[vdr] known user base (was: Re: Replay Problems with Extension HD)

2009-09-09 Thread Christian Tramnitz

I don't think people would like that.
DRBD has imho a good approach* to track users (and used versions!), but 
regardless of the method, this is certainly not on Klaus' priority list.



Best regards,
   Christian (#68)


*On first startup (or after upgrades) a unique ID will generated and the 
user will be asked if he wants to send this ID together with the current 
version to the maintainer. Optionally (to appear on a list just like 
vdr's user list) personal data may be entered, but this is up to the 
user. Pressing enter will just send the unique ID and version, aborting 
the prompt will not send anything.



jori.hamalai...@teliasonera.com wrote:

Perhaps VDR should try to send UDP packet to Klaus's server when it starts.
Not all will not like it, but it is same for me. Windows software do this
constantly under name for automatically check for program updates.

BR, Jori, a registered VDR user since 2003.



___
vdr mailing list
vdr@linuxtv.org
http://www.linuxtv.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/vdr


Re: [vdr] known user base (was: Re: Replay Problems with Extension HD)

2009-09-09 Thread VDR User
On Wed, Sep 9, 2009 at 12:10 AM, Christian Tramnitzchris@gmx.net wrote:
 I don't think people would like that.
 DRBD has imho a good approach* to track users (and used versions!), but
 regardless of the method, this is certainly not on Klaus' priority list.


 Best regards,
   Christian (#68)


 *On first startup (or after upgrades) a unique ID will generated and the
 user will be asked if he wants to send this ID together with the current
 version to the maintainer. Optionally (to appear on a list just like vdr's
 user list) personal data may be entered, but this is up to the user.
 Pressing enter will just send the unique ID and version, aborting the prompt
 will not send anything.


 jori.hamalai...@teliasonera.com wrote:

 Perhaps VDR should try to send UDP packet to Klaus's server when it
 starts.
 Not all will not like it, but it is same for me. Windows software do this
 constantly under name for automatically check for program updates.

 BR, Jori, a registered VDR user since 2003.

User-tracking has _absolutely no place_ in VDR what-so-ever!!  It
serves no purpose and if someone wants to be added to a user list
somewhere, they can register themselves.  If someone really thinks
this is a brilliant idea, they can write a plugin to do it but it
should have no chance becoming a part of VDR core.

No offense but that's the worst idea I've heard by far.

___
vdr mailing list
vdr@linuxtv.org
http://www.linuxtv.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/vdr