On 04/10/2010, at 9:46 AM, Randy Bush wrote:

>>> 1.4.1. Certification authorities -- 2nd paragraph
>>> From: Organizations that do not distribute INRs, but hold such resources
>>>  also act as CAs when they create EE certificates.
>>> To:   Organizations that do not distribute INRs, but hold such resources
>>>  also act as CAs when they create EE certificates. Subscribers with
>>>  PI space are the principle examples of this class of CAs.
>> 
>> I'd drop this change - the distinction between PI space and otherwise
>> is poorly made here. Again. I prefer the original words,
> 
> the pa/pa distinction is irrelevant.  if i have pa space and want to
> announce it bgp, the parent still has to cut a cert for me and i still
> have to cut a roa.


agreed

> 
>> I would like to see the CP accommodate an operating practice where the
>> issued certificate has a lifetime that reflects the nature of the
>> business relationship between the INR distributor and the INR
>> recipient.
> 
> i suggest not getting into business relationships.  surely we can deal
> with expiry without crossing that line.

While it's a personal preference of mine, at the same time its not a strongly 
held personal conviction such that I'm prepared to advocate that this needs to 
be chiseled into a CP document. I can pass on this.

  Geoff

_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to