, you wrote: On another note, as I promised you last week I did ask Ben if RunRev planned on open-sourcing the On-Rev real-time debugger. He's not sure and will check with Kevin, but he did confirm my hunch that it requires

Re: [TIC: Tongue in Cheek] Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2015-02-09 Thread Mark Wieder
Richard- Thursday, May 15, 2014, 2:34:38 PM, you wrote: On another note, as I promised you last week I did ask Ben if RunRev planned on open-sourcing the On-Rev real-time debugger. He's not sure and will check with Kevin, but he did confirm my hunch that it requires specific sockets open on

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Mike Kerner
Let's see - on the DG, Hanson and I had a brief conversation, that was similar to what you were describing to the list, then you tossed FIX: into the mix, so I'm going to have to take a look at, and write a FIX: for DG's For OR/RO, all I can say is whatever. Let's fix the name of RO so it

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Dave Kilroy
I don't know whether the Menu Builder falls into the 'IDE oddity' category but it sure it a liability! - Some are born coders, some achieve coding, and some have coding thrust upon them. - William Shakespeare Hugh Senior -- View this message in context:

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Devin Asay
On May 16, 2014, at 9:12 AM, Dave Kilroy d...@applicationinsight.com wrote: I don't know whether the Menu Builder falls into the 'IDE oddity' category but it sure it a liability! Dave, Anything specific, or do you just find it confusing in general? Devin Devin Asay Office of Digital

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Dave Kilroy
Hi Devin Sorry to be vague, didn't think I needed to say how unreliable it the menu tool is - it has bitten me in the past and plenty of others too. What usually happens is that you set up your menus and then when you reopen the stack half of the entries will have vanished, or some will be

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread J. Landman Gay
How so? I use menu builder as a quick way to block out menus and haven't had any trouble (except for the versions with a bug that got fixed.) It does need updating to include the new tag features though. Do you mean the interface isn't clear? On May 16, 2014 10:12:07 AM CDT, Dave Kilroy

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Devin Asay
On May 16, 2014, at 10:16 AM, Dave Kilroy d...@applicationinsight.com wrote: Hi Devin Sorry to be vague, didn't think I needed to say how unreliable it the menu tool is - it has bitten me in the past and plenty of others too. What usually happens is that you set up your menus and then

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread J. Landman Gay
I wonder if you're talking about the two versions of LiveCode that had a bug. It chopped off half of every menu template script. That's been fixed now. On May 16, 2014 11:16:46 AM CDT, Dave Kilroy d...@applicationinsight.com wrote: Hi Devin Sorry to be vague, didn't think I needed to say

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Richard Gaskin
J. Landman Gay wrote: I wonder if you're talking about the two versions of LiveCode that had a bug. It chopped off half of every menu template script. That's been fixed now. When discussing things that don't work it's VERY helpful to note the bug report number. If a bug hasn't yet been

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Charles E Buchwald
I don't use the Menu Builder much, but I use the Geometry Manager on a regular basis, and I've found it to be reliable. I only wish I could use it on mobile. Because I can't, I've written a lot of my own geometry management scripts. In general, the better feature parity we have across all

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Devin Asay
On May 16, 2014, at 11:14 AM, Charles E Buchwald char...@buchwald.ca wrote: I don't use the Menu Builder much, but I use the Geometry Manager on a regular basis, and I've found it to be reliable. I only wish I could use it on mobile. Because I can't, I've written a lot of my own geometry

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Mike Kerner
Geometry Manager would be even more useful on mobile since MG doesn't support screen rotation any more. I don't know if Scott is thinking about adding that feature to tmC. I think the menu builder is flat-out weak. It isn't buggy for me, it just isn't very helpful. I guess it's good that I am

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread Dave Kilroy
Devin I think you are correct - it's buggy rather than an example of weird interface design and shouldn't appear on this list. And for those of you who have never been snagged by Menu Builder this thread gives examples of the kind of things it can do:

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-16 Thread J. Landman Gay
I've never seen any of those things either, but since so many others have, I wonder if there actually might be a problem with the interface. I'd like to be a fly on the wall and watch people use it. On May 16, 2014 5:44:20 PM CDT, Dave Kilroy d...@applicationinsight.com wrote: Devin I think

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mark Wieder
Devin- The contextual menu that pops up when you right-click on a control is different from the one that pops up when you right-click a stack, which is different from the one that pops up in the Application Browser, which is different from the one that pops up in the Project Browser. Drives. Me.

