> and list the required 'g' values for the signal sets you support. that's what I've done, but I havn't made a distinction between peri and hori
> OTOH, the main consideration for choosing ACN was that these things > will in most cases be handled by tools and code rather than by humans. I have found that the *most* error prone step is hooking up the Jack channels from my software, into AmbDec. When using hori I have to skip certain channels here and there, and its confusing as all hell, because the FuMa names dont really correspond to the N3D names I'm using. So I'll retract my comment on not caring about the channel names .. I think the most confusing thing is for the channel names to have an implied order. FuMa implies the order of the alphabet, but this order is wrong. And ANC implies its numerical order. It would be strange to have ACN channel 3 in position 2. So my preference is for the channels to have no clear implied order. I'll commit to your 0C0, 1C1, 1S1 names if you confirm they are the names you'll use in ambdec. The names with + will cause a problem when exporting to mono file names. I know you dont believe in doing that, but users will have a need. > The 'Gerzon' one puts the horizontal components before the others > for each degree. But why would you want to do that ? lets not go there :) AmbDec uses Jack and Jack has no concept of 'channel order' ... does it? ... so the order is never an issue for AmbDec. But you say you will use the ACN number for displaying matrix info? Tell you what, if you decide now, I'll go with the same channel order and channel name as you do. My preference for channel names is the 0C0 one ... Etienne _______________________________________________ Sursound mailing list [email protected] https://mail.music.vt.edu/mailman/listinfo/sursound
