[zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-22 Thread Robert Watzlavick
I've noticed something strange over the past few months with four files on my raidz. Here's the setup: OpenSolaris snv_111b ZFS Pool version 14 AMD-based server with ECC RAM. 5 ST3500630AS 500 GB SATA drives (4 active plus spare) in raidz1 The other day, I observed what appears to be undetected

Re: [zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-22 Thread Robert Watzlavick
On Oct 22, 2011, at 13:14, Edward Ned Harvey wrote: >> > How can you outrule the possibility of "something changed the file." > Intentionally, not as a form of filesystem corruption. I suppose that's possible but seems unlikely. One byte on a file changed on the disk with no corresponding chan

Re: [zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-22 Thread Robert Watzlavick
can still be applied? -Bob > On Oct 22, 2011, at 9:27 AM, Robert Watzlavick wrote: > >> I've noticed something strange over the past few months with four files on >> my raidz. Here's the setup: >> OpenSolaris snv_111b >> ZFS Pool version 14 >> AMD-b

Re: [zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-23 Thread Robert Watzlavick
On 10/22/2011 04:14 PM, Mark Sandrock wrote: Why don't you see which byte differs, and how it does? Maybe that would suggest the "failure mode". Is it the same byte data in all affected files, for instance? Mark I found something interesting with the .ppt file. Apparently, just opening a .ppt

Re: [zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-24 Thread Robert Watzlavick
On Oct 24, 2011, at 9:42, Edward Ned Harvey wrote: > > I would suggest finding a way to connect the external disks directly to the > ZFS server, and start using zfs send instead. > Since these were my offsite backups I was using Truecrypt which drove the use of ext3 and Linux. Also I wanted

Re: [zfs-discuss] File contents changed with no ZFS error

2011-10-27 Thread Robert Watzlavick
Just to close out the discussion, I wasn't able to prove any issues with ZFS. The files that were changed all seem to have plausible scenarios. I've moved my external USB drive backups over to ZFS directly connected to the file server and it's all working fine. Thanks for everyone's help! -