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Devin Asay
Thanks for the responses folks. Keep them coming, and I'll post a summary. Here's another one of mine: Names of blendLevel inks: Whaaa? What do those things even mean? Devin Devin Asay Office of Digital Humanities Brigham Young University ___

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Try resizing something, or using the alignment tools. I just ran into this, again, this week, when I was trying to fix a vertical line. The line is too short, so I changed the length. The line lengthened, UPWARD. So I then changed the top of the line, thinking that would help me except the

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
And another: If you have your lappie hooked to two monitors at work, and you use both monitors, and then you go home, guess what happens to windows, especially on a Mac, where you are using multiple workspaces? That's right, the windows, even the LC development windows, are off-screen somewhere

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Whoops! Wait, a second, here's another: The locked of the properties palette for each object is separate and persistent. This is really great when you are working with a component or object that is installed by another developer, and want to look at two of the developer's objects side-by-side

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Devin Asay
On May 15, 2014, at 9:12 AM, Richard Gaskin ambassa...@fourthworld.com wrote: Devin Asay wrote: Thanks for the responses folks. Keep them coming, and I'll post a summary. It may be helpful if you'd post your summary to the IDE Contributors Forum:

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Richard Gaskin
Devin Asay wrote: Thanks for the responses folks. Keep them coming, and I'll post a summary. It may be helpful if you'd post your summary to the IDE Contributors Forum: http://forums.runrev.com/viewforum.php?f=67 Here's another one of mine: Names of blendLevel inks: Whaaa? What do those

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Devin Asay
On May 15, 2014, at 9:16 AM, Mike Kerner mikeker...@roadrunner.com wrote: Whoops! Wait, a second, here's another: The locked of the properties palette for each object is separate and persistent. This is really great when you are working with a component or object that is installed by

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Charles E Buchwald
Mike, this is the part that I don't get about open source... yet. I guess we don't have the community structures to handle it. I mean, I've made that (free) plugin to handle this specific problem. lcMover moves stacks/windows around, whether they are off-screen or not. I even added an option

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread J. Landman Gay
There's a small view of two overlapping images at the bottom of the inspector that shows what the ink will do. The names of the inks are the same as the ones that Photoshop and many other image processing programs use, so that's a tough call. Specialists might complain if they are changed.

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Devin Asay
On May 15, 2014, at 9:57 AM, Charles E Buchwald char...@buchwald.ca wrote: Mike, this is the part that I don't get about open source... yet. I guess we don't have the community structures to handle it. I mean, I've made that (free) plugin to handle this specific problem. lcMover moves

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Devin Asay
On May 15, 2014, at 10:00 AM, J. Landman Gay jac...@hyperactivesw.com wrote: There's a small view of two overlapping images at the bottom of the inspector that shows what the ink will do. Well, I'll be d**ned. How many times have I looked at that, and it never registered until now. What

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Richmond
On 15/05/14 17:42, Devin Asay wrote: Thanks for the responses folks. Keep them coming, and I'll post a summary. Here's another one of mine: Names of blendLevel inks: Whaaa? What do those things even mean? Yes: a set of names that had some sort of connexion with the effects produced would

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Dar Scott
This one might be just me. It is awkward to move off the keyboard while editing a script to hover over a control in the Object Inspector waiting for it to take so I can see the name of the property. On May 15, 2014, at 8:42 AM, Devin Asay devin_a...@byu.edu wrote: Thanks for the responses

