On 25/08/2015 10:34 PM, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:
sent from a phone
Am 25.08.2015 um 03:30 schrieb Warin <[email protected]>:
e.g. bank, carpenter, post_office As the post office is called an office I
suppose it should go as office=post_office :-) The more I think of a bank the
more I think of it is an office.
craft=carpenter
bank and post office are in amenity and no need to move them (for places open
to the public). I see the office key as a back office (not open to the public
if not by appointment), so office=bank makes perfectly sense, but it is not the
same as amenity=bank
Amenity: OSM description: For describing useful and important facilities for
visitors and residents.
So;
A supermarket is an important facility for residents and visitors. Therefore it
is an amenity.
A convenience store is an important facility for residents and visitors.
Therefore it is an amenity.
Do you see where this leads .. ALL shops are amenities!
Office: OSM description: A place of business, similar to shops.
Humm more: A place predominantly selling services. These may range from the
obvious services such as accountants and lawyers.
No requirement for an appointment, offices of travel agents, estate agents,
insurance ... don't normally require an appointment.
Accountants and Lawyers are also useful and important to visitors and residents
from time to time.
So ALL offices are amenities too....
------------------------------------
The idea is to organise things - like with like.
So ALL shops should all be together under shops= (even though all shops are in
fact amenities too). Same for offices.
This reduces the amenity= values to those that are not offices nor shops.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
