On 25 June 2012 17:28, Rémi Després <[email protected]> wrote:
> > 2012-06-25 à 16:24, Wojciech Dec: > ... > > The updated MAP draft does not change the MAP architecture nor its > technical underpinnings. In fact there are no changes, bar editorial to the > normative parts of MAP, > > Having asked several times for a list of substantial evolutions from > previous MAP drafts, with their justifications, and having received no > answer, I see this statement as an indirect but first answer. > Woj> You were provided with an answer (pls see Ole's mail). > > But it doesn't seem acceptable (*): > - AFAIK, the added 5th parameter of basic mapping rules is more than > editorial > Woj> Please indicate what the new parameter in your opinion is. - I didn't find the equivalent of the following sentence in previous > drafts: "A MAP-E CE provisioned with only a Default Mapping Rule, as in the > 1:1 case, and with no IPv4 address and port range configured by other > means, MUST disable its NAT44 functionality." > Woj> Well, perhaps you would like to suggest what the CPE should do in the case the CPE is issued with a default mapping rule, ie a default route in map terms, and the absence of an assigned IPv4 address or other parameters (BMR). The above appears to be reasonable behaviour. > > => A carefully studied list of substantial changes MAP supporters have > found appropriate after the Paris meeting remains to be due. > Woj> Take it from the other people who have done implementations, technically there are no changes. -Woj. > > > something that is proven by existing implementations prior to this draft > supporting the current draft. > > Please understand that your stating that some tests (for which we don't > have detailed reports) should be considered a proof that what you say is > true, is difficult to accept. > Especially if what you say seems contradicted by a verifiable fact (see > (*) above). > > RD > >
_______________________________________________ Softwires mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/softwires