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
It's persistent between launches of LC. The case in question is dealing with the dataGrid, because there are issues with the DG, which I detailed in a bug report that I filed this week, in particular related to resizing a header. Because a DG is an amalgam of numerous LC objects, issues can

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Charles, I was not aware of your add-on. Your add-on, like numerous other add-ons, have not made it to the collective consciousness, yet. That's exactly why we're talking about taking the revOnline project broader and trying to get it organized and improved, so that it becomes a catalog of

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Most of the LC-coded portions of LC are not part of GitHub. This also includes dataGrids, which have several issues I discovered earlier in the week. On Thu, May 15, 2014 at 12:07 PM, Devin Asay devin_a...@byu.edu wrote: On May 15, 2014, at 9:57 AM, Charles E Buchwald char...@buchwald.ca

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Dar Scott
I’d call this one more than an oddity. This is a bug. It goes along with the one about how no window can be higher than the icon bar even if it is on a display placed high and the bar is not even on that display. Dar On May 15, 2014, at 9:23 AM, Mike Kerner mikeker...@roadrunner.com wrote:

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
+1 On Thu, May 15, 2014 at 1:59 PM, Dar Scott d...@swcp.com wrote: This one might be just me. It is awkward to move off the keyboard while editing a script to hover over a control in the Object Inspector waiting for it to take so I can see the name of the property. On May 15, 2014, at

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Charles E Buchwald
OK, so what do we have to do, as a community of users, to get RevOnline working again? This seems like a good way to encourage and coordinate community participation. Particularly so because we are talking about LC code, outside of the GitHub ecosystem, and outside of the IDE. And because it's

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Look at the [Off] Cool Plugins thread. -- On the first day, God created the heavens and the Earth On the second day, God created the oceans. On the third day, God put the animals on hold for a few hours, and did a little diving. And God said, This is good.

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
Richard is heading up this effort. It is being discussed in another thread. Volunteers have been...volunteering. On Thu, May 15, 2014 at 2:40 PM, Charles E Buchwald char...@buchwald.cawrote: OK, so what do we have to do, as a community of users, to get RevOnline working again? This seems

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Richard Gaskin
Charles wrote: OK, so what do we have to do, as a community of users, to get RevOnline working again? Fix it. :) My Community meeting this morning with Ben focused almost exclusively on RevOnline. It's true that LiveCode is inherently problematic to attempt to integrate into tools like

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Mike Kerner
This is similar to a discussion I had earlier this week about fixing the issues I found in DataGrid. However, what do we do about OnRev, especially if we are going to work on it as a group of sorts? On Thu, May 15, 2014 at 4:29 PM, Richard Gaskin ambassa...@fourthworld.comwrote: Charles

Community Contributions (was IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil))

2014-05-15 Thread Charles E Buchwald
Mike, I did follow the whole [Off] Cool Plugins thread. I was a bit disappointed that it kind of petered out after several people expressed an interest in helping. I did propose that the forum for plugins and extensions be split in two. My thought being that developing either is very different

Community Contributions (was IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil))

2014-05-15 Thread Charles E Buchwald
Mike, I did follow the whole [Off] Cool Plugins thread. I was a bit disappointed that it kind of petered out after several people expressed an interest in helping. I did propose that the forum for plugins and extensions be split in two. My thought being that developing either is very different

[TIC: Tongue in Cheek] Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Alex Tweedly
On 15/05/2014 21:29, Richard Gaskin wrote: As an example of this workflow in action, we have a simple fix here: http://quality.runrev.com/show_bug.cgi?id=11493 Since the code change is comprised of adding only five characters to a comparison string and can be easily seen in the Message Box,

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Richard Gaskin
Mike Kerner wrote: This is similar to a discussion I had earlier this week about fixing the issues I found in DataGrid. I think I missed something. Did you submit fixes with those? If you did, please add a FIX: prefix to the report titled so they can be flagged. However, what do we do

