Med, > To start with, there was no consensus to include MAP1:1 in the MAP spec. > Unless I'm mistaken, objection to include that mode in the base MAP spec was > raised several times in the mailing list. It was mainly raised by authors of > Lw4o6 but they are also contributors to softwire. > > As an editor of this document, with all due respect, you should ask the > opinion of the WG before recording the consensus into the document. The WG > owns this document and it can decide what to put on it. > > I'm personally in favour of removing MAP1:1 section from this document as > this mode can not be packaged as stateless. But, this is only my opinion.
you didn't answer my question. 1:1 mode has always been part of MAP. are we arguing over whether we should explicitly mention that fact in the MAP draft. or are we arguing over making it technically impossible to do MAP 1:1 mode? cheers, Ole >> -----Message d'origine----- >> De : Ole Troan [mailto:[email protected]] >> Envoyé : jeudi 14 février 2013 11:14 >> À : BOUCADAIR Mohamed OLNC/OLN >> Cc : [email protected]; [email protected] >> Objet : Re: [softwire] #25: Maintain or remove MAP1:1 Mode? >> >>> #25: Maintain or remove MAP1:1 Mode? >> >> OK, so here is a task for whomever thinks MAP 1:1 mode should >> be removed. >> >> - what does "remove MAP 1:1 mode mean"? >> - please suggest text changes to the mechanism that removes 1:1 mode. >> >> given that my opinion is that 1:1 mode is an unremovable part >> of MAP, the question just doesn't make sense to me. >> >> I don't want this issue to be an excuse to block a last call, >> can we quickly resolve this, and can we agree to drop it if >> there are no significant contributions within the next week? >> >> cheers, >> Ole >> >> >>> >>> The WG discussed several times this point (refer to the mailing list >>> archives). >>> >>> MAP1:1 mode is a particular mode which may re-use some of >> the provisioning >>> methods defined for MAP. >>> >>> MAP1:1 vs. Lw4o6: >>> * MAP1:1 is not fully stateless. >>> * Lw4o6 is a standalone specification which provides the >> same service as >>> MAP1:1. >>> >>> -- >>> >> -------------------------------------+------------------------- >> ------------ >>> Reporter: | Owner: >> draft-ietf-softwire- >>> [email protected] | [email protected] >>> Type: defect | Status: new >>> Priority: major | Milestone: >>> Component: map-e | Version: >>> Severity: - | Keywords: >>> >> -------------------------------------+------------------------- >> ------------ >>> >>> Ticket URL: <http://trac.tools.ietf.org/wg/softwire/trac/ticket/25> >>> softwire <http://tools.ietf.org/softwire/> >>> >> _______________________________________________ Softwires mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/softwires
