RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-22 Thread Steven Vincent Johnson
From Alexander: yes, like 20 years ago when they were just as intricate, and we all had gps and autocad What??? Not true. Not according to what I've seen and read. Crop circles have only become more intricate within the last decade or so. Twenty years ago and prior crop circles were

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-22 Thread Jones Beene
Good point Steven. In fact, the incremental increase in complexity of crop circles over time seems to roughly correspond to the increase in inexpensive computer power and GPS etc. which is available to students. Equally surprising and far more ironic is that the increase in inexpensive computer

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-22 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
I think both Jed and Jones have expressed important concepts often glossed over by many. There is Jed's down-to-earth commentary regarding the fact that all too often we have an arrogant tendency to dismiss just how incredibly smart and perceive our own ancient indigenous population had been in

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Steven Vincent Johnson
Robin sez: So, based on this, I conclude that the galaxy is not filled with millions of intelligent species in civilizations that have lasted for hundreds of thousands or millions of years, and achieved much greater wealth and stability than we have. Or if there are such civilizations, the

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Jed Rothwell
Kyle Mcallister wrote: If it was an interstellar communication and it happened to impinge on earth . . . If it was deliberate, yes. If not, if it was something else, or a spurious transmission for reasons unknown, it might not remain on us for long. The beam width would be a factor, motion

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Jones Beene
-Original Message- From: mix...@bigpond.com There is at least one alien species bending over backwards to contact us, and we are just as vigorously sticking our collective heads in the sand. I am referring to crop circles. You can't be serious, Robin After all, isn't it obvious

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
Jones sez: From: mix...@bigpond.com There is at least one alien species bending over backwards to contact us, and we are just as vigorously sticking our collective heads in the sand. I am referring to crop circles. You can't be serious, Robin After all, isn't it obvious why we are

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Jed Rothwell
mix...@bigpond.com wrote: There is at least one alien species bending over backwards to contact us, and we are just as vigorously sticking our collective heads in the sand. I am referring to crop circles. Assuming aliens create crop circles . . . the circles do not look like an attempt to

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread mixent
In reply to Jones Beene's message of Wed, 21 Jul 2010 07:45:26 -0700: Hi, [snip] You can't be serious, Robin After all, isn't it obvious why we are sticking out collective heads in the sand? These are cereal killers, for goodness sake! ROFL. Avoid them at your peril! ...or contact them

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread mixent
In reply to Jed Rothwell's message of Wed, 21 Jul 2010 14:35:14 -0400: Hi, [snip] Assuming aliens create crop circles . . . the circles do not look like an attempt to communicate with us, but rather an attempt to mystify us. Or amuse us. They resemble art, or graffiti. They are rife with

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread mixent
In reply to Steven Vincent Johnson's message of Wed, 21 Jul 2010 08:40:00 -0500: Hi, [snip] When properly executed our flawless logic is more than capable of ignoring countless similar reports, reports by police, and airline pilots. I'm always amazed at how such reports are summarily ignored

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Jed Rothwell
Robin wrote: It's obvious to me that the more complex crop circles that just appear in a single evening can't possibly have been created with common technology. There may be advanced black ops technology that is capable of it . . . I do not know much about this, but I would be cautious about

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Jones Beene
Robin wrote: It's obvious to me that the more complex crop circles that just appear in a single evening can't possibly have been created with common technology. There may be advanced black ops technology that is capable of it . . . Jed Wrote: I do not know much about this, but I would be

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Steven Vincent Johnson
Jed sez: Has anyone made a video of a crop circle forming? Yes, allegedly. Such authenticity is challenged. Personally, I suspect the majority are most likely of prosaic origin. However, that doesn't necessarily mean they all are. Roughage! Regards, Steven Vincent Johnson www.OrionWorks.com

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Steven Vincent Johnson
Jones sez: ... Plus they like our produce on K-PAX so why come early? Yup. Apple cores, banana skins and all! Roughage! ;-) Regards, Steven Vincent Johnson www.OrionWorks.com www.zazzle.com/orionworks

