[zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Eric Haycraft
You cannot add 1 drive at a time to a raid-z or raid-2z. You need to add the same number of disks that were used per stripe.. So, if you start with 5 disks, you would have to add 5 more in the future to add disk space. There is also a method of swapping each disk one at a time with a larger

[zfs-discuss] Re: ZFS committed to the FreeBSD base.

2007-04-08 Thread Pawel Jakub Dawidek
On Sun, Apr 08, 2007 at 08:03:11AM +0200, Bruno Damour wrote: hello, After csup, buildworld fails for me in libumem. Is this due to zfs import ? Or my config ? Thanks for any clue, i'm dying to try your brand new zfs on amd64 !! Bruno FreeBSD vil1.ruomad.net 7.0-CURRENT FreeBSD

[zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread William D. Hathaway
One option is you can replace all the existing devices in a raidz vdev with larger devices, and then export/import the pool and the vdev will grow in size. I agree that you simply can't add a single device to grow a raidz vdev. This message posted from opensolaris.org

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Frank Cusack
On April 7, 2007 11:11:37 PM -0700 Eric Haycraft [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You cannot add 1 drive at a time to a raid-z or raid-2z. You need to add the same number of disks that were used per stripe. You cannot add drives to a raid-z or raid-z2, period. -frank

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Malachi de Ælfweald
Hmmm... I definitely missed this one... I thought the documentation said that using zpool attach would add a new drive to the existing raidz(2) and then it would start resilvering... Malachi On 4/7/07, Eric Haycraft [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You cannot add 1 drive at a time to a raid-z or

[zfs-discuss] pool resilver oddity

2007-04-08 Thread Thomas Garner
Perhaps someone on this mailing list can shed some light onto some odd zfs circumstances I encountered this weekend. I have an array of 5 400GB drives in a raidz, running on Nexenta. One of these drives showed a SMART error (HARDWARE IMPENDING FAILURE GENERAL HARD DRIVE FAILURE [asc=5d,

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Frank Cusack
[top-posting corrected] On April 8, 2007 1:43:48 PM -0700 Malachi de Ælfweald [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 4/7/07, Eric Haycraft [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You cannot add 1 drive at a time to a raid-z or raid-2z. You need to add the same number of disks that were used per stripe.. So, if you

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Malachi de Ælfweald
Yeah, I am not sure what docs I was originally looking at... Although we may want to ensure that the ZFS Admin Guide is a bit more clear on the matter: Additional disks can be added similarly to a RAID-Z configuration. Malachi On 4/8/07, Frank Cusack [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [top-posting

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Erik Trimble
Malachi de Ælfweald wrote: Hmmm... I definitely missed this one... I thought the documentation said that using zpool attach would add a new drive to the existing raidz(2) and then it would start resilvering... Malachi The man page is a little unclear. zpool attach is for adding drives to a

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Malachi de Ælfweald
Yeah, what I had been hoping (and to be honest kinda counting on) was that I could do a raidz2 across the 7x250GB drives (which is not actually going to happen since I am going to mirror 2 of them for boot) and then just add another 250GB drive when more space is needed. Realistically, I am not

[zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Eric Haycraft
Since no one seems to believe that you can expand a raidz pool, I have attached the following output from solaris 11/06 showing me doing just that. The first expanision is with like sized disks, and the second expansion is with larger disks. I realize that the documentation only has examples

[zfs-discuss] Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Erik Trimble
Eric Haycraft wrote: Since no one seems to believe that you can expand a raidz pool, I have attached the following output from solaris 11/06 showing me doing just that. The first expanision is with like sized disks, and the second expansion is with larger disks. I realize that the documentation

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Ed Gould
Eric Haycraft wrote: Since no one seems to believe that you can expand a raidz pool, I have attached the following output from solaris 11/06 showing me doing just that. The first expanision is with like sized disks, and the second expansion is with larger disks. I realize that the documentation

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Sanjeev Bagewadi
MC, If you originally had 4 * 500 GB disks configured in RAID-Z, you cannot add 1 single disk and grow the capacity of the pool (with same protection). This is not allowed. Regards, Sanjeev. MC wrote: Two conflicting answers to the same question? I guess we need someone to break the tie

Re: [zfs-discuss] Re: simple Raid-Z question

2007-04-08 Thread Manoj Joseph
Erik Trimble wrote: While expanding a zpool in the way you've show is useful, it has nowhere near the flexibility of simply adding single disks to existing RAIDZ vdevs, which was the original desire expressed. This conversation has been had several times now (take a look in the archives