Re: [TIC: Tongue in Cheek] Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Richard Gaskin
Well, always good to anticipate future-proofing. :) On another note, as I promised you last week I did ask Ben if RunRev planned on open-sourcing the On-Rev real-time debugger. He's not sure and will check with Kevin, but he did confirm my hunch that it requires specific sockets open on the

Re: [TIC: Tongue in Cheek] IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Igor de Oliveira Couto
On 16 May 2014, at 8:34 am, Richard Gaskin ambassa...@fourthworld.com wrote: On another note, as I promised you last week I did ask Ben if RunRev planned on open-sourcing the On-Rev real-time debugger. He's not sure and will check with Kevin, but he did confirm my hunch that it requires

Re: Community Contributions (was IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil))

2014-05-15 Thread Richard Gaskin
Charles E Buchwald wrote: Mike, I did follow the whole [Off] Cool Plugins thread. I was a bit disappointed that it kind of petered out after several people expressed an interest in helping. I wouldn't be too disappointed. Things ebb and flow; we all have many things to do. But two very

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread J. Landman Gay
On 5/15/14, 12:59 PM, Dar Scott wrote: It is awkward to move off the keyboard while editing a script to hover over a control in the Object Inspector waiting for it to take so I can see the name of the property. You can select go the the General pane in preferences, look for Property labels

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread J. Landman Gay
On 5/15/14, 10:35 AM, Devin Asay wrote: The locked of the properties palette for each object is separate and persistent. From what I can see, cards and stacks selected from the app browser will open a locked inspector (anything in the left-hand pane.) Objects on a card (anything in the

Re: Community Contributions (was IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil))

2014-05-15 Thread Charles E Buchwald
Thanks for your considered and thorough answer, Richard. As a footnote, I posted another little plugin I made. I've been working with HTML a lot, and the itch I've been scratching with it is having to switch between HTMLtext and styledText, and sometimes look up LC-legal HTML entities. The

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Dar Scott
Yeah, I was aware of that, but never tried it. I’m afraid I’d get very confused. I should be brave. Also, I’m greedy and want both. I’ll try what you suggest and see if that is too greedy. Dar Dar Scott Consulting d...@swcp.com Helping LiveCode programers with Externals and Libraries On

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Alejandro Tejada
Devin Asay wrote [snip] Yes, I agree that sometimes concepts are too complex to describe in a short, neat label. But in the interface, perhaps the menu could show the effect of the ink visually, or maybe there could be a help button that would pop up a list explaining the inks in simple

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-15 Thread Scott Rossi
You're right, the results aren't predictable, as you've seen, since object-level effects are modified when compounded by an effect applied to a containing group. Color sometimes plays factor too. But realistically, there aren't that many results that are useful. Generally, I've found the

IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Devin Asay
On May 13, 2014, at 9:57 PM, Alejandro Tejada capellan2...@gmail.com wrote: Richard Gaskin wrote [snip] These are basic tasks we should expect to be done efficiently and without error. They require no celebration. Don't even mention them unless something goes wrong. Otherwise, as long

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Dar Scott
On May 14, 2014, at 10:00 AM, Devin Asay devin_a...@byu.edu wrote: Closely related: Why are lock size and lock location controlled by a single property? Good question. The good news is that it is now possible to group a single object. Dar Scott Libraries and Externals d...@swcp.com

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Richmond
On 14/05/14 19:26, Dar Scott wrote: On May 14, 2014, at 10:00 AM, Devin Asay devin_a...@byu.edu wrote: Closely related: Why are lock size and lock location controlled by a single property? Good question. The good news is that it is now possible to group a single object. What? I grouped a

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Dar Scott
Yeah, I goofed. No sleep. I was getting confused with grouping a group. It can be done, but I don’t know how with the IDE. Dar On May 14, 2014, at 11:35 AM, Richmond richmondmathew...@gmail.com wrote: On 14/05/14 19:26, Dar Scott wrote: On May 14, 2014, at 10:00 AM, Devin Asay