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Alexander Hollins
yes, like 20 years ago when they were just as intricate, and we all had gps and autocad On Wed, Jul 21, 2010 at 4:45 PM, Jones Beene jone...@pacbell.net wrote: Robin wrote: It's obvious to me that the more complex crop circles that just appear in a single evening can't possibly have been

RE: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread Steven Vincent Johnson
Jed sez: Assuming aliens create crop circles . . . the circles do not look like an attempt to communicate with us, but rather an attempt to mystify us. Or amuse us. They resemble art, or graffiti. There is no other intelligent life in the solar system, so if they are here, they are

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-21 Thread mixent
In reply to Jones Beene's message of Wed, 21 Jul 2010 16:45:01 -0700: Hi, [snip] But … lest we get too pedantically logical, there is that lingering (~1 out of 100) which we’re not all that sure about – and don’t forget that summer vacation this is also the best time for ETs to ‘visit’ since

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread Terry Blanton
On Mon, Jul 19, 2010 at 9:27 PM, Kyle Mcallister kyle_mcallis...@yahoo.com wrote: There have been hundreds of these, the most famous being the '77 WOW signal that the Big Ear picked up. I'm sure we all know that high gain antennas obtain their gain by narrowing the beamwidth of the signal.

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread Jed Rothwell
Terry Blanton wrote: If you consider that the source of the WOW signal might be the same type of narrow beam, fixed antenna. And the planet source is in the same motion as the earth. It's no surprise that you might get a brief burst of intelligence but never see it again due to the motion of

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread Jed Rothwell
I wrote: To be effective you would want to send out multiple beams from deep space, repeated for thousands of years, from an antenna orbiting the star or on the surface of an airless planet . . . Even something as elaborate as this will eventually cost a trivial amount. It seems to me that

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread francis
Jed Rothwell To be effective you would want to send out multiple beams from deep space, repeated for thousands of years, from an antenna orbiting the star or on the surface of an airless planet . . . Even something as elaborate as this will eventually cost a trivial amount. It seems to

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Tue, 7/20/10, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: If it was an interstellar communication and it happened to impinge on earth, it would have stayed pointed in our direction for a long time. Ditto for a deliberate signal to attract our attention and announce the existence of

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-20 Thread mixent
In reply to Jed Rothwell's message of Tue, 20 Jul 2010 18:41:34 -0400: Hi, [snip] So, based on this, I conclude that the galaxy is not filled with millions of intelligent species in civilizations that have lasted for hundreds of thousands or millions of years, and achieved much greater wealth

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sun, Jul 18, 2010 at 10:23 PM, mix...@bigpond.com wrote: ...two modern myths. ;) Spiraling into control: http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20727694.100-quantum-entanglement-holds-together-lifes-blueprint.html http://snipurl.com/zlv2y snip When the researchers analysed the DNA

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Sat, 7/17/10, mix...@bigpond.com mix...@bigpond.com wrote: At a distance of 1 light year, a dish with a radius of 100 m would pick up grand total of 3E-22 W from a 10 MW transmitter on Earth. I don't think there are any 10 MW transmitters, and even if there were, a signal that small

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Jed Rothwell
Kyle Mcallister wrote: it is suggested a UHF carrier could be detected at a range of 0.3 ly. If that is true, a passing probe, eavesdropping on nearby solar-type stars could get an idea that there's something near the Sun. I read a paper some time ago, by Jill Tarter I think, that suggested

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Sat, 7/17/10, mix...@bigpond.com mix...@bigpond.com wrote: To put this in perspective, in order to pick up 1 micro-Watt in total from our 10 MW transmitter, the dish would have to have a radius of 6 million km. BTW the *closest* star to Sol is 4 ly away, not one. 1uW is a lot of

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Sun, 7/18/10, mix...@bigpond.com mix...@bigpond.com wrote: I seem to recall that measurements on some supernova indicated that the neutrino burst and the x-rays arrived at the same time. IOW neutrinos don't travel faster than light. (Only tachyons do that ;^) On the one hand... In my

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Mon, 7/19/10, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: Hmmm . . . What about up-links to geosynchronous TV and telcom satellites. Or, if a civilization expands beyond one planet (but not interstellar), what about interplanetary communications? I don't have any data on hand about

