(wg chair hat somewhere in the corner, and nowhere near my head)

Many thanks for this clarification David.

I think in the context of use here, where the text refers to an "an  
entity, responsible for the issuance of certificates" and in  
particular a CA, meaning an "an entity, responsible for the issuance  
of certificates" "trusted by one or more users to create and assign  
public-key certificates" then the term "CA", standing for  
"certification authority" is precisely the correct term to use.

Rob, are you ok with this now?

   Geoff



On 20/09/2008, at 12:48 AM, David A. Cooper wrote:

> Geoff,
>
> Here are the definitions from X.509:
>
> X.509, Clause 3.3 (Definitions):
>
>     certification authority (CA): An authority trusted by one or  
> more users to
>     create and assign public-key certificates. Optionally the  
> certification
>     authority may create the users' keys.
>
>     authority: An entity, responsible for the issuance of  
> certificates. Two types
>     are defined in this Specification; certification authority which  
> issues public-key
>     certificates and attribute authority which issues attribute  
> certificates.
>
>     CA-certificate: A certificate for one CA issued by another CA.
>
> X.509, Clause 7 (Public-keys and public-key certificates):
>
>     An end-entity certificate is a certificate issued by a CA to a  
> subject that is
>     not an issuer of other public-key certificates.
>
>     A CA-certificate is a certificate issued by a CA to a subject  
> that is itself a
>     CA and therefore is capable of issuing public-key certificates.  
> CA-certificates
>     can be themselves categorized by the following types: [ ... self- 
> issued certificate,
>     self-signed certificate, cross-certificate].
>
>
> Dave
>
> Geoff Huston wrote:
>> Now i'm in a terminology soup too.
>>
>> I thought that it was appropriate to talk about a CA, where CA  
>> stands  for "Certification Authority", which is an entity that  
>> issues digital  certificates for use by other parties, so it was  
>> appropriate to talk  about a CA's manifest, CRLs issued by a CA and  
>> certificates issued by  a CA,
>>
>> You are proposing to use the term "CA certificate" instead.
>>
>> Now for me the "CA certificate" is not the active entity, its the  
>> "CA".
>>
>> I looked arounf in RFC5280 and did not find any use of "CA   
>> certificate" and heading off into wiki-land also found use of the  
>> term  "CA", but not "CA Certificate" as an activity entity.
>>
>> So I'll hold off on this and see if others could offer views on  
>> what  is usual here in terms of accepted terminology.
>>

_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to