Here's my take on it.
I don't like bubbling because of several reasons.
1. Typically there are about 10,000 spores and dust particles in each
cubic foot of air near the floor. That level decreases with height but
nevertheless one can see that air is NOT clean in an average room. I do
not think it wise to pump those particles through the water. I also think
that it will raise the conductivity of the water giving one the false
impression the mix is getting stronger. Stirring doesn't have this downside.
2. As Ivan stated, it also adds Co2 to the water. Stirring does not.
3. The bubblers most people opt for have tubing and diaphragms made of
some plastic which may or may not outgas into the water. Not good.
As to the other part. I tell our customers that it isn't the PPM that
counts because that's only a measure of the weight of silver. 1 PPM = 1 mg
silver. It's how many particles the silver is divided into that gives the
most efficacy. So we say, if some is good (PPM), more is not necessarily
better. I think many people fall for the idea that higher PPM is better
when the fact is, strong mixes can lead to agglomeration and less total
particles in a given measure of water. We recommend not making CS over 10
PPM so as to get a clear mix. If they want more silver particles in their
system, we tell them to drink more of the water, not try to make it
stronger. It is self defeating to keep trying for the strongest mix possible.
As to the SG6 Auto. I have done quite a bit of experimenting with
different motors and stirring speeds before settling on the motor speed we
use which was 30 RPM but is now 40 RPM (different motor). My observations
are that it only takes a very gentle movement of the water to move the
cloud away from the anode. It does not take vigorous movement. Slow
stirring accomplishes that quite easily. I have watched the dispersion for
long periods using a laser pointer to see the movement. I think vigorous
stirring can cause more agglomeration than gentle stirring. That's only an
opinion...I may be wrong. I had poor results when using a small higher
speed DC motor. Maybe others have better results.
Someone said that the generator is designed for a pint. That's sort of
true. It does work best in a pint. However it also works in much larger
vessels. It just takes longer and there is a bit of stratification if the
vessel is very deep. However, the CS disburses over a few hours. We tell
folks that there are 3 ways around this.
a. Set the dial a bit higher than you really want the end strength of the
mix to be. It will average out to the strength you desired after shut-down.
b. Wait a while for the mix to disburse and turn the generator back on to
add a bit more silver to the water.
c. Make a smaller quantity at one time and combine the fractions.
When making a half gallon at a time one has to expect to have some
differences compared to making a pint. It's not the same.
Immediately after making the CS, the PWT generally reads higher than the
next day. That's because there is more ionic silver then than after some
of the particles have become colloidal. The total amount of silver in the
water is the same. Only the ratio of ionic to colloidal has changed. The
strength hasn't decreased as some people think because the PWT only reads
ionic portions. That's why we say in our instructions that the reading
will be lower the next day.
As far as buildup on electrodes is concerned, if one insists on running in
large volumes of water and trying to make high PPM, there will obviously be
a buildup of elemental silver on the cathode. That's to be expected. It
isn't usually a problem if one is making lower PPM CS.
Hope this helps.
Trem
www.silvergen.com
At 05:47 PM 1/17/2002 -0500, you wrote:
I have the SG6-very happy with my generator.
I have done some experiementing with the way I make my CS.
I would like to compare my brew with stirring vs. bubbling and please
comments as too the differences.
I use a 64 fl. oz. coffee creamer container to make my CS.
Some days...using the stir....it seems to take longer. Not observant enough
to say why one day is different vs. another.
Here are the comparisons of the last two batches made:
--First brew:
Stirred batch.
Seeded, ppm per Hanna PWT 4ppm.
I cleaned electrodes (with heavy build up) 3 x's during the brew.
After 36 hours of generation...the ppm per Hanna was about 18ppm. Indicator
light, indicating that the brew had not reached 20pppm (as dialed) was still
on.
My stirred CS ALWAYS reads a lower number the next day, when retested. Often
I will turn the generator back on, let it run again until the indicator
light goes off.
Allowed the brew to sit overnight. A lot of precipitate in the container.
Did not bother to retest the ppm. ( I expected it to be lower than what
measured the night before)
I gave up on that brew...used it in the bathwater....
--Second brew:
Bubbled batch-stirrer removed.
Seeded DW ppm at start 4ppm.
10 hrs. later: indicator light off.
I did not clean the electrodes at all.
I shut down the generator.
Did not test the ppm.
left til this AM, testing ppm with Hanna, the ppm is 26ppm. (set at 20ppm)
Some, but little precipitate....electrodes with little build up.
My observed main points
-bubbled CS consistently more stable after brew sits (ppm's do not fall from
one day to the next)
-bubbled CS consistently has less build up on the electrodes, less
precipitate in the container.
-bubbled CS consistently able to achieve higher ppm (per Hanna)
-occassionally will get pale yellow CS with stir, never with bubbled
-consistently stirred CS will turn ashen with even minimal exposure to
light, bubbled does not seem to (I have not specifically ''tested'' this.)
-brew time for higher ppm's consistenly quicker with bubbler. (this case 36
hours for less than 20ppm stirred vs. 10 hrs. for 26ppm bubbled)
I have no clue why such a difference. I know Ole Bob you do not like the
bubbler, I believe also Trem that you prefer stir....
Could someone explain some of these differences for me...in terms I could
understand....
and if bubbling is not good, why....when it appears to make a better
product?
TIA
Connie
--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.
To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to:
[email protected] -or- [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.
To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>