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Devin Asay
On May 14, 2014, at 10:26 AM, Dar Scott d...@swcp.com wrote: On May 14, 2014, at 10:00 AM, Devin Asay devin_a...@byu.edu wrote: Closely related: Why are lock size and lock location controlled by a single property? Good question. The good news is that it is now possible to group a

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Peter Haworth
One thing that confused the heck out of me at the start is how the menu bar changes depending on whether a stack or the script editor is in front (this is on OSX). When in the script editor, the menu bar shows File, Edit, Debug, Handler, Window, Help and the File menu has no entries to open a

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Devin Asay
On May 14, 2014, at 12:41 PM, Peter Haworth p...@lcsql.com wrote: One thing that confused the heck out of me at the start is how the menu bar changes depending on whether a stack or the script editor is in front (this is on OSX). When in the script editor, the menu bar shows File, Edit,

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Alejandro Tejada
Actually, new users wants that LiveCode IDE looks and behave as their own favorite software... So a Graphic Designer wants that Livecode looks and behave like Photoshop, Ilustrator, Flash, etc. A MS Office needs that LiveCode adopt all the conventions of these products... The 3D artist wants...

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Devin Asay
On May 14, 2014, at 3:31 PM, Alejandro Tejada capellan2...@gmail.com wrote: Actually, new users wants that LiveCode IDE looks and behave as their own favorite software... So a Graphic Designer wants that Livecode looks and behave like Photoshop, Ilustrator, Flash, etc. A MS Office

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread J. Landman Gay
On 5/14/14, 1:04 PM, Devin Asay wrote: I'd like to keep the focus of this thread on things in the LiveCode IDE that are odd, inconsistent, or confusing to the new user. I know there are a hundred things like that. Problem is, I'm so used to working around them that I can't think of what they

Re: IDE oddities (was Re: Error Messages Are Evil)

2014-05-14 Thread Dr. Hawkins
On Wed, May 14, 2014 at 10:47 AM, Dar Scott d...@swcp.com wrote: No sleep. I was getting confused with grouping a group. It can be done, but I don’t know how with the IDE. Group two things, and delete one. I've stumbled across *empty* groups hanging around in my stacks . . . -- Dr.

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-13 Thread Dave Kilroy
Thanks for this Dar - I like it very much :) Dar Scott wrote Sure. Here is a belabored example of my style of tenacious I/O. - Some are born coders, some achieve coding, and some have coding thrust upon them. - William Shakespeare Hugh Senior -- View this message in context:

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-13 Thread Richard Gaskin
Peter M. Brigham wrote: Someone on this list (Richard Gaskin?) once observed that the difference between a tool and a product is that a tool only has to be able to be used properly, whereas a product has to be unable to be used improperly. I wish I could take credit for that, but that slice

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-13 Thread Alejandro Tejada
Richard Gaskin wrote [snip] These are basic tasks we should expect to be done efficiently and without error. They require no celebration. Don't even mention them unless something goes wrong. Otherwise, as long as the computer is doing what we expect it to do, please just shut up and let

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-12 Thread Peter Bogdanoff
I've been having a horrible experience with the United States Internal Revenue Service website--trying just to set up an account in order to download a pdf of a previous year's return. Every attempt (at least 6) over two days ended somewhere along the process with: A technical problem

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-12 Thread Richmond
snip Idiot programmers. Maybe the same ones who did the Obamacare website. Grr. Peter Bogdanoff UCLA Yes; a program is only so good as its programmers have made it; so Donald Norman's anthropomorphic heresy piling all the blame on some machine is ridiculous. Nowadays we don't have bad

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-12 Thread J. Landman Gay
On 5/11/14, 7:49 PM, Dar Scott wrote: Sure. Here is a belabored example of my style of tenacious I/O. Good stuff, thanks for writing that up. I need to pay more attention to this kind of thing. It's way too easy to pop up a dialog and tell the user they're wrong, and that's not a great

