On 05/10/2008 1:03 AM, Alexander Tsvyashchenko wrote: > > Hello Peter, > >>> 1) JIDs matching: the conclusion seemd to be to use 'exactMatch' >>> attribute (?), but as you've pointed out this is the problem not only >>> for XEP-136. >> >> I added that: >> >> http://www.xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0136.html#collections-with > > Ah, sorry - it seems I missed that :-( > > Some comments then ;-) > >> If the client or server wishes to match an exact bare JID, the boolean >> 'exactmatch' attribute MUST be included and MUST be set yo "true" or >> "0" [7]. > > 1) I think there is a typo, last phrase should read as "true" or "1".
Fixed. > 2) I would not restrict it to bare JIDs: instead it seems to me more > logical to write smth similar to "if the client or server wishes to > match an exact bare JID or domain JID, Right, I'll clarify that. > the boolean 'exactmatch' > attribute MUST be included and MUST be set yo "true" or "1", thus JIDs > like example.com matching exactly example.com instead of > [EMAIL PROTECTED]/*, and JIDs like [EMAIL PROTECTED] matching exactly > [EMAIL PROTECTED] instead of [EMAIL PROTECTED]/*" - the latter one may be > important as some collections may be recorded with bare JIDs like > [EMAIL PROTECTED], so we might need to access them somehow. Yes. > 3) 'exactmatch' is currently present only in 'chat' element: however, it > doesn't look like it belongs there, as 'chat' element is in fact not > used for matching. Isn't it? It is used to specify the JID with whom you have been chatting (via the 'with' attribute). > Instead, it should belong to commands description > (such as 'remove' or 'list' elements) and in preferences (such as 'item' > element). Yes, I think <remove/> and <list/> make sense. I'm not so sure about <item/> because I don't think that is used for any wildcards. > Maybe it should be specified in some separate sub-section that > 'exactmatch' attribute may be present in every element where JID is > included and 'matching' makes sence? Maybe -- I'll look at that soon. > 4) XML Schema probably should be updated too? Yes. Peter -- Peter Saint-Andre https://stpeter.im/
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
