Hi John et al,
I couldn't let this pass without comment :-)
!!
I'm not sure that I am in any position to "approve" the
correct terms - the BSS Sundial Glossary is just a collection of the bits of
information that I've pulled together from various sources, including much input
from the participants of this list. I have no problem with the use of
slang terms, especially when they help those poor unfortunates that aren't
sundial enthusiasts know what we're talking about. It does need care,
though, not to introduce or reinforce misapprehensions. Most of John's
terms seem to avoid this, though whether they are more easily understood than
the "scientific" term is debatable.
One term which is common and not (yet) in the Glossary is
"High noon". Is this an americanism? I have, of course, seen my
cowboy movies, but am unclear where the term originates. Is it that, with
the relatively low latitudes in the south of America, the Sun can come close to
directly overhead (altitude = 90 degrees) at noon? If so, it reinforces
the wrong view of much of the UK media that the Sun is at the "zenith" at
noon. Whilst many ordinary people think of "zenith" as the highest point
of the arc, astronomically it is defined as the point which really is directly
overhead (only expressed rather more formally!).
Another point to watch is the use of
"due north" instead of celestial pole. If you are at northerly latitudes,
the difference between celestial and geographic north can be
significant. Why not use the Pole Star as a better everyday
approximation?
"Horizon pollution" is an
interesting term. I guess we would define this as a percentage of the
daylight period when the Sun falls on a particular site. It's difficult to
come up with a mathematical definition, as it depends on the Sun's declination
as well as the positions of any obstructions. Do we know of any dials at
locations which can show the time over the full sunrise-sunset period thoughout
the year?
Regards,
John
------------------------------------------------------
|
- Sundial Slang John Carmichael
- Re: Sundial Slang John Davis
- Re: Sundial Slang John Carmichael
- Off list: High Noon (the movie!) and sundials John Pickard
- Re: Sundial Slang Mario Arnaldi
- Re: Sundial Slang John Davis
- Fw: Sundial Slang John Carmichael