Hallo Robert, hello Willem,
Am 02.01.2018 um 15:24 schrieb Robert Helling: > Hi, > >> On 2. Jan 2018, at 14:53, Stefan Fuchs <[email protected] >> <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >> >> I am personally interested in this topic so I started to play with >> your patch and this is my feedback: >> - +1 for implementing s.th <http://s.th/>. regarding ICD / IBCD >> - Ok with choosing this 5% rule of thumbs from IANTD unless someone >> clearly shows us that there is a MUCH better approach or e.g. a kind >> of 2nd/3rd/... limit we could consider additionally >> - No real idea where else we could put this code other than in the >> plannernotes.c >> Ok, this was the easy part, now the more difficult items: >> - I already expected people to give negative feedback regarding >> cluttering the UI/output - and I would have understood this. >> Always adding this additional column in the dive plan table with some >> complex info which is needed by almost nobody really doesn't look >> that nice. So we need to look for a clever solution for this. I >> already see a few options: >> x Only show this column for Tx dives (not too difficult but still it >> could happen that s.o. want's NOT to see the info) >> x Prefs option to switch it on/off (yeah, also cluttering the UI) >> x Don't print ICD info into plan/table but only show it as a tool tip >> when hovering over the gas in the plan (complex, maybe even not possible) >> > > I also like the idea of displaying the info on ICD (and I am happy to > hear that there is some sort of limit that at least some people agree on). Yeah, surprisingly already two or maybe even three people feel ok with the same solution ;-) BTW, it's the rule of "1/5", not as I accidentally wrote the rule of "5%". Honestly I didn't hear of this rule until Willem mentioned it. But I simply say "ok for me" because: - IANTD afaik is not the least important tech diving association ;-) - What I read about this rule of thumbs on the web makes sense - The results simply fit together with my knowledge of what is a OK gas combination and what is a NOT OK gas combination regarding ICD (not too difficult for me because the only two Tx bottom mix I "know" are Tx21/35 and Tx18/45 and I know that EAN50 as 1st deco gas is OK together with the Tx21/35 but NOT OK with the Tx18/45) - Implementing the "rule" itself will finally maybe even not be the most important/interesting part but showing dN2% and dHe% is much more interesting - BTW, yes, I would also print dHe% > I am not sure, the dive notes/written dive plan are the best location > for the display, though, in particular since those notes are supposed > to be printed on wet notes (and during the dive this is not relevant > information). Wouldn’t it be better to make this an event in the > profile or modify the gas change event accordingly (including the > percentage information and maybe using a different icon if the change > is above the threshold)? Yes, goes on the list of possible solutions. But also Willems latest proposal should go on the list. And then we need to fill the decision form - hopefully Dirk installed a process for this - sorry, working in a large company for too long time already... ;-) Best regards Stefan -- Stefan Fuchs E-Mail: [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
_______________________________________________ subsurface mailing list [email protected] http://lists.subsurface-divelog.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/subsurface
