Hi,
Le mercredi 26 octobre 2022, 16:45:10 CEST Daniel Gultsch a écrit : > > However in practice Microblogging was not applicable in more common cases and some related features were not used > > Citation needed. I’m inclined to trust the author on that but I'm > generally curious on how and when mirco blogging didn’t work and what > features were not used. I'm curious too actually, I've quickly read this new XEP, and I'm not exactly sure about its purpose and how it differs from XEP-0277, a section explaining clearly why a new XEP is necessary and the difference from XEP-0277 would be more than welcome. Some random comments: - I really doesn't like this marketing name "PubSub Social Feed", "Microblogging over XMPP" is not great either because classic blogging is doable too, but something like "Blogging" or "Atom over XMPP" would be more appropriate IMHO. I can live with this though - if we're about to define a new XEP, we should get rid of the mandatory text version when we publish XHTML (but that would make it incompatible RFC4287, however I think it's not the best choice for XMPP use case) - XHTML-IM should not be recommended IMHO, we need real XHTML fir blogging and also to be able to make proper gateways to other protocols. Security Consideration should give precise advice on how to sanitize the content instead. - I don't think that a html alternate link SHOULD be published, the protocol should not be related to HTML, HTML rendering is just what some clients do - "pubsub#access_model" should not be set to "presence" but to "open" IMO. For privacy reason, "presence" by default may be OK though, I'm not exactly sure what is the best option here. - what is this "Gallery profile" thing ? It looks like a terrible way to do photo galleries, ignoring all the work done by stuff like XEP-0447. Please, I see no good reason to have this. - style remark: quotes (notably in section 4.1) are not following XEP-0143 guidelines Regards Goffi _______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
