On 25/09/19 00:01, Lemuel Johnson wrote:
...>
It's a bit of a pain but Chris' method works for me.

As his video shows, it does work (when it does) in the limited case that there are no "duplicate" bookmarks, although that might cover many people's requirements. However so-called duplicate bookmarks are a natural feature of organising bookmarks into folders since you might want to archive some part of the bookmark hierarchy separately.

For example, I have an Ally Bank (http://www.ally.com) bookmark in my Financial folder. If I click on the bookmark I'm redirected to https://www.ally.com and the default action for the bookmark icon in the location bar is Add Bookmark. If I edit the properties of the bookmark and change the URL to https... then click it the bookmark icon (now with a green-ish background) opens the Edit Bookmark dialog.
True, the Edit dialog will apply only to the bookmark clicked.

Matching http: and https: bookmarks for the same site isn't the problem (though it could be another problem).

The OP's question asked how to match a bookmark in the Bookmarks Manager search results to the folder containing that bookmark, since the Bookmarks Manager search results pane (out of the box) doesn't show where each bookmark is stored.

The proposed solution is to navigate using the bookmark item in the search results and identify the highlighted folder in the folder pull-down of the address bar's Edit Bookmark dialogue. One issue with this solution is that its clunkiness echoes around the world; the second is that it can't work if bookmark search returns duplicate bookmarks.

Suppose
- you have two bookmark folders, each recording sites used in a particular business activity;

- both activities use Ally Bank and therefore contain a bookmark to https://www.ally.com (which you would have if you added a bookmark after typing http://www.ally.com in the address bar);

- like the OP you are old enough to have many other such activities and corresponding bookmark folders;

= wishing to identify which activities use Ally Bank, you search for 'Ally' using Bookmarks Manager (the context of the OP's question).

Which folder should be highlighted after navigating to the Ally Bank site using each of the two bookmarks shown in the search results and opening the folder pull-down in the address bar's Edit Bookmark dialogue?

As you found with the http->https redirection, the address bar only knows about the displayed URL and not how it got there, so the dialogue has no way to select one folder or the other: I guess it shows whichever it finds first?

I would report what actually happens in such a case except that I only ever see "Other Bookmarks" highlighted, and never the user-created bookmark folder.

/df

--
London
UK
_______________________________________________
support-seamonkey mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/support-seamonkey

Reply via email to