Chis, > I've looked over these changes and feel that they address the WGLC comments > that were received.
I strongly disagree on several counts. First, the new document says: Transmission of syslog Messages over UDP [RFC5426] defines how to provide unreliable, non-secure datagram transport for syslog. This transport is NOT RECOMMENDED. NOT RECOMMENDED means SHOULD NOT implement. SHOULD NOT implement means DEPRECATED. There was no WG discussion of deprecating RFC 5426. In fact, in some cases, protocol security may not be needed, for a variety of reasons. In other cases, security may already be provided by, say, IPsec, required in IPv6. Saying that the work completed just last year is deprecated without any WG discussion is absurd. Rich Graveman _______________________________________________ Syslog mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/syslog
