Terry, On 3/27/2012 4:22 PM, Terry Manderson wrote:
I feel like the Monday meeting was a bit of a lost opportunity. I appreciate that the presenters made effort in presenting, and making slides and presenting ideas. However I feel like the "RPKI over Bittorrent" really needed focused discussion on what the problem is, and a resulting definition of what RPKI needs in a requirements spec to address the problems that were alluded (and BTW I am more than happy to help form that set of requirements).
I see your point here. However, I am personally very grateful to Rob for his BitTorrent experiment. I believe that the choke point of the global RIR repositories is a vital challenge in RPKI deployment. I think the working group would benefit from spending significant bandwidth thinking about this challenge and I see Rob's presentation as a very reasonable way to get the ball rolling.
That is, this particular topic has been completely dormant on the mailing list in the past months. Therefore, doing any kind of concrete experiment and presenting it to the working group as a possible approach for getting around the global-repository choke-point seems like a valuable way to spur work/discussion on this topic.
- Matt Lepinski _______________________________________________ sidr mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