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread Kyle Mcallister
V, From http://www.faqs.org/faqs/astronomy/faq/part6/section-12.html I did some calculations (assumes I did the arithmetic right) for a dish with an aperture of 10,000 meters. Such a structure could be conceivably constructed in space, using either one massive construct, or arrays of smaller

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread mixent
In reply to Terry Blanton's message of Mon, 19 Jul 2010 19:53:30 -0400: Hi, From further down in the same article:- However, Aleksei Aksimentiev of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign is sceptical that quantum effects are the sole reason for the helical structure. He points out that

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-19 Thread mixent
In reply to Kyle Mcallister's message of Mon, 19 Jul 2010 17:07:03 -0700 (PDT): Hi, [snip] it is suggested a UHF carrier could be detected at a range of 0.3 ly. 0.3 ly is effectively next door. In order to be that close, it would have to have been deliberately sent to our solar system. If they

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread Jed Rothwell
Kyle Mcallister wrote: Another I'd add to the list is, we assume they would use radio waves or optical (laser) communication (ala COSETI). Some other medium may exist, which we either cannot use effectively at the moment (neutrinos) . . . The article in Failure mentioned the possibility of

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread francis
Jed Rothwell said on Sun, 18 Jul 2010 08:13:01 -0700 Kyle Mcallister wrote: Another I'd add to the list is, we assume they would use radio waves or optical (laser) communication (ala COSETI). Some other medium may exist, which we either cannot use effectively at the moment (neutrinos) . . .

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread Jed Rothwell
Fran wrote: We are also assuming “serial” transmission. A message could be contained in a constant holographic image. . . . Indeed. And if we can come up with this list in the 21st century, imagine how many more variations an advanced civilization might think of. You might think there would be

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread mixent
In reply to Jed Rothwell's message of Sun, 18 Jul 2010 11:11:38 -0400: Hi, I seem to recall that measurements on some supernova indicated that the neutrino burst and the x-rays arrived at the same time. IOW neutrinos don't travel faster than light. (Only tachyons do that ;^) Kyle Mcallister

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sun, Jul 18, 2010 at 5:51 PM, mix...@bigpond.com wrote: I seem to recall that measurements on some supernova indicated that the neutrino burst and the x-rays arrived at the same time. IOW neutrinos don't travel faster than light. (Only tachyons do that ;^) And entanglement resolution.

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-18 Thread mixent
In reply to Terry Blanton's message of Sun, 18 Jul 2010 19:22:37 -0400: Hi, [snip] On Sun, Jul 18, 2010 at 5:51 PM, mix...@bigpond.com wrote: I seem to recall that measurements on some supernova indicated that the neutrino burst and the x-rays arrived at the same time. IOW neutrinos don't

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-17 Thread Kyle Mcallister
--- On Fri, 7/16/10, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: Jed, and all: Another I'd add to the list is, we assume they would use radio waves or optical (laser) communication (ala COSETI). Some other medium may exist, which we either cannot use effectively at the moment (neutrinos) or

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-17 Thread mixent
In reply to Kyle Mcallister's message of Sat, 17 Jul 2010 19:19:55 -0700 (PDT): Hi, [snip] TV and commercial radio broadcasts would reach out a light year or so before being 'lost.' At a distance of 1 light year, a dish with a radius of 100 m would pick up grand total of 3E-22 W from a 10 MW

Re: [Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-17 Thread mixent
In reply to mix...@bigpond.com's message of Sun, 18 Jul 2010 13:15:03 +1000: Hi, [snip] To put this in perspective, in order to pick up 1 micro-Watt in total from our 10 MW transmitter, the dish would have to have a radius of 6 million km. BTW the *closest* star to Sol is 4 ly away, not one. At

[Vo]:Somewhat OFF TOPIC Merchants of Doubt

2010-07-16 Thread Jed Rothwell
From Failure Magazine. I just love the title of this magazine! See: http://failuremag.com/index.php/feature/article/merchants_of_doubt/ Merchants of Doubt This is somewhat political, but I regard it as an antidote to the accusation that we are conspiracy theorists and the opposition is all