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-12 Thread Peter M. Brigham
Someone on this list (Richard Gaskin?) once observed that the difference between a tool and a product is that a tool only has to be able to be used properly, whereas a product has to be unable to be used improperly. A well-designed application should anticipate as much as possible users' likely

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Richmond
On 11/05/14 21:48, Alejandro Tejada wrote: Recent article published by Don Norman. http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/error_messages_are_e.html Error messages punish people for not behaving like machines. It is time we let people behave like people. When a problem arises, we should call it machine

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Bob Sneidar
Call me a naysayer, but I think the premise is nonsense. Only a perfect machine could conform to those standards, and there is no perfect machine. All will have or develop problems, and to not inform the user when that happens is irresponsible at best, and disastrous at worse. And it doesn’t

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Alejandro Tejada
Probably, the point of Mr. Donald Norman is: Reduce as much as possible the chance of human error... (Richmond wrote about this key concept in a previous message: affordance) http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/affordances_and.html A truly collaborative system would tell me the requirements before I did

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Dar Scott
Ah, I have much to learn. I said, “The house was painted red.” I should have said, “The house was painted redly.” Dar On May 11, 2014, at 1:43 PM, Richmond richmondmathew...@gmail.com wrote: On 11/05/14 21:48, Alejandro Tejada wrote: Recent article published by Don Norman.

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Dar Scott
Often I design communications without error responses to commands. Instead there is state information while the underlying system is working doggedly to make what you wanted work. On May 11, 2014, at 12:48 PM, Alejandro Tejada capellan2...@gmail.com wrote: Recent article published by Don

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread dunbarx
-Original Message- From: Bob Sneidar bobsnei...@iotecdigital.com To: How to use LiveCode use-livecode@lists.runrev.com Sent: Sun, May 11, 2014 4:49 pm Subject: Re: Error Messages Are Evil Call me a naysayer, but I think the premise is nonsense. Only a perfect machine could conform to those

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread J. Landman Gay
I'm interested. Can I get an example? I know Apple discourages error dialogs now. On May 11, 2014 5:44:47 PM CDT, Dar Scott d...@swcp.com wrote: Often I design communications without error responses to commands. Instead there is state information while the underlying system is working

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Peter Haworth
Perfect example - signing up for an account online and getting an error because your password didn't meet the site 's rules which they didn't reveal to start with. That's evil! Pete lcSQL Software On May 11, 2014 2:24 PM, Alejandro Tejada capellan2...@gmail.com wrote: Probably, the point of

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Dar Scott
Sure. Here is a belabored example of my style of tenacious I/O. I typically start one each of a communications “machine with prefixStart command and stop it with prefixStop. The status is available though a status function and notification of the status change by a callback. A very simple

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Mark Wieder
Dar- Do not go gently into that good night. -- -Mark Wieder ahsoftw...@gmail.com This communication may be unlawfully collected and stored by the National Security Agency (NSA) in secret. The parties to this email do not consent to the retrieving or storing of this communication and any

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Dar Scott
Long ago, deep in a previous century, I set up a Cromemco or MITS Altair for my secretary to do some word processing while I was out. When I came back, she was in tears. The computer told her, “Invalid! Jump to!” I looked at the screen. At the bottom was the line “Invalid jump to .”

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Richmond
On 05/12/2014 01:41 AM, Dar Scott wrote: Ah, I have much to learn. I said, “The house was painted red.” I should have said, “The house was painted redly.” LOL! You made my Monday a thousand times more cheerful. Thanks so much. Richmond. Dar On May 11, 2014, at 1:43 PM, Richmond

Re: Error Messages Are Evil

2014-05-11 Thread Bob Sneidar
I also meant to say that to imagine one could predict every kind of erroneous user input or machine fault and program around it is easy, but it’s just our imagination. In reality, it is a great deal more difficult to do. I remember articles written when Hypercard was rolled out